The top goal-scorer in WPIAL girls soccer last year will have the opportunity to score more goals this season after all.

The WPIAL board of directors overturned a previous ruling and granted sophomore Jayden Sharpless eligibility to play this season at North Catholic High School after she transferred from Freedom. The WPIAL made its decision Thursday after a hearing with Sharpless at the league offices in Green Tree.

A few weeks ago, the WPIAL ruled Sharpless ineligible to compete this season, claiming she transferred from Freedom to North Catholic (at least partially) for athletic reasons, which is against WPIAL and PIAA rules. The WPIAL made that ruling based on submitted transfer paperwork that showed Freedom contested the transfer, saying it was for athletic reasons.

But Sharpless had the right to appeal the decision and have a hearing. She took advantage of that opportunity, and the hearing included Freedom and North Catholic representatives.

Advertise with us

“It was a split vote by our board,” WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley said. “There was a lot of discussion, but we decided to make her eligible.”

Sharpless was terrific last year as a freshman at Freedom when she led the WPIAL in goals with 64 and helped Freedom to a WPIAL Class 1A title and a second-place finish in the PIAA. Sharpless played alongside her sister, Myla, who graduated.

The WPIAL also had a hearing Thursday and granted eligibility to Jack Westerberg after he transferred from Fox Chapel to Shady Side Academy.

In addition, the WPIAL had three short hearings with athletes who were appealing their postseason ineligibility after transferring. Avonworth’s Kyros Thorpe and Carmichaels’ Sydney Kuis and Jackson Machesky already had been granted eligibility to play in the regular season in their respective sports, but were trying to have their postseason ineligibility overturned.

The PIAA instituted a rule last August where student-athletes who transfer after playing a sport in their sophomore year are automatically ineligible for the postseason in that sport at the new school. The WPIAL or PIAA can grant a waiver to the postseason ineligibility, but only under certain circumstances.

Advertise with us

The WPIAL ruled Thorpe, who transferred from Central Catholic, ineligible for the postseason in football. Thorpe, a receiver, has been a key player for Avonworth in the first two games, tied for the team lead in receptions with 7 for 210 yards. He also has scored three touchdowns.

Kuis was ruled ineligible for the postseason in volleyball at Carmichaels after transferring from Mapletown. Machesky, who transferred from West Greene, was ruled ineligible in the postseason for basketball and baseball.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh