If there were any lingering doubt that JuJu Smith-Schuster’s taunt of Vontaze Burfict did him in, rather than the actual block, the NFL erased it on Wednesday.
Bengals safety George Iloka, who like Smith-Schuster was suspended one game for an illegal block, had that ruling overturned.
#Bengals S George Iloka had his 1-game suspension overturned. He’ll now pay a $35,464.50 fine.
— Ian Rapoport (@RapSheet) December 6, 2017
Both hits were violent. Both made contact with, as the NFL put it, the “head and neck injury.” Smith-Schuster’s was “unnecessary.” Iloka’s — a helmet-to-helmet shot on Antonio Brown in the end zone — was “flagrant” and “egregious.” So, you’d think that the appeal process would unfold similarly.
Nope. Smith-Schuster will sit, and Iloka won’t. (Ben Roethlisberger isn’t going to be happy.)
If you want an answer as to why, it’s in the original letter, too; NFL VP of football operations Jon Runyan went out of his way to scold Smith-Schuster for his conduct after the play. The die seemed to be cast yesterday.
“Your conduct following the hit fell far below the high standards of sportsmanship expected of an NFL player,” Runyan wrote.
Read More
Is that all enough to take a hit from illegal, which Smith-Schuster’s and Iloka’s were in equal measure, to suspendable? That’s what the NFL seems to be saying here. It’s not just about the block, in other words. It’s not even about the perception of the block; both plays were excessively violent in a game that already had been, effectively, ruined. It’s about the taunt. It’s about Smith-Schuster standing over Burfict for a few extra seconds.
If that’s what the NFL wants to eliminate, so be it. Crack down on taunting. Let this be a warning to the rest of the league — but make it clear, because in a vacuum, the difference between the hits is too small to parse. Like Ed Bouchette said in his chat yesterday, the phrase “slippery slope” is a cliche, but in this case it applies.
Wow 😂😂😂
— JuJu Smith-Schuster (@TeamJuJu) December 6, 2017
Huh?Where is this secret rule book where y’all decide this? #nonsense pic.twitter.com/2JEUYLuY13
— Cam Heyward (@CamHeyward) December 6, 2017
Stay classy @NFL smh
— Ramon Foster (@RamonFoster) December 6, 2017
Pittsburgh Steelers vs Everybody else. And guess who I’m taking @RamonFoster
— Cam Heyward (@CamHeyward) December 6, 2017
We’ve seen it in hockey over the years; it’s become nearly impossible to tell the difference between a play that gets a misconduct, a play that gets one game and a play that gets three. That’s the NHL’s fault. If the NFL wants to avoid starting down a road to something similar, they should seize on — and publicize — the differentiation point. Smith-Schuster, like it or not, got a game for standing over Burfict.
Why not make it clear? As an added bonus, now the NFL can even say “Rob Gronkowski didn’t taunt anybody” and still have a logically defensible case for he and Smith-Schuster getting the same penalty: You can be Level-1 violent and get away with it, like Iloka did, but Level 2 violence, like Gronkowski’s, gets you a game, as does Level 1 violence plus a taunt, like Smith-Schuster.
The other choice is saying nothing and setting up more confusion and outrage whenever this happens again. Smart money is there.
Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @seangentille





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.