That Carolina-New Orleans game was hard to watch last night. For two teams that were expected to be playoff contenders before the season they sure did provide some follies in the first half.
The comedy of errors got me to thinking about preseason prognostications. The Saints were a chic pick to win the Super Bowl by some and a favorite to win the NFC South by many others. They still might do the latter but only because the competition is so bad.
Carolina? Well, the Panthers won the division last season and went toe-to-toe with the 49ers in the playoffs. Now they look like a team that is staring down a top 10 pick in the draft next spring.
And remember the talk of a dynasty in the days and weeks following Seattle’s 43-8 victory against the Broncos in Super Bowl XLVIII. The perception of the NFC in the aftermath of the Seahawks’ blowout victory was such that Ross Tucker penned a piece for the Sporting News that suggested the conference could go on another long run of Super Bowl victories much in the same way it did from 1985 until 1997 when the NFC won 13 consecutive Super Bowl games.
That could still happen, but at the midway point of the season the AFC has been the better conference. The defending champion Seahawks are 4-3. San Francisco, which has played in the past three NFC title games, is 4-3 and battling injuries.
While the NFC South does not have a team with a winning record, 11 of the 16 teams in the AFC have winning records. The NFC has just seven of 16 over .500.
In head-to-head competition, the AFC has a 17-16-1 record against the NFC.
None of this is to suggest a team from the AFC will definitely win the Super Bowl in three months. It’s just a reminder of how quickly things can change in the NFL. One dominant performance in February hasn’t led to anything close to the NFC being superior to the AFC this season.
I played the prognostication game before the season and it was published in the P-G. For fun let’s go back and look at my preseason predictions from the P-G’s NFL preview section. Not so bad in the AFC. As for the NFC, well, I guess I was wrong about the Cowboys… and the Cardinals… and the Lions.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.