Poll Question: Where will the Steelers draft in 2014? 1-5 (54%) 6-10 (32%) 11-15 (14%) 16 or lower (0%)
Jim: At times I thought Vince Williams looked pretty good last night. Is he a possible long term starter?
Ray Fittipaldo: I guess the coaches thought so, too. I haven't seen the snap breakdown, but it appeared he played 80 percent of the snaps. We didn;t see too much of Kion Wilson. That's interesting because on Thursday Dick LeBeau said they were pretty even and he thought they would split time again. Perhaps WIlson did not play well early and that led to Williams being in the game more. I am sure Tomlin will address this and many other topics tomorrow at his news conference.
Bill: Any chances the tackles improve?
Ray Fittipaldo: I suppose there is hope, but what happened Sunday night proves Mike Tomlin is running out of patience and that's all that really matters. I wrote a detailed post on the blog about the problem the Steelers are facing with the offensive line and the number of high picks that are invested there. If they don't improve the team could be in for a long rebuilding process. A lot of time and money has been invested in Marcus Gilbert and Mike Adams and neither appears capable of holding down a starting job. You almost never see a coach rotating players in and out of the game in the manner Tomlin did Sunday night. If that does not sound alarm bells about this line nothing will.
Ricky from CA: Where do we go from here? If turnovers are curbed do we see enough offense to win games? Can Ryan Clark get out of his funk of bad play or is he at the age where he has just slipped? What do you do with the ever chaging O-Line? Thanks again for your chats!
Ray Fittipaldo: They can't find ways to win these types of games. The Steelers won the Super Bowl in '08 and went in '10, but people tend to forget sometimes how those teams struggled at times. What made those teams special was how they won as a team. If the offense played poorly the defense picked it up. If the defense played poorly the offense would find a way to make a play. None of that is happening now. As for Clark, he did not have a good game last night and he blew a coverage vs. the Bengals. But I don't view him as a major problem with this team. About the O-line, I would not be surprised if Beachum is in there more this week for one or the other, Gilbert or Adams.
Jim: When you basically have four rookie lineman starting is it really that big of a surprise they are struggling?
Ray Fittipaldo: Total misconception about the offensive line. Gilbert is in his third year, Adams and DeCastro their second. Foster is a five-year vet. Velasco is in his fourth or fifth year. There are plenty of teams around the league plugging rookies and second-year players into their line and not having the problems the Steelers are having. I wish people would get off that thing about how it takes time for linemen to develop. Yes, it does to a certain point, but it's naive to think the Steelers are the only team in the league playing with younger players. It's simply not true.
Derrick: I don't see Haley being fired this week because of the long travel week. Regardless of a win or loss, is he gone during bye week? If he is who is the most likely candidate to replace?
Ray Fittipaldo: I never say never, but I don't think the Rooneys operate that way. They have never been shy about making coaching changes after a season, but it's rare that it happens during a season.
George: A year like this was bound to happen. The steelers have had a lot of success the past ten years or so and with that comes lower draft picks and higher salaries which limits your salary cap flexibility. Isn't fair to say this is a rebuilding year?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers have refused to say that, but the more the losing happens the more it's looking like they are in a rebuilding mode. And when that happens there is no reason to bring back older players who might have a year or two left. So a losing season almost assures guys like Brett Keisel and Ryan Clark, even if they play well, won't be brought back. At some point you have to get younger and point toward the future. The Steelers always believe they have a shot, but a bad season can change that outlook.
Bill: I read your pg plus article today and it makes a lot of sense. One thing I believe they may need to look at his nose tackle right? I'm not sure Mcclendon is the answer and a draft pick may be needed for that position along with wide receiver, tackle, linebacker right?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good point, Bill. McLendon is not as big as Casey Hampton and although he's far from their biggest worry teams have been running with more success on the Steelers than recent years. Why is that? Well, McLendon is really the only new player along the line. Keisel and Hood have been starters for years and Heyward has been a reserve. Woodley has been a longtime starter. The only other new starter in the front seven is Jarvis Jones. But I don't want to blame McLendon or the somewhat more leaky run defense for this team's problems. In the grand scheme of things there are bigger problems to fix.
Kathy: Maybe Todd Haley could learn something from Chip Kelly if there are 8 people in the box or more, we may need to pass the ball? if there are 7 or less in the box we can run? Why did Haley call a play that sent Felix Jones into an 8 man Box? result fumble, same play Issac Redman had? result fumble?
Ray Fittipaldo: You mean the same Chip Kelly, who is 1-2. And believe me Kelly didn't invent checking out plays at the line of scrimmage. QBs for years have been getting out of bad plays when eight men are near the LOS. Haley deserves some criticism for the ways things have unfolded. There is not a lot of rhythm or continuity with his offense, but it still compiled 459 yards last night. They are moving the ball, but they have to cut out the turnovers and start scoring touchdowns in the red zone. That would solve a lot of their problems.
JAXMAN: How can everyone be so lousy on the O-line? Someone is doing a poor job on evaluating talent. Colbert will probably lose his job over this. The Rooney's have to be very upset. Your take?
