DormontyDawson: Any buzz on Arnfelt? I thought he played very well. Any anti-buzz on Landry Jones? I've seen high school kids with stronger arms than his, and with far more confidence. He looks like the 6th grader who hates football but his parents are making him play.

Ray Fittipaldo: Landry Jones did look a bit overwhelmed in his first NFL game and he hasn't had a particularly strong camp, but it takes time for QBs to learn a new playbook and get comfortable in their surroundings. It's not like he's a first-round pick. They're expected to come in and make a difference right away. Jones is a fourth-round pick. He's not getting a ton of reps in camp. He is watching Roethlisberger and Gradkowski get most of the work. As for Arnfeldt, I thought he did well, but so did guys like Al Woods and Alameda Ta'amu. D line coach John Mitchell might have some depth and that's always important with the way he likes to rotate guys. That being said, I'm not sure Arnfelt gets on the 53-man roster.

Mike: Very leary after Saturday night's performance. Seems like nothing has changed. please talk me down

Ray Fittipaldo: It was the first preseason game. Most of the starters only played a series or two. The running game looked OK while the starters were in there. The first drive bogged down after Marcus Gilbert was called for holding. Other than the 57-yard TD catch the first-team defense gave up that unit played pretty well. They did not give up a yard after the blocked punt. Special teams were an issue and there were some dumb penalties, but I'd wait until the regular season to panic. Still plenty of time to iron out the kinks.

Advertise with us

Guest: Will Woods get serious playing time with #1's Cam and Ziggy ahead of him?

Ray Fittipaldo: I like what I see out of Woods. He was here last season, too. He is one of those non-descript players who does well in this defense. Unlike his competition at DE, he was not a high-round pick. He's also position flexible and can play nose tackle. With Ziggy Hood becoming a free agent after the season Woods' future could be in 2014. He is likely to provide depth this season.

Frank: Why pass on 3rd and short, I think pre season is a good opportunity to see if the new running game can pick up first downs in short yardage situations?

Ray Fittipaldo: They'd like to do a little bit of everything in the preseason. The run game has received lots of attention in the media because of the switch to a zone scheme, but this remains a passing league. Teams always pass in third-and-short situations now. I think they feel pretty good about their short-yardage package if Isaac Redman remains healthy. He is very adept at making something out of nothing.

Tom: It seems like the Steelers have been pressured to draft certain players from media/fans the past few years and are now suffering cause of it? All the talk of the defense being too old made them reach for guys like Hood, Heyward, Jones, and on the O side DeCastro. Other top guards (especially the Ravens Osemele in RD 2) outperformed DeCasstro last year and didn't DeMontre Moore make the Jones pick look silly already. Wouldn't a Eifert, Bell, Moore pick be perfect right now!

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers never pay attention to what the media or fans think when it comes to drafting a player. They invest hundreds of thousands of dollars into their scouting operation and make those picks after spending hours upon hours in the film room and at college games. You mention DeCastro, but he was injured for half the season and came back to play at less than 100 percent. He wasn't hurt when he came back, but he was not physically where he had been in August. The Hood and Heyward criticisms are valid. The Steelers need those guys to come through more. Every teams swings and misses once in a while in the draft. It happens. And let's face it, when you;re drafting late in the first round the chances that player does not live up to first-round expectations grow increasingly with every pick.

John B.: Do you think making all the O-linemen "position flexible" is hurting them by not just learning the full extent of one position? Especially rookies who are just coming in and getting up to speed with the process.

Ray Fittipaldo: The way the NFL is set up every backup offensive lineman has to be position flexible. Mike Tomlin usually only dresses eight linemen for games, so you can't have a backup for every position. Most of the time, a guy has to be a center and guard or guard and tackle. In Kelvin Beachum's case, he can play all three, which makes him even more valuable. For athletes at this level, switching from guard to tackle or guard to center isn't that big of a deal. Plus, if they want a job in the NFL they have to do it so they learn pretty quick.

Ken: Can someone explain to me how people--even people connected with the game like greedy owners-- think quality NFL football can somehow magically appear with just 2 preseason games? About 90% of these guys need work.

Ray Fittipaldo: I know they are looking at tweaking the preseason a bit, but I don't see major changes coming. The owners make too much money with the four preseason games. The only way they'd give away revenue of preseason games is by adding regular season games and the way head injuries dominate the league now I don't see that happening anytime soon. You say the guys need work, but most of those guys won't be on the 53-man roster.

