The problems with the Steelers defense in 2013 – lack of run defense, yielding too many big plays – will have to be rectified next season if the Steelers want to contend for the AFC North title.
And those will be the two biggest areas addressed by defensive coordinator Dick LeBeau and his staff during the offseason.
But what or who is to blame? Was it the fault of the defensive schemes used by LeBeau, the same schemes that have been wildly successful for so many years? Or the fault of the players in those schemes?
Mostly, it was the players in those schemes, and here’s why:
The biggest problem with the run defense was the inability to shut down the inside, and that was largely due to the loss of Casey Hampton and the injury to Larry Foote.
The Steelers gave Steve McLendon a $7.5 million contract last season to remain with the team, even though he had never started a game. That money would suggest they expected McLendon to be a capable replacement for Hampton, and he was not.
It is unfair, of course, to expect McLendon to be Hampton, a five-time Pro Bowler. He does not have his instincts or his knowledge to know when to expect the run, nor does he play with the same stay-at-home style that eats up blockers and creates space for the linebackers to run to the ball. He plays more of a one-gap style and often runs himself out of plays.
This is not to suggest that McLendon is not a good player. It just might be that he is a better fit, with his style, at defensive end rather than nose tackle. Or, it just might be that he needed a year of experience to learn the nuances of the position and will be much improved in 2014. Still, it is something the Steelers need to figure out in the offseason.
After outside linebacker, nose tackle is the most important position in the Steelers’ 3-4 defense. What they do in the draft, or even free agency, will speak to whatever urgency the Steelers feel they have at that position.
A possible solution is Al Woods, who had to fill in at nose tackle when McLendon was hurt and actually played very well. If Brett Keisel is not re-signed, and Ziggy Hood leaves in free agency, the Steelers could move McLendon to end and use Woods in the middle.
The problem with that, though, is much the same: Instead of just one position, the Steelers would be relying on two players at new positions and keeping their fingers crossed they can handle the responsibility.
That is no way to improve on a run defense that ranked 21st in the league and allowed an average of 4.4 yards per carry. That is why I expect the Steelers to re-sign Hood, a former No. 1 draft choice, provided he doesn’t receive some outrageous offer in free agency (which I doubt).
Of course, that means they would be using the same people and expecting a different result.
Isn’t that the loose definition of insanity?




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.