The 2014 Hall of Fame class will be enshrined in Canton, Ohio in a month. A couple of current Steelers will be considered for induction when their playing careers end. Strong consideration will be given to safety Troy Polamalu and quarterback Ben Roethlisberger.

Last month the NFL Network debated whether Roethlisberger is Hall of Fame worthy. Rod Woodson and Warren Sapp, two Hall of Fame players, were in-studio analysts for this show and both said Roethlisberger had not yet done enough to warrant Hall of Fame consideration.

Sapp’s reasoning was Roethlisberger had not been one of the best quarterbacks of his era.

“Are you considered the best the NFL has to offer?” Sapp asked.

Advertise with us

When compared to Tom Brady or Peyton Manning, Roethlisberger will come up short in almost every measure. Brady and Manning will go down as two of the best to ever play the position. They played the majority of their careers in passing offenses tailored to their talents while Roethlisberger played his early years on a running team.

That begs the question: Should Roethlisberger be penalized for playing in an era when two of the all-time greats also played?

Regardless, there are many quarterbacks enshrined in the Hall of Fame who were not one of the best quarterbacks of their era.

Does anyone believe Warren Moon was on the same level as Joe Montana, Dan Marino or John Elway?

If you do, your football watching privileges should be revoked.

Advertise with us

Moon twice led the league in passing, but he played in the run and shoot offense. He never led his team to a Super Bowl.

How about Jim Kelly? He also played in the same era but was a notch below Montana, Marino and Elway.

How about Sonny Jurgensen? Was he “the best the NFL had to offer” in his era?

Or Bob Griese?

Or Len Dawson?

Advertise with us

Woodson did not believe Roethlisberger had the credentials either. Woodson likened Roethlisberger to Jim Plunkett, who won two Super Bowls for the Raiders, but is not in the Hall of Fame.

The number of Super Bowls might be the only thing Plunkett and Roethlisberger have in common. Plunkett had a 72-72 record in the regular season and an 8-2 record in the postseason. Roethlisberger has him by 23 wins in the regular season and two in the postseason in five fewer seasons.

The passing stats are not close either. Plunkett passed for 25,882 yards in 15 seasons. Roethlisberger has 34,105 in 10 seasons. Roethlisberger has 219 career touchdown passes and 122 interceptions; Plunkett had 164 touchdowns and 198 interceptions.

Hall of Fame players don’t vote on who gets in the Hall of Fame anyway. Professional football writers do. There are no specific criteria for quarterbacks or any other position for enshrinement.

But quarterbacks are judged on their statistics as well as their ability to lead their team to victories, especially in the playoffs.

Advertise with us

Roethlisberger has compiled some impressive statistics and his winning percentage in the regular season and the playoffs rank among the best of all-time. He has been to three Super Bowls and won two of them. He has a superb 10-4 playoff record (.714) and is 95-47 in the regular season entering his 11th season.

If Roethlisberger retired today his regular-season winning percentage would rank fourth among the 23 quarterbacks who are in the Hall of Fame.

Here is a list of the Hall of Fame quarterbacks and their regular-season winning percentages:

Troy Aikman .569 (94-71)

*George Blanda .541 (53-50-1)

Advertise with us

Terry Bradshaw .667 (107-51)

Len Dawson .662 (94-57-8)

John Elway .643 (148-82-1)

Dan Fouts (.505) (86-84-1)

Otto Graham .814 (57-13-1)

Advertise with us

Bob Griese .621 (92-56-3)

Sonny Jurgensen (.485) 69-73-7

Jim Kelly .631 (101-59)

Bobby Layne .610 (80-51-4)

Dan Marino .621 (147-93)

Advertise with us

Joe Montana .713 (117-47)

Warren Moon .502 (102-101)

Joe Namath .496 (62-63-4)

Bart Starr .622 (94-57-6)

Roger Staubach .745 (85-29)

Advertise with us

Fran Tarkenton .556 (124-109-6)

Y.A. Titte .600 (78-52-5)

Johnny Unitas .648 (118-64-4)

Norm Van Brocklin .554 (61-46-4)

*Bob Waterfield .663 (14-8)

Advertise with us

Steve Young .657 (94-49)

*Blanda was elected to the Hall for a combination of their quarterbacking and kicking skills and the record for Waterfield, who played from 1945-52, appears to be incomplete.

Source: Pro Football Reference

Roethlisberger’s playoff winning percentage is just as impressive when compared to the other Hall of Fame quarterbacks.

The 2005 and 2008 Super Bowl teams were built around defense. Sapp even noted how Roethlisberger’s performance in Super Bowl XL ranked as one of the worst ever for a Super Bowl-winning quarterback, which is true.

Advertise with us

But Roethlisberger’s role on the Super Bowl XL team should not be underestimated. It was Roethlisberger who threw early and often in playoff victories against the Colts and Broncos when the Steelers jumped out to big early leads on the road. And it was Roethlisberger who bailed out the defense after Larry Fitzgerald’s late touchdown in Super Bowl XLIII against the Cardinals.

Roethlisberger is 32 and can likely play for another five years or more. His resume will change. He has time to improve his chances and time to diminish them should he struggle.

But as long as winning percentage in the regular season and in the playoffs continues to be part of the equation Roethlisberger is in some elite company and in very good position to one day land in Canton.

Here is how Roethlisberger measures up (in terms of winning) against the four current quarterbacks who are most often mentioned as potential Hall of Famers:

Tom Brady has a 148-43 record (.778) and is 18-8 in the playoffs with a 3-2 record in Super Bowls.

Advertise with us

Peyton Manning has a 167-73 record (.695) and is 11-12 in the playoffs with a 1-2 record in Super Bowls.

Drew Brees has a 110-75 record (.594) and is 6-5 in the playoffs with a 1-0 record in Super Bowls.

Aaron Rodgers has a 58-29 record (.666) and is 5-3 in the playoffs with a 1-0 record in Super Bowls.