The Pirates could have asked for nothing more than for the game to be in the hands of Mark Melancon, their stellar closer. This time, though, it didn’t work out for Melancon or the Pirates.
In a scoreless game in the ninth, Melancon gave up two singles -- which Gregory Polanco and Andrew McCutchen played into a run -- and then a homer to Mark Reynolds that accounted the final score in a 3-0 loss to the St. Louis Cardinals Monday night at PNC Park.
The Pirates had chances galore. They stranded 16 and were 0-for-12 with runners in scoring position. They had two on and none out in the ninth but could not score against closer Trevor Rosenthal, who had allowed game-losing homers in his two previous appearances.
They trail St. Louis by four games with five remaining. They are all but mathematically eliminated.
That doesn’t mean it hasn't been an outstanding season and it doesn’t mean it can’t continue to be one. But the task ahead -- Jake Arrieta in the wildcard game -- is daunting, to say the least.
Thoughts on the defeat and the future:
Read More
Gerrit Cole is the quintessential ace -- a fierce competitor with a chip on his shoulder the size of a lumber yard. He’s a former overall No. 1 draft choice who has a nasty temperament and an upper 90s fastball. Fans love his attitude. There’s no doubt he will pitch the wildcard game for the Pirates against the Chicago Cubs.
But there is doubt as to whether he currently is the Pirates best pitcher? Looks aren’t everything.
J.A. Happ does not exude the attitude of Cole. But he has been spectacularly good for the Pirates and continued that way last night. He shut out the Cardinals on one hit and no walks over the first six innings.
In his past nine starts, Happ has a 1.53 ERA, an 0.91 WHIP and a 9.52 K/9. In those nine starts, he has allowed three or more runs only one time.
In Cole’s past nine starts, he has a 3.12 ERA, a 1.08 WHIP and a 8.90 K/9. In those nine starts, he has allowed three or more runs five times.
Cole will get the start. That doesn’t mean it’s the right decision.
■ ■ ■
In what was the biggest game of the season, if not the biggest game of the Pirates' regular season in decades, the attendance at PNC Park was 30,198, which is 78.7 percent of capacity.
Before the game, it was mentioned in the comment section that anything less than a sellout would be ‘embarrassing.’
No one should feel embarrassed about last night’s crowd, except, possibly, the Pirates marketing department.
The Pirates are making millions in profit, the players are averaging millions in salary. The average fan owes the team nothing. The public paid for most of the stadium, supports the team extremely well at the gate and on TV and can’t get enough of the overpriced concessions at PNC Park. That’s more than enough.
■ ■ ■
With five games remaining, the Cardinals have 99 wins, which is truly amazing considering their well-documented history of injury. That history continued last night when outstanding rookie Stephen Piscotty (.877 OPS) left the game after a collision in the outfield with Peter Bourjos. The full extent of Piscotty's injuries are not know, but it was a frightening scene as he lay motionless on the outfield grass before being taken off the field on a stretcher.
The Cardinals also are without their excellent catcher Yadier Molina, who will miss the rest of the regular season, at least, with a thumb injury. Last week, outstanding young starter Carlos Martinez was pronounced out for the season. Outfielder Matt Holliday is just returning from injuries that caused him to miss most of the season and he may not be able to regain his form in the limited time remaining. Top starter Adam Wainwright has been out for almost all of the season. And that’s the abbreviated version of their injury list.
No one in Pittsburgh much likes the Cardinals, but their season has been truly remarkable. No one should be surprised, though, if they lose in the NLDS to the Pirates or Cubs, both of which currently have better personnel.
■ ■ ■
Much has been written about the absolute dominance of Arrieta and it’s all true. But try to remember this: His record is 21-6, not 21-0.
In 2013, Clayton Kershaw had a 1.83 ERA in the regular season and a 3.13 ERA in the postseason. In 2014, he had a 1.77 ERA in the regular season and a 7.82 in the postseason.
No pitcher is a sure thing.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.