One need not look far to find out how dangerous it is to draft a quarterback in the first round of the NFL draft. Sure, there are the can’t-miss-prospects such as Eli Manning, Phillip Rivers and Ben Roethlisberger from the 2004 draft class. At least one of them someday might have their bust in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
More recently, first-round quarterbacks are more likely to be labeled as busts because they fail.
I was reminded of this when I turned on the NFL Network this morning because one of the first-round failures was staring me in the face.
On the set to offer his advice and his opinion on this year’s quarterback class was Matt Leinart, the No. 10 overall pick in the 2006 draft. Leinart started 18 games in his six-year career. He did not play last season and at 30 appears to be transitioning to his post-football career. He is not alone.
Teams desperate for quarterbacks are always reaching to get the player who is going to turn their franchise around. Drafted seven spots before Leinart in 2006 was Vince Young, with the No. 3 overall pick. Young struggled mightily and like Leinart is one the outside looking in less than a decade after he was the face of a franchise.
In 2007, it was JaMarcus Russell taken No. 1 overall. He too is out football. The other quarterback taken in the first round that year was Brady Quinn, who is on his fifth NFL team.
The next season was better for quarterbacks in the first round. Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco were the only first-round quarterbacks and they’re very good. Flacco has a Super Bowl ring.
In 2009, Matt Stafford, Mark Sanchez and Josh Freeman were first-round picks. Sanchez and Freeman are reserves and Stafford, for all of his regular season success, has never won a playoff game.
In 2010, it was Sam Bradford and Tim Tebow, who is out of the NFL. Bradford remains a starter, but there are rumblings the Rams might be in the market in this draft to take his replacement already. It’s only been four years since they invested the No. 1 overall pick in him.
Sure, Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III came around in 2012, but recent history suggests quarterbacks taken in the first round will fail more often than they succeed.
Three or four quarterbacks can be taken in the first round Thursday night when the NFL draft gets underway. In the past week, there has been talk that all three could slide down to late in the first round or fall completely out to the second. Could NFL general managers finally be coming around to the idea that reaching for a quarterback is detrimental to your team?
That would be bad news for the Steelers and other teams drafting in the middle of the first round. The Steelers are hoping to land an impact receiver or cornerback, but if quarterbacks fall their top targets could be off the board by the time it’s their turn.
The Steelers are hoping the time honored of franchises reaching for their next quarterback continues. The past decade suggests at least two teams will take a quarterback in the first round.
Unfortunately for them, the odds are better they’ll be a TV personality by the time they’re 30 rather than quarterbacking the team that drafted them.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.