Following the season-ending injury to Miami tight end Dustin Keller after a low hit from Houston safety D.J. Swearinger some high-profile offensive players have commented on how such hits have no place in the game.
Falcons tight end Tony Gonzalez had harsh criticism for Swearinger and any other players that go after the knees of opposing players. The NFL has said it will discuss the issue with the competition committee over the offseason.
Those developments have Steelers safety Ryan Clark wondering how defensive players are supposed to adapt.
“I’m so disgusted with the NFL right now about those situations,” Clark said. “If an offensive player makes enough of a stink they’ll change it. I know Tony Gonzalez was extremely upset about the hit on Dustin Keller. I understand that. I believe some of you may have the film. I said if you start penalizing guys and fining guys for hits up top… Some of these hits up top are not illegal.
“I remember a hit I had on Victor Cruz last year, which was clearly legal, but it gave up seven points. I hurt my team by doing something I deemed legal and something the NFL also deemed legal by not fining me.
“So you go to the other extreme. The guys know there is no way possible I will get fined if I go low. It will be one or the other. Guys will hit up high and maybe risk of getting a concussion or hurting a shoulder. When you get hit low the season is going to be over. The season is going to be over. If they decide to change this rule they might as well put flags on because you’ll give a guy who is 200 pounds, like myself, a two-foot area to stop a guy who is 240 or 250 running at full speed. They might as well just take us off the field and see how many points you can score on offense in 60 minutes.”
When Clark was asked if defensive players could simply wrap a player’s legs instead of driving their force into the lower part of the body, he explained why that’s a bad idea.
“It would be soft and stupid,” he said. “In order for me to get down and wrap up… When you saw a guy down or chop him down low the play is dead right there. It’s over. There won’t be any more yards gained. There won’t be any more momentum to carry them forward.
“If I have to run up and wrap up a guy’s leg and he falls forward, or I fall back, I don’t want that. If I’m hitting him at the yard marker and I’m trying to stop his forward progress, and he falls forward for the first down it’s a whole new set of downs and now I’ve done my job insufficiently. I think they’re putting us at a disadvantage if they ask us to do that. And also now I’m in a position where I can get hurt. I don’t know if I’m getting hit in the side of the head with a knee.
“So in some sense you’re protecting another player, but you’re putting another one in harm’s way, both physically and career-wise in terms of him losing his starting job.”
Clark said he understands why offensive players are allowed to use low blocks on defensive players, but he wonders if the NFL will look at changing those rules, too, and what affect that would have on the game.
“If we’re trying to find a way to legislate low tackles, you’ll also find a way to do that on cut blocks,” he said. “If you’re doing that on cut blocks, you’re asking LaRod Stephens-Howling to block James Harrison up high on the blitz and you put him at a disadvantage if you try to do that. If you’re going to take this out of the game for us, what are you going to do to make it even on the other side?
“Eventually, it won’t be football. If every time someone gets hurt we decide to take that play out of football it will be a different game. They need to change the name of it and change the name of the league.
“I believe they’re trying to do the best they can to keep players healthy. But you can’t protect everything. Obviously, you want to protect the head. You’ve done that. Now you have to let us play. If guys will get hit low and that’s going to be a part of it, then that’s a part of it. If a receiver decides to cut my legs that’s a legal play. I understand that. Do I get upset sometimes? Yes, but it’s part of the rules.
“Right now we have to have a way to get guys who are bigger than us on the ground. Even when you have those defenseless player situations and it’s so full speed the only way I know I won’t hit him in his head but also keep my momentum and use the speed I have built up is to hit him low. If you take that away from us you really handicap us in a huge way.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.