On the bright side, better to be eliminated, 11-1, than, say, 11-10.
In the latest most important game of the season, Pirates starter Charlie Morton was awful, which was not totally unexpected. But teams that score one run don’t often win. The onus for this defeat rests almost as much with the offense as with Morton. In their past four games, the Pirates have been shut out twice and scored one run once.
Give credit to the Cardinals. They shut down a lineup that has won 96 games with what amounts to a minor-league pitcher. In the 20th start of his MLB career, which began in 2013, Tyler Lyons came up with his finest performance -- seven innings, no runs, four hits, no walks.
But all of that is history. Morton won’t pitch again this season for the Pirates and now there are questions about whether he’ll ever pitch for them again. Since the Pirates owe him $9 million, it’s highly likely he will.
The immediate task in front of the team is securing home-field for the wildcard game with the Cubs. Their magic number is two with three games remaining. The Cubs play four more.
Regardless of the site, the wildcard challenge is daunting: Jake Arrieta. The Pirates will have to beat the man who is arguably the current best pitcher in baseball. He has been extraordinary in the second half of the season. But like all pitchers, he is beatable, just less so than most.
The Pirates could have a one-game postseason. They also are built for a much longer run.
If they can get past Arrieta, the future is promising. And that’s because their next opponent will be the team that beat them last night and took two out of three in the series. It is a bit preposterous to disrespect a team that already has won 100 games and suggest it is ripe to be taken, but hear me out.
The Cardinals are 14-12 in their past 26 games and clearly in decline. The team that wins the wildcard game is more than capable of beating St. Louis and getting to the World Series.
About the Cardinals:
• Their rotation is in disarray.
Michael Wacha has been terrible in September and was knocked around in the first game of yesterday’s doubleheader, an 8-2 Pirates’ win. Lance Lynn has mostly staggered through September. Carlos Martinez is on the disabled list. A month ago, those three probably would have been at the top of the St. Louis rotation. In fairness, Jamie Garcia and John Lackey have been very effective.
• Their bullpen, once the best in baseball, is in decline
Closer Trevor Rosenthal has allowed game-winning home runs in two of his past three appearances and has a 6.48 ERA in September. Other ERAs this month from the St. Louis bullpen: Seth Maness 7.45, Steve Cishek 4.32, Jonathan Broxton 3.27.
• Their lineup is hurting in many ways.
Catcher Yadier Molina, the heart of the Cardinals, hasn’t played since Sept. 20 and could miss, at least, the start of the postseason with a thumb injury. Shortstop Jhonny Peralta, a middle-of-the-lineup bat, has a .631 OPS since June 13. Slugger Matt Holliday is 4-for-20 since returning to the lineup Sept. 17 after missing most of the season. Top rookie Randal Grichuk, who has an .881 OPS, is 5-for-26 and playing sparingly since returning to the lineup Sept. 7.
If the Pirates can win the wildcard game, they will enter the NLDS against St. Louis with a rotation of Francisco Liriano, J.A. Happ, Gerrit Cole and A.J. Burnett. That is a better starting rotation than St. Louis can present.
But first they must get past Arrieta, be it at PNC Park or Wrigley Field. And that is a huge obstacle in what otherwise could be an excellent postseason.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.