Ray Fittipaldo: Good afternoon. Please post your questions and we'll get started a little early. Bonus chat time to dissect the loss!
jimbo: Ray,WTF happened yesterday?!
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not sure the Steelers win if Emmanuel Sanders catches that deep pass on the first play from scrimmage, or if Isaac Redman doesn't fumble, but I am convinced it would have been a different game with a 9-0 lead. Ryan Clark pointed out afterward that getting down would have meant the Titans could not have protected Jake Locker the way they did by running so much. They were able to do that because the offense was so inept. Yes, the injuries played a role, but the running game was off to a wretched start even with Pouncey in the game. There is a lot wrong with this team and plenty has to be fixed before the game at the Bengals Monday night on -- gasp -- national television.
Zed: Will Haley be fired during or after the season?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Rooneys rarely take such action during a season. If you remember, in 1989, the Steelers lost the first two games by the score of 92-10 under the direction of new offensive coordinator Joe Walton. That team got its act together, made the playoffs, beat Houston in a wild card game and almost went to Denver and beat John Elway in a divisional round game. I'm certainly not predicting the playoffs for this team after the way it played yesterday, but I do want to point out how things can change quickly in the NFL. It was one very bad game. There are problems, but there are 15 games to go. I will say even though the Rooney are not quick to pull the trigger on firings during the season they have no problem shaking things up after a season. So yes, Haley is coaching for his job. I cannot see the ownership signing off on two seasons of this during the prime of Big Ben's career.
Tim: I'm just letting you know that I'm quitting following the team. Yesterday I took my new girlfriend to the game. The team was so bad that my girlfriend lost all respect for me and now she wants to "see other people." I'm so burned up.
Ray Fittipaldo: Bad choice for a Sunday afternoon date.
Ralph: Is Kion Wilson up to the task of replacing Foote? Who will make the calls on D now? Timmons?
Ray Fittipaldo: The coaches will work that out early this week. Kion WIlson dressed for the game and took Foote's place after he was injured. Wilson has limited NFL experience and was not on a roster last season. Vince Williams, a sixth-round pick out of Florida State, also is on the roster. He did not dress for the Titans game. I am guessing one of them will start this week unless they go sign a veteran off the street. Either way, it's not a rosy scenario for a defense that on the whole played pretty well in the opener.
Arians: When will the Steelers place value on adding offensive talent in the draft?
Ray Fittipaldo: They drafted Maurkice Pouncey in the first round in 2010. They took David DeCastro in the first round last season and they spent second-round picks on Marcus Gilbert ('11) and Mike Adams (last year). They tried desperately to upgrade the line through the draft. Pouncey has been a Pro Bowler, but the other guys are still trying to find their way. The poor performance of the running game and the leaky pass protection only added to the concerns that are out there about the O-line. Now without Pouncey, and if Kelvin Beachum starts in his place, your best depth player is now a starter. Tough blow yesterday with Pouncey going down.
Ryan: Has the "Steeler Way" gotten old? Or is this just a team with to many holes?
Ray Fittipaldo: The "Steeler Way" produced Super Bowl wins in 2005 and 2008 and another appearance in the game in 2010. Not every team can stay on the top forever. The franchise was going to go through a down period again at some point just as it did from 1998-2000. The trick is not going through an extended period of losing. I'm not saying this will definitely be a lost year, but no one should be surprised if it is. It happens to almost every team in the league.
Al B: Why does Tomlin/Haley insist on rotating the RBs in and out? Redman himself said that he thinks this hurts his ability to get in a groove and it sure looks like he's right!
Ray Fittipaldo: Did you want Redman in the game after fumbling twice in the first half? I believe Redman had a point when he told me that last week, but he has to earn his keep. No coach in their right mind would keep a player in there after the way Redman fumbled and ran. He had something like minus-6 yards on his first four carries. I'm more interested in why Felix Jones did not replace him. Haley and Tomlin went with Larod Stepehsn Howling instead. Jones dressed but barely played at all. That was interesting. If he wasn't up to speed with the offense, then dress someone esle who could help on special teams.
Fake_Jamesh: Ray, do you agree if perhaps TE Heath Miller played yesterday, we would've won by 3 pts and things would not have been Apocalyptic.
Ray Fittipaldo: Miller means a lot to this team, but he cannot catch every pass or make every block. And he certainly cannot help that much in pass protection. As Chuck Noll once said of Sidney Thornton. And I'm paraphrasing here: This team has problems and they are many.
Arians: Why does every other team in the league place value on big targets for their QBs while Colbert gets nothing but 5'10 WRs and slow RBs
Ray Fittipaldo: Derek Moye is 6-5, made the 53-man roster and dressed for the game. However, he barely played. I thought they would at least throw one or two up for him in the end zone near the end of the game. I agree with the premise of your statement. The Steelers have a lot of the same types of receivers. The worst part of it is Antonio Brown is the only proven NFL player among them.
Guest: The Steelers have an obvious mess at RB, TE and O-Line. What do they address first?
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, they added Jonathan Dwyer this morning. He'll help with the depth until Le'Veon Bell returns. I'm not sure how much quality help is out there for the offensive line. Most of the good players are playing for the other 31 franchises. As for the tight end situation, you just have to hope Heath Miller returns sooner rather than later.
Fake_Jamesh: Ray: They kept saying OL needs time to gel? How long is it gonna take? Concensus, Mike Adams and Gilbert are not starter material.
Ray Fittipaldo: If the coaches came to that conclusion now it's too late because their top backup is now most likely the starting center. They're going to have to let them learn on the job.
