One of the nice things about the Stanley Cup playoffs is that the shelf life on stories tends to be short. If something happens, we all talk about it that night. The next day, the relevant players are asked about it, they gave their canned responses, more #content is created based off that, and then we move on.

Most of the time, that’s how it works; it’s a 24-to-48-hour cycle, and it restarts a few times a week. The case of Alex Ovechkin’s shot vs. Ron Hainsey’s ear, though, has dragged on a bit. Sunday was a travel day, so neither team practiced or spoke to the media — Barry Trotz and Mike Sullivan both held conference calls.

So, a small fire that started after Game 2 — whether Ovechkin deliberately fired a puck at Hainsey with 2:21 left in the Penguins’ eventual 6-2 win, and the fact that a few Penguins reportedly wondered themselves — smoldered for a couple days.

Now, it might’ve been understandable for them to have questions about it initially; Chris Kunitz was annoyed enough to skate over to Ovechkin while Hainsey was on the ice, and it’s a professional sport. Dull as hockey players can seem off the ice, they’re also human beings performing in high-pressure environments.

Advertise with us

They’re not going to be particularly rational 10 minutes after a playoff game. It’s probably fair to give them a pass.

But now, after two days’ worth of hindsight and cool-down time, the conspiracy theories should stop. Given that Monday morning was the first time Ovechkin spoke after the whole deal, though, asking him about was totally justifiable. He apologized, just like he did to Hainsey on Saturday night.

“You never want to hurt someone,” Ovechkin said. “It’s an accident. The puck flipped off my stick. It goes high.”

Capitals defenseman Brooks Orpik, according to the Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey, got a little more specific.

“That’s pretty far off. He’s a guy who hammers the puck, and half the time he’s just trying to hit the net as hard as he can. He doesn’t know where it’s going. It’s part of the game.”

Advertise with us

Right. For whatever reason, though — it could be standard fan irrationality, or some strain of Alex Ovechkin Derangement Syndrome that’s taken hold of a relevant portion of the population — some people are still mad. If you doubt that, look at the responses to Mackey’s tweet.

So, as a public service: Alex Ovechkin did not deliberately hit Ron Hainsey in the ear with a hockey puck. Here are three reasons, though there are more.

1. Ovechkin was trying to score. The Caps were down three and on the power play, about 2:30 away from dropping the first two games of the series at home. If you believe in sports curses — not that you should — the Caps are dealing with one, at the moment. Wasting a scoring chance would be deeply stupid. Trying to beat Marc-Andre Fleury short-side from the top of the circles, especially when you’re Alex Ovechkin, is less stupid.

2. Ovechkin, probably, isn’t a psychopath. There are plenty of obnoxious things about watching the NHL. The frequency of dumb, dirty plays are toward the top of the list. Ovechkin has had his share, as has Brooks Orpik, as has Sidney Crosby. It happens; slewfoots happen, and slashes happen, and late hits happen, and boarding happens. We’ll probably get one on Monday night.

What doesn’t happen with any real degree of frequency: A player deliberately shooting a puck at someone else’s face. Try to think of the last time you saw it. You’re probably coming up empty, and there’s a reason for that. It’s an act of weird, premeditated violence that’s too weird, even for hockey

Advertise with us

3. The puck drifted. This is the big one. Alex Ovechkin is a great player; getting elevation on his shot off the rush like that is part of what makes him so.

But the odds of him a) making the split-second choice to shoot the puck at Hainsey’s head and b) actually managing to execute it after the puck drifted several inches during his shooting motion are ... zero, actually. Let’s call it zero.

The Penguins weren’t thrilled about it on Saturday. That’s understandable. Ovechkin had to answer for it. That’s understandable. Now, nearly two full days after the fact, if you’re spending your afternoon wondering about it much more, it’s time to reevaluate.

Or, we can just move on. That’d be fine, too.