On Wednesday, we examined the Hall of Fame credentials of Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger. Today we’ll take a look at safety Troy Polamalu and compare his resume with other safeties in the hall.
The first thing you have to know is it has been 14 years since a player who played safety the majority of his career was elected to the hall of fame. That was Ronnie Lott in 2000, who played nine of his 14 seasons at safety. It has been 16 years since a player was elected to the hall of fame who played his entire career at safety. That was Paul Krause in 1998 and it took voters 14 years to elect him.
Since 2008, six defensive backs have been elected to the hall of fame and all six played cornerback for the majority of their careers. They are Rod Woodson, Deion Sanders, Aeneas Williams, Darrell Green, Dick LeBeau and Jack Butler. LeBeau and Butler were senior committee selections.
Safeties have had a harder time getting elected to the hall of fame in recent years than any other position.
There are only seven players who played strictly safety in the Hall of Fame. There are others in the hall who transitioned to safety after starting their careers at cornerback. Some, such as Lott, played safety longer than corner, so we’ll take that into consideration when we look at the numbers.
First, let’s take a look at Polamalu’s statistics through his NFL 11 seasons.
Polamalu has 32 interceptions, 12 sacks and 6 fumble recoveries. He has also has five touchdowns, three via interception returns and two via fumble returns. Polamalu has played in 146 NFL games and started 130. He has missed 30 games over his 11 seasons, an average of almost three per season. He also has made eight Pro Bowls.
Now, let’s take a look at the seven players in the hall who strictly played safety for the duration of their NFL careers:
Willie Wood – In 166 career games over 12 seasons for the Packers, Wood had 48 interceptions, 6 fumble recoveries and two defensive touchdowns, both via interception returns. Wood was an eight-time Pro Bowler.
Larry Wilson – In 169 games spanning 13 seasons for the Cardinals, Wilson had 52 interceptions, 14 fumble recoveries and 7 defensive touchdowns. Wilson was an eight-time Pro Bowler.
Elmen Tunnell – In 167 games over 14 seasons for the Giants and Packers, Tunnell had 79 interceptions, 16 fumble recoveries and 4 defensive touchdowns.
Yale Lary – In 133 games spanning 11 seasons with the Lions, Lary had 50 interceptions, 13 fumble recoveries and 3 defensive touchdowns.
Paul Krause – In 226 games spanning 16 seasons with the Redskins and Vikings, Krause had 81 interceptions, 19 fumble recoveries and 6 defensive touchdowns.
Ken Houston – In 196 games spanning 14 seasons with the Oilers and Redskins, Houston had 49 interceptions, 21 fumble recoveries and 10 defensive touchdowns.
Jack Christiansen – In 89 games spanning eight seasons with the Lions, Christiansen had 49 interceptions, 7 fumble recoveries and 3 defensive touchdowns.
Next up are the corner-safety combos.
First up is Lott, who played safety for nine of his 14 seasons after playing corner for his first four seasons and then splitting time at corner and safety in his fifth season.
Lott – 40 interceptions, 12 fumble recoveries and 1 defensive touchdown as a safety. In his first five seasons, mostly at cornerback, Lott had 23 interceptions, 5 fumble recoveries and 4 defensive touchdowns.
Next up is Mel Renfro, who played the first six seasons of his 13-year career at safety before moving to cornerback for his final seven years.
Renfro – Renfro had 31 interceptions, 5 fumble recoveries and 2 defensive touchdowns as a safety. He had had 21 interceptions, 6 fumble recoveries and 1 touchdown as a cornerback.
We are not including Woodson, who only played safety for five of his 17 seasons in the league. We also are not including Williams, who played safety for only two of his 14 seasons in the league. Williams was elected this year and will be enshrined next month.
Lastly, let’s take a look at Ed Reed, the modern-day safety Polamalu is compared to the most and someone who will merit strong consideration for the Hall of Fame when he retires. Reed has been a safety for his entire career.
Reed has started 169 of his 174 NFL games. He has 64 interceptions, 13 fumble recoveries and 9 defensive touchdowns.
Polamalu falls well short of Reed when it comes to the statistics. Reed has twice as many interceptions and almost twice as many defensive touchdowns. Reed came into the NFL in 2002; Polamalu in 2003.
No doubt, Polamalu’s injury history has something to do with his stats. And that certainly will work against him when it comes time to consider him for the hall.
When it comes to comparing Polamalu against true safeties already in the Hall of Fame once again Polamalu falls short statistically. It’s extremely difficult to compare eras especially when the game was so different in the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s, when all of those seven safeties played.
Polamalu supporters will champion his candidacy because he played the position in a different manner than anyone else ever had. He was excellent in run support. He could blitz. He could disrupt from anywhere on the field.
All of that will boost his candidacy. But examining his stats and acknowledging voters have had a hard time quantifying the value of safeties in the recent past it’s hard to gauge Polamalu’s chances right now. He’s got a shot, but he’ll have to overcome some obstacles to get there.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.