Clark: Will the team sign another offensive lineman to help now that Pouncey is out?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, they'll add another offensive lineman. Whether that's a starter-caliber player or merely a depth player is yet to be determined.
The Hammer: When does Tomlin get some blame for young players not progressing and improving? I can't think of one player he has developed.
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin should not be the only to get some blame. He's not scouting them or drafting them. He has some input, but the Rooney pay a bunch of scouts and GM Kevin Colbert to evaluate college players. Some of the higher-profile drafts picks have not produced. Whether that's because they were overrated to begin with or because of the coaching is up for debate, but blaming only Tomlin for these problems is unfair. You win and lose as an organization. Everyone gets credit when things go well and everyone should get some of the blame when things don't go well.
Yo: Ray, I live in a different country. What is the vibe in town regarding the team? Are people down/sad? I live in Cambodia.
Ray Fittipaldo: Judging from the way the fans poured of out Heinz Field yesterday at about 3:00 p.m., I'd say disgusted is a pretty good word to describe the way people felt.
Guest: Steelers cut a center to pick up a journeyman guard and now a backup tackle, who was playing TE is now playing center.
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers cut John Malecki, who played in 1 NFL game, because they didn't think he was worthy of being on the 53-man roster. So they signed Cody Wallace because they thought he was a better option. I'm not saying Wallace is the answer, but they clearly did not think Malecki was going to be able to handle a starting job in the league. They would have kept him on the roster if they did.
mike H: Did the decision to fire Bruce Arians and hire Todd Haley (made by Art Rooney II) cost the Steelers Ben Roethlisberger's prime? For me it's up there with passing on Dan Marino in franchise blunders. Ben has no line, no backs, and no weapons. Will need to learn new system next yr.
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a popular opinion now, but I seem to remember listening to talk radio and reading chats like these when Arians was employed by the Steelers and those people complained about the job he did. In retrospect, he's now Bill Walsh because of how things have panned out with Haley. It should be note that Haley's offense was doing OK until Ben got hurt last year. And as troubling as Sunday's performance was, it was only one game.
hollow: With Larry Foote gone for the year, will the Steelers look to move Jones or Worilds into the inside spot?
Ray Fittipaldo: Anything is possible because of the lack of quality depth at ILB, but those guys have never played there before. Maybe you just have to bite the bullet and go with the young guys and hope they play well.
walter: Do the offensive problems have anything to do with the new ZONE BLOCKING SCHEME?
Ray Fittipaldo: There were problems late last season with the offense and that was when they used strictly a power blocking scheme. Maybe it's just the offensive linemen not doing their job no matter what type of running play is called.
Steelers4Tim: The Steelers really need a big bruising back. I said they'd live to regret not signing Javorskie Lane when they had the chance. They have the worst stable of RBs in the NFL.
Ray Fittipaldo: Isaac Redman is a big back, but it's hard for any back to be productive when they're getting hit in the backfield before they get a head of steam. I'm not saying he's Franco Harris, but there is a reason he's been in the league for four or five years.
SoccerMom: With all of the recent draft busts and the depleted roster, is Kevin Colberts job in serious jeopardy? Shouldn't it be?
Ray Fittipaldo: Colbert is the architect of two Super Bowl winners. I think he's earned a mulligan or two. But as I said before he should not be absolved of blame. There is plenty to go around.
Mitch: Ray, why does Tomlin struggle so much with clock management? Do they have someone to assist him?
Ray Fittipaldo: If they do I don't know who he is or what his role is. I'm with you on him taking that timeout with 2:03 left in the game? In that situation, at the 5-yard line, you should be throwing in the end zone. It's either going to be a touchdown or an incompletion, which stops the clock anyway. It didn't make any sense to me.
Carl: Is the new zone blocking scheme to blame for yesterday's disaster? Also, should the US intervene in Syria? Thanks.
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe they should go back to the 70s and start trapping again.
WashPA: Emmanuel Sanders showed he was not a #1 or #2 WR yesterday. Should the Steelers have just taken the draft pick from New England for him instead of renting him for one year?
Ray Fittipaldo: Word was that Ben went to bat for Sanders and nudged the front office to sign him. So it's up to Ben and Sanders to make this one-year marriage work. For what it's worth, Sanders isn't exactly off to a raucous start in earning that big contract he covets so much.
Ryan: Are you concerned that our defense doesn't seem to pressure the qb and make as many splash plays as they have in years past? Is Lebeau's 3/4 d becoming stale?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, it is a concern. The defense was solid yesterday, but it did nothing to make a game-changing play. I pointed out in the paper today how they had the Titans in a third-and-13 and a third-and-15 on that field goal drive early in the third quarter and allowed them to convert each time. If you're not going to turn people over you had better get off the field when you have chance, and they didn't do that yesterday.
Nick: Why in the world, when youre down by 2 TDs with 2 minutes left on the opponents 10 yard line, do you throw the ball to the 4 so the (surprise) RB can be tackled immediately and you waste a TO? THROW THE BALL INTO THE ENDZONE!!
Ray Fittipaldo: Agree with you. That late drive produced a touchdown, but it was so inefficient that even if they did recover that onsides kick they didn't have enough time to win the game.
Guest: Any chance Sanders loses his spot to Wheaton soon?
Ray Fittipaldo: Based on his playing time yesterday it does not appear the coaches feel comfortable enough with him in the offense.
Anita: How much longer for Dick Lebeau?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's Dick's birthday today. He's closer to 80 than 70, so I am not sure, but to suggest he is the reason for the team's struggles is silly.
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for the questions this week. We'll do it again next Monday in advance of the game against the Bengals. Have a good week.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.