The American sports fan has come to love lists. Or maybe it's the American journalist. Whatever the case, CBSsports.com has a good discussion-starter today. NFL writer Pete Prisco ranks the NFL coaches 1-30, and he ranks Mike Tomlin at No. 5, behind his good friend in Baltimore, John Harbaugh, who comes in at No. 3.
It’s hard to argue with the first two coaches on Prisco’s list. Bill Belichick and Tom Coughlin are Hall of Fame-caliber coaches. Belichick is No. 1 and in all likelihood a slam-dunk Hall of Famer. Prisco theorizes Coughlin cemented his spot in the Hall of Fame by virtue of his second Super Bowl victory. He might be right. In any case, I have no issue with him being second on this list.
One could make a strong argument for Tomlin being No. 3 on the list, however, ahead of Harbaugh and Sean Payton. For one, he has as many Super Bowl victories and coached his team to another. Harbaugh and Payton have only been to one.
Let’s take a look at Tomlin and Harbaugh head-to-head.
*Tomlin is 63-33 (.656) during the regular season and 5-3 in the postseason. Harbaugh is 54-26 (.675) and 9-4 in the playoffs. Harbaugh has a better winning percentage in both the regular season and playoffs in his five seasons than Tomlin’s six seasons as a head coach.
*In head-to-head matchups, Tomlin is 7-5 against Harbaugh during the regular season but 2-0 in the playoffs, including the 2008 AFC championship game and a 2010 AFC divisional round game. Prisco prefaced his list by saying any coach with a Super Bowl ring has to rank higher than one that does not. Using a similar premise, shouldn't postseason record, especially when it comes to head-to-head meetings, count more than the regular season?
Of course, Green Bay fans are probably wondering how Mike McCarthy is ranked No. 6 behind Tomlin when McCarthy beat him head-to-head to win Super Bowl XLV. McCarthy is 74-38 (.661) during the regular season and 6-4 in the playoffs.
And Payton is an interesting choice at No. 4. He is coming off a year-long suspension handed down by NFL commissioner for Bountygate. Prisco took that out of his equation and cited his Super Bowl ring and his offensive play-calling abilities as his reason for Payton meriting such a lofty ranking. Payton is 62-34 (.646) and 5-3 in the playoffs, a record identical to Tomlin in the postseason.
It gets much less interesting after the top 6, but it’s a good read nonetheless.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.