We have a new made-for-the-internet debate to spend our short time on Earth arguing about. Thank you, Nick Bonino.
The Penguins center lobbed this bomb on Monday afternoon. Cue the “30 for 30”-style, “What if I told you ... there was a different way to button your shirt” voiceover.
Apparently guys on team button dress shirts top to bottom...that is bananas! Never seen before. Only normal way is bottom to top, thoughts?
— Nick Bonino (@NickBonino) April 3, 2017
It’s a question on par with “When you’re making a bowl of cereal, do you pour the milk or cereal first?” and “Which side of the toilet paper roll do you face up on the holder?” Most of us eat cereal. A larger percentage of us use toilet paper. And a possibly even larger percentage has, at some point in our lives, buttoned a shirt.
If you do it one way, odds are you’ve never given much thought to the other option. Some things are just done because ... that’s how they’re done. I don’t know why I put toothpaste on the brush before running it under the sink. I just do it.
That brings us back to Bonino, who seems legitimately shocked that anybody would ever start with the top, then work their way down. Personally speaking, it’s just as shocking that he starts at the bottom. His shock is shocking. I’ve literally never heard of anybody starting with the bottom button. Ever.
@FeitsBarstool buddy half my team starts at the top. I was going insane in the locker room. Couldn't believe it
— Nick Bonino (@NickBonino) April 3, 2017
If Bonino didn’t get that initially, he gets it now; his Twitter poll is coming back pretty decisively in favor of Team Top Button.
I guess this should settle it. Do you button your dress shirt from bottom to top like a normal person, or top to bottom.
— Nick Bonino (@NickBonino) April 3, 2017
It doesn’t settle anything on either side, though. Again: An hour ago, I’d have guessed that the poll would be 95 percent in favor of Team Top Button. You always have to account for a certain amount of weirdos, I suppose, but even a 60/40 end result would be stunning.
This isn’t trying to figure out when to tuck in a shirt. You start with the second button and work your way down. If you’re wearing a tie, you circle back to the top button, then deal with it. If you’re not wearing a tie, the top button is addressed a case-by-case basis. Personally, I lean toward no, but realize that there are people out there who think differently.
For the record, in a quick poll of about 10 Post-Gazette staffers, men and women, only one buttons from the bottom up, and he’s an intern. A representative from Heinz Healey’s, a men’s clothing store in Downtown Pittsburgh, seemed legitimately baffled by the question.
He guessed it’d be split in hockey. Maybe, the thought process went, Canadians and Europeans do it their own way.
“I’m sure that Americans are buttoning it from the top down,” he said.
Bonino grew up in Connecticut. Maybe that’s how they do things in Farmington. In any case, we should all be grateful that he gave us something new to fight about in bars.
Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @seangentille.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.