Pat Narduzzi speaks to media ahead of ACC championship

It seems tough, predicting what Pitt will do in a given game.

It gets easier, though, when you abandon the concept of simple wins or losses. The fundamental question isn’t “Can Pitt score more points than Team X?” It’s, “What is the most Pitt outcome to this particular Pitt event?” And a lot of the time, that contradicts every stitch of conventional wisdom.

It’s not foolproof; it’s just a helpful consideration. A lot of times, they lose when they should win, and they win when they should lose. There is evidence. There are years and years of evidence.

That, friends, brings us to the ACC championship — a game in which, at last glance, Pitt was set to enter as a four-touchdown underdog. That simple fact, combined with last week’s addled belly-flop of a game in Miami, makes it increasingly easy to believe the stage is set for the Pitting of a lifetime. Oh, what a Pitting it would be!

Advertise with us

So, forget how good Trevor Lawrence is, and how good Clemson’s run defense is. Forget what you know. Don’t believe your lying eyes. Don’t try to guess how Pitt would beat the Tigers. Just assume, for this exercise, that it happens. Maybe Kenny Pickett goes 33 of 41 for 414 yards and four touchdowns. Maybe Qadree Ollison and Darrin Hall can figure something out against a defensive line filled, almost literally, with future first-round picks.

Maybe Lawrence gets hurt. Maybe there’s a nearby train derailment or an e. Coli outbreak or a swarm of locusts that descends upon Charlotte. Who cares. Doesn’t matter. Pitt wins.

Then, this is what could happen.

• Pitt, automatically, plays in a New Year Six bowl. The ACC champ gets a spot in the Fiesta or Peach Bowl. This is non-negotiable.

• Clemson, nearly as automatically, falls out of the College Football Playoff. The Tigers are second, behind Alabama, in those standings. No. 3 Notre Dame's regular-season schedule is finished. If No. 6 Ohio State beats Northwestern and No. 5 Oklahoma beats Texas — and that'd be chalk in both instances — a Pitt win would almost certainly leave Clemson on the street. FiveThirtyEight puts those odds, with Clemson at No. 5, at 89 percent.

Advertise with us

The most likely outcome, according to FiveThirtyEight, would be Bama vs. Oklahoma and Ohio State vs. Notre Dame in the semis — but really, spots 2-4 would be effectively up for grabs.

Clemson is still Clemson, though — a marquee program with a huge fanbase and just one loss. You can effectively pen them into another at-large spot in a New Year's Six bowl. In this exercise, they'd take over for Ohio State's level-up. The logic here is that they’ll beat Northwestern handily enough, and that Oklahoma will struggle to at least some degree with Texas if they don’t lose outright.

(The Longhorns beat the Sooners 48-45 in Week 6, and OU’s defense hasn’t gotten any better since, even though they canned Mike Stoops immediately after that loss. They’re only two games removed from allowing Kansas — Kansas! — to hang 40 on them in Norman while averaging 8.2 yards per play. If you’re opting for them over a team that just demolished Michigan ... good luck.)

In any case, that's where stuff really starts getting fuzzy; Ohio State is headed for the Rose Bowl ... unless they jump the Sooners to take Clemson’s spot in the playoff. Several bowl projections have Michigan taking a spot in the Peach Bowl. In our exercise, they'd vacate that for the Rose. Let's say they play Washington. Sure, why not?

Then, Clemson and Pitt would get thrown into a pool of five teams for four spots in the Fiesta and Peach bowls, along with LSU, Florida and whichever Group of Five team the committee chooses. Until last week, UCF seemed like a lock — then QB McKenzie Milton broke his leg. That'll be a consideration even if the Knights beat Memphis in the American Athletic Conference title game, because Boise State is at No. 22 ... and Fresno State, the Broncos opponent in the Mountain West championship, is at No. 25. If UCF loses, the winner of Boise-Fresno could easily make the jump.

Advertise with us

Let's say Boise emerges there. Florida has the edge over LSU in the CFP rankings, and neither is playing this week. So, since a Clemson-Pitt rematch is off the table. The odds of either the Fiesta or Peach bowl accepting Pitt-Boise State are slim. Same goes if UCF manages to beat Memphis without Milton. A UCF-Pitt rematch isn't in the cards at either place.

Voila: Enjoy Pitt-Florida in Glendale. You'd think the Panthers would manage to beat a three-loss team after derailing another's national-title hopes. So, Gators by 24.

Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com, Twitter @seangentille

Clemson coach Dabo Swinney on losing to Pitt in 2016, and Pat Narduzzi