Advertise with us

DormontyDawson: I was so impressed with David Gilreath last year. He seems like such a different (inferior) player now. Same with Baron Batch. Two fairly easy cuts, yes?

Ray Fittipaldo: Batch is probably on the outside looking in now. It's probably between him and Jonathan Dwyer for the final spot at RB. With Plaxico Burress out for likely the season, that fifth WR spot is interesting now. I wouldn't necessarily count Gilreath out. He is in competition with sixth-round pick Justin Brown, Derek Moye (who was on the practice squad for some of last season) and Reggie Dunn.

Tom: I know it was a preseason game and was nothing more that a live action Combine, but shouldn't the special teams be the one area of strength during preseason. Aren't those the guys actually trying to go 100% to make the team? Does it worry you they look so bad?

Ray Fittipaldo: It certainly was eye opening that there were so many mistakes. But once again, how many of these guys will be around in September when the real games are played? DaMon Cromartie-Smith is a guy who is trying to make this roster as a special teams player. He got beat on that blocked punt. That's not good for him. Same with Gilreath. He might be on the roster, but maybe not. More than likely, an experienced returner will be back there when the games count. The worrisome thing is special teams were below average last year. It's why Smith is here in the first place. I'll give him the benefit of the doubt because it was the first game and many of those players making mistakes are fringe guys who might be on the roster anyway.

Frank: It looks like this year's 1-4 picks will all contribute THIS year, makings of a very good draft. Agree?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I have to wait to see how they do during the regular season. It doesn't look like Jarvis Jones will start unless there is any injury to Worilds. Bell looks like the real deal, but we haven't see him in a game yet. I know they like Markus Wheaton and Shamarko Thomas, but they won't start either. I like the potential there, but you can't really grade a draft for years down the road.

Ken: I sense a very intense Tomlin this year. Do you see it at camp?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, lots more hitting than usual. Tomlin said it's because they're young on the offensive and defensive lines and he wants to see what those guys can do. The only way to find out is to let them go at it.

nerdbird: Couldn't or wouldn't keep at lest 2 of colon legursky starks? would not they be better backups than what we have now

Ray Fittipaldo: If you subscribe to Pro Football Focus, Doug Legursky was by their estimation the worst lineman on the team last season. They did not value him very much and evidently neither did the Steelers. Plus, they have a cheaper version of Legursky in John Malecki if they keep Malecki, who is no longer eligible for the practice squad. As far as Max Starks and Willie Colon go, they did not fit well into the new zone blocking scheme. Plus, for the money Colon made he was too injury-prone.

Advertise with us

Tom: In general all 32 teams are fairly even in talent level and many games are decided by a TD or less. The difference is being able to make a few "splash" plays. Now that Wallace and his high % of Steeler TD's the past year or two are gone, who will be scoring the TD's this year?

Ray Fittipaldo: Antonio Brown is the top candidate to step into that role. They're paying him $7 million a year. Emmanuel Sanders is a guy who can be more productive if he can stay healthy and Wheaton has big-play capability as well. That being said, did you notice how often they threw deep to Wallace last year? Not much. Todd Haley does not go for the big play that often. He's rather dink and dunk it down the field.

DormontyDawson: I like the running back mix of Bell, LSH, Redman and Dwyer. If Bell is as advertised, that group is in top 50% of the league, in my opinion.

Ray Fittipaldo: Once again, I want to see Bell in a game setting before drawing any conclusions. But based off practice, he is their best back. Redman is very good in short-yardage and Stephens'Howling can be that change of pace and third-down guy. I agree it's a nice mix, but everyone knows the offensive line has to block well in front of them. That hasn't exactly been this team's strong suit the past few years.

Tom: Exactly, Wallace wasn't a one trick pony that everyone wants him to be now that he is gone. He got a lot of his TD's in the Redzone when guys like Sanders (0 TD) and Brown couldn't get open. I think they are going to need a RB to score a lot of TD's this year. T

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Bell has that potential. Heath Miller isn't a big play guy, but he was great in Haley's offense until he got hurt.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for taking part in the chat this week. Stay tuned to my Twitter account (@rayfitt1) about next week's chat. We're driving to D.C. Monday and I might have to make a time change. Will keep you posted.