Ray Fittipaldo: As I mentioned earlier I wrote a long blog post on the offensive line that I encourage everyone to read if they have not. Basically, it points out how if the high draft picks fail it will have a domino effect on the rest of the roster. Sure, the scouts deserve blame if they are busts. Sure, the coaches deserve blame for not developing talent. And sure, the players deserve blame for not living up to the hype. It's all connected. When a team is 0-3 no one escapes criticism. That's just the way it is.
Jim: I think someone mentioned on one of the morning shows yesterday that Sanders could be traded if they kept losing. Is that really a possibility?
Ray Fittipaldo: I believe I read a tweet from Jason LaConfora from CBS who predicted that might happen. If you think about it, it owuld make sense for the Steelers to try to get something for Sanders if they're not going to make the playoffs. But it also must make sense for the Patriots to want to make that trade. What would Bill Belichick give up for a player he can sign in free agency in a few months anyway? The Steelers might be able to get a fourth- or fifth-round pick if the Patriots are desperate. I think you're dreaming if you think the Steelers get anything more than that for Sanders.
Bill: Paulson doesn't seem to be capable of blocking and really isn't a great receiver so why not play Moye? He did have a touchdown last week.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah, I was kind of surprised Moye did not dress. Looking back, with their struggles in the red zone all night maybe he could have helped. But Moye's problem is he does not have a large role on special teams, so you're basically dressing him with the idea that he might, if things go well for the offense, play 8-10 snaps a game. For a team that struggles on offense and needs its specials teams to perform the coaches might have thought a helmet went to a player capable of making a difference in the kicking game. And let's give credit where credit is due. If there was one silver lining to Sunday night it was the play of the special teams, especially its ability to limit Devin Hester, the best kick returner in the league.
John in Ohio: Any chance Steelers move Adams to RT (okay there last year) and find a free agent LT during bye week? I would hope if they play lousy again in London, it is time for a change of sorts - your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin said last night he would leave no stone unturned in his preparation for fielding a winning team. The first crack went to Kelvin Beachum. Without watching the game film, it's hard to determine how well he played. If Beachum is not the answer then he could try something else. But remember this team is up against the salary cap and it would be almost impossible to cut a veteran making around a million a year to bring in another veteran who would make just as much pro-rated.
Tom: How people say Haley is the problem is beyond me! That is pure Cleveland Browns thinking. Lets change the coach and maybe our players will magically be better. Haley has done everything people wanted...numerous deep balls, awesome fake wr screen plays, end around. Players are turning the ball over and passes are not being completed to open receivers What am I missing that this is Haleys fault?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not absolving Haley of blame, but he was low on the blame list Sunday night. It starts with the five turnovers and the QB who basically handed the other team three scores.
guest: Ray, Are you going to London? Great city.
Ray Fittipaldo: Ed, Gerry and Gene are going. I'll be covering the team here on Thursday when those guys are traveling.
John in Ohio: It looks more and more like Redman should have been cut originally instead of Dwyer. Are coaches still on the Redman bandwagon?
Ray Fittipaldo: It does not appear so. Redman barely played last night. What did he play, four or five snaps? They went with Felix Jones for a while before he fumbled and then turned to Dwyer. Wait a minute. Where have we seen this before? Oh yes, last year. I don't know what to expect from Le'Veon Bell, but it would be nice if the coaching staff could find someone they feel like they can rely on.
John in Ohio: If you were in charge - what would you do to try and fix the Steelers?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'd got to Mass every day and pray like heck the offensive line can improve.
Tom: The last few games everyone has said they have a shot of winning each game as long as Ben is playing. Since he has come back from his injury Ben hasn't been nearly as accurate or careful with the ball. Maybe people should criticize Haley less and let him reign Ben in. I trust Haley's system much more than I do Ben passing 40-50 times a game. Ben is great, but not able to carry the team right now ... your opinion?
Ray Fittipaldo: You make a fair point. Ben definitely has not taken care of the ball since he returned from his injury. Not sure if the injury has anything to do with that, though. Think back to the Bengals game at Heinz Field last December. The winner would move on to the playoffs and the loser would not. Ben gets the ball back with a chance to win the game and instead he throws an INT to set up the winning FG for the Bengals. I still think he has a lot left in the tank and wold improve greatly if he had some semblance of a running game and/or pass protection. It's amazing how many of his big passes down the field last night were after he had had to scramble in the pocket and elude pressure. He still has that knack. He just has to cut down on the turnovers.
Mike: Ray, I've been doing that for 3 years now and it's not working and I go to St. Vincent in Latrobe on top of it!
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe go twice a day.
Bill: What record did you have the Steelers going this year
Ray Fittipaldo: I said 9-7. Not feeling very confident in my prognostication skills right about now.
JamesinNYC: Since it looks like a top ten pick for the Steelers this year what one position would give them the biggest bang for their buck? OT?
