Pickett or Rudolph?

This isn’t just a question that was unimaginable a week ago.

It is a question that has Pittsburgh buzzing and was the talk at seemingly every Christmas Eve and Christmas Day gathering.

The popular, even overwhelming, choice is Mason Rudolph. He gave the Steelers their best quarterback play of the past two seasons in Saturday’s season-sustaining 34-11 win against the Cincinnati Bengals. He led the team to its highest point total in two years. He threw for 290 yards, a Steelers best this season. He threw two long touchdown passes to George Pickens. He finished with a 124.0 passer rating.

Advertise with us

I get why Rudolph’s teammates gushed about him after the game.

“Mason was ready for the moment,” Cam Heyward said. “With everything going on, Mason attacked. It wasn’t anything sitting back and letting things happen. He went out there and attacked the game.”

“He has tremendous confidence in himself,” Calvin Austin III said. “You can feel it. He had that intensity and focus in the huddle.”

I get why there were multiple “Ma-son Ru-dolph!” chants at Acrisure Stadium during the game. “I would be lying if I said I didn’t enjoy it,” Rudolph said.

Certainly, I get why everybody wants Rudolph to start in Seattle against the Seahawks on Sunday.

Advertise with us

But the correct choice is Kenny Pickett as long as his ankle injury has fully recovered after surgery.

The whole point of this season — at least for me — was for the Steelers to find out what they had in Pickett. Was he worth a No. 1 pick in the 2022 NFL draft? Is he the franchise’s quarterback of the future?

I’ll admit, the answers to those questions so far have been a lukewarm maybe.

That’s why I want to see what Pickett can do in a virtual must-win game against the Seahawks.

Pickett supporters will tell you he can be the real deal once he gets the chance to play with a real offensive coordinator. His detractors forget he also played his best game against the Bengals — how bad is their defense? — on Nov. 26, the first game after Matt Canada was fired. He was playing well in the next game against the Arizona Cardinals, leading the team to a field goal on its first drive and having it in position to score a touchdown when he was injured late in the second quarter. He missed the past two games.

Advertise with us

Steelers players wanted no part of the Pickett-or-Rudolph question after the win on Saturday.

“Next question,” Najee Harris said.

“It ain’t my choice,” Diontae Johnson said. “I just go out there and play.”

I don’t know which direction Mike Tomlin is leaning or if he even will provide any insight during his Tuesday press briefing at noon. But I’m guessing he will go back to Pickett. He pushed hard to draft him. He, too, has to want to see what Pickett can do under the most intense pressure.

It’s not as if Tomlin showed any faith in Rudolph before Saturday’s game when he finally started him after losing all confidence in Mitch Trubisky. The Steelers signed Trubisky and drafted Pickett before the 2022 season, relegating Rudolph to third string. Rudolph’s prior start was against the Detroit Lions in Week 10 of the 2021 season. He took no snaps in 2022 and just six in mop-up duty for Trubisky against the Indianapolis Colts on Dec. 16.

Advertise with us

Rudolph acknowledged he wondered if the start against the Bengals would be his final start for the Steelers or for any NFL team, for that matter. He will be a free agent after the season. He returned to the Steelers on a one-year, $1.08 million deal before this season only because no other team showed much interest in him.

“You’ve got confidence in yourself as a player, but you’re kind of wondering, ‘Am I going to jump into the commercial real estate realm next year or be playing quarterback?’” Rudolph said after the win against the Bengals, before adding how wonderful it felt to be “earning my paycheck and not just feeling like a freeloader.”

Saturday’s game made for a wonderful story for Rudolph.