The Pro Football Hall of Fame announced its finalists for enshrinement last night and one of them got me to thinking about their candidacy. Tony Dungy is among the finalists and will find out Feb. 1 if he will be inducted.

I like Dungy as a coach and as a man. However, I’m not sure he belongs in the Hall of Fame, especially before some others who are still waiting to be enshrined.

So let’s play a game this morning. I’ll give you six blind resumes of NFL head coaches past and present. Based on the criteria of regular-season record, playoff record and number of Super Bowl victories, you tell me which deserve to be in the Hall of Fame. Hint: Only one is in the Hall of Fame.

Don’t peek. The corresponding names will be at the bottom. Post your comments below.

Advertise with us

1. 82-45 regular season record (.646), 6-5 playoff record, 1 Super Bowl win

2. 80-64 regular season record (.556), 9-4 playoff record, 2 Super Bowl wins

3. 140-90-1, regular season record (.623), 12-9 playoff record, 1 Super Bowl win

4. 143-112 regular season record (.561), 11-8 playoff record, 0 Super Bowl wins

5. 70-36 regular season record (.660), 6-3 playoff record, 1 Super Bowl win

Advertise with us

6. 139-69 regular season record (.668), 9-10 playoff record, 1 Super Bowl win

1. Mike McCarthy

2. Jimmy Johnson

3. Bill Cowher

4. Marv Levy

Advertise with us

5. Sean Payton

6. Tony Dungy

*Levy was enshrined in 2001 and is the only coach on this list without a Super Bowl win.