Ray Fittipaldo: It would really be a kick in the gut if they felt necessary to draft an offensive tackle in the first round after taking two guys in the second round in 2011 and 2012. This team could use a big receiver. It also can use an inside linebacker, a safety, a tight end for the future. Depressed yet?
Guest: It has been said on the PG+ sound off that there are reports in Pittsburgh that everyone including Colbert, Tomlin, Haley, LeBeau, etc are being evaluated currently by Art based on this poor start. True or false? If true please expand.
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm sure everyone is being evaluated. That's how professional sports work. But if you are inferring that change will be made in-season I am skeptical.
Guest: Any chance Ben stands up for team needs in his extension negotiation or does he continue to try to be the good politically correct employee?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not understanding your question.
Guest: Why is Isaac Redman active ahead of Moye on game day? There is proof on tape that Moye can be more valuable to the team.
Ray Fittipaldo: I supposed running backs are more likely to sustain an injury in a game, so dressing a third running back might make more sense than dressing a fifth receiver. I wouldn't read anything more into it than that. Just because Moye did not dress for one game does not mean the coaches are down on him. Sometimes it can simply come down to whether a guy can make a difference on special teams.
Guest: How is Heath's knee today?
Ray Fittipaldo: Players are not available today. We get them on Wednesdays, Thursdays and Fridays.
Guest: What benefits will the veterans take away from rookies this week?
Ray Fittipaldo: Any guys three years and under in the league will not be allowed to use the shower facilities.
Jesse: Ray, if LeBeau ends up retiring at the end of the year, who is waiting in the wings? Butler? Lake?
Ray Fittipaldo: Keith Butler has not been promised anything, but I think it is assumed he is the next in line.
Guest: Does Bell play next Sunday? What should we expect from him given the oline situation?
Ray Fittipaldo: Bell made a lot of unexpected progress last week, so yes it is a possibility for him to play. But as point out, how much of a difference can a running back make when there are no holes to run through?
Mike: This is just me thinking but while the responsibility for the poor start is something that should be shared by everyone, I really think more of the blame/burden should be directed to Colbert & the scouting department. They're putting the players on the field for Tomlin & the coaches to work with. It seem that there is too much finger pointing at the coaching staff and not enough toward the people responsible for the makeup of the team. I know Tomlin has say so, but doesn't the final decision come from Colbert?
Ray Fittipaldo: Everyone gets their fair share of the blame when things go bad. I don't think anyone is giving Colbert and is scouts a free pass.
Jason: It's clear that the offensive line lacks both confidence and aggressiveness. Case in point, Mike Adams barely touched Julius Peppers last night and offered little more than a traffic cone to run around. DeCastro looks tentative and the Steelers lineman in general seem to lose the one-on-one battles. It doesn't seem to be a matter of scheme. What, if anything, can be done with the limited depth we already have on the O-line? Outside of Kelvin Beachum, nobody seems to be pushing any of the starters for playing time
Ray Fittipaldo: Beachum is pushing both tackles, but after him, you are right. There aren't many other options. I don't think they have any plans of playing Guy Whimper. If they do, you'll know the team is in real trouble. Well, they're already there, but you know what I mean.
Mile Hi Stiller: Is it Starks time to called back
Ray Fittipaldo: Starks, I believe, signed with the St. Louis Rams last week.
JamesinNYC: Thanks for depressing me more haha ... but top 10 you don't pick ILB or TE. I have seen draft boards give them a WR. Safety I could see. If they really bombed and could pick a top QB would they do it or trade down for multiple picks? Guess that is a dream scenario?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would not draft a QB. If things are settled around him he can be an effective player for another four or five years.
Tom: It is easy for us fans to look at all the bad since we are used to winning. As a guest said earlier, this is how the NFL is designed to work, good teams get back and bad teams get good (Excluding the Browns of course). I think a year with a top pick or two will put us back in contention quickly. We haven't been blown out but rather shot ourselves in the foot with untimely mistakes. The D is still superb and many young guys are playing well. Do you see this team as a lot of talent that just needs experience?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would hesitate to call the defense superb. It has zero turnovers in three games and just three sacks. Those game-changing plays from previous years are not there anymore. I think this team needs an infusion of talent at a number of positions as I pointed out earlier.
Tom: Moye, Moye, Moye....last week it was Wheaton, Wheaton, Wheaton. Rookies won't be the answer. Wheaton had two mathcups man to man on lb's and didn't produce. When will people learn that changing coaches and playing rookies isn't a solution? Experience and continuity is everything in the NFL.
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with one thing. If we're hung up on Moye being a savior then we're all missing the big picture. I simply said I was surprised he did not dress because he made a big play for a struggling offense the week prior.
Richy: Spence is not coming back, OT are not quick enough and it appears DeCastro is not strong enough. Next up?
Ray Fittipaldo: You're probably right about Spence. You might be right about the tackles. I have not been encouraged by DeCastro, but he might deserve a little more rope than the others because he missed two-thirds of his rookie season to a pretty bad knee injury.
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for the questions this week. We'll do it again next week at the same time. Have a good week.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.