Is the sun setting on the golden era of Pitt basketball?
That might seem like a harsh sentiment. But the case can be made that the best years of this excellent run of success, which began in 2001, already are in the past.
This is not to suggest Pitt has a future as an ACC doormat. Jamie Dixon is too good a coach for that to happen. The Panthers will continue to be a respected program, one that is regularly, but not always, invited to the NCAA tournament and one that sometimes will be a contender to win the ACC. But the days of No. 1 rankings and top seeds in the tournament could well be a memory.
Should anyone doubt that Pitt is in decline, consider these four-year glimpses at the team's league records:
• From 2004-07, Pitt was 45-19 in conference play.
• From 2008-11, Pitt was 53-19 in conference play.
• From 2012 to the present, Pitt is 31-31 in conference play.
This decline has nothing to do with Pitt’s change in conference from the Big East to the ACC in 2013. The ACC could well be a lesser league to the old Big East. What’s more, half of the 14-team ACC once played basketball in the Big East.
Pitt’s glory run began in 2001, Ben Howland’s second season as coach. The Panthers stunned even their most ardent fans by advancing to the final of the Big East tournament. In advancing that far, Pitt won more games, three, than it had in the previous 10 Big East tournaments.
Few expected the Panthers to capitalize on that success the way they did. Too many underestimated Howland, a little-known coach hired away from Northern Arizona, and Dixon, his assistant who took over in 2004. Pitt would go to 10 straight NCAA tournaments beginning in 2002, and although its success in that event was meager, all that regular-season winning elevated the program to elite status. In 11 of 14 seasons, Pitt was ranked in the top 10 at least once.
And now that wonderful resume is slowly slipping away. The reason is simple and as old as competitive athletics: Not enough good players.
It has long been said, and correctly so, that Pitt never got the best talent but Howland and Dixon coached up what they had and were able to get maximum effort from their players. That maximum effort, however, was negated in the postseason, where all teams turned up their level of intensity in the one-and-done tournament. Pitt’s lesser talent could not be masked.
Pitt fell to 13-8 overall and 3-5 in the ACC with a devastating overtime loss at Virginia Tech Tuesday. The Panthers led by seven with two minutes remaining but could not defend well enough the 3-point shooting of the Hokies. The loss makes an NCAA tournament bid a distinct long shot.
Pitt should be better next season. The team has only two upperclassmen, starting guards Cam Wright, a senior, and James Robinson, a junior. So there’s room for improvement, particularly from forwards Michael Young and Jamel Artis. But neither is the NBA-bound players Pitt so often must compete against.
Pitt is placing a lot of hope in Durand Johnson, who figures to take Wright’s spot at shooting guard next season. But Johnson, who will be a senior, has been anything but dependable. He was suspended for the first two games of the 2013-14 season and for all of this season. The reason for his current suspension has never been disclosed, although since it spanned two semesters it’s not likely academic in nature.
Johnson will give the team the 3-point threat it lacks this season, but his all-around game is not up to Wright’s level.
Rozelle Nix, a 7-0 junior college player, will join the team next season and could easily move into the starting lineup, which would free Young from duties to which he’s not altogether suited. But it remains to be determined if Nix’s game is ready for the ACC. Incoming freshman guard Damon Wilson will provide depth.
Other players on the team -- Josh Newkirk, Chris Jones, Ryan Luther, Sheldon Jeter and Cam Johnson -- all could pick up their games. And Pitt could well contend for a tournament invitation.
But there are no signs that the glory years will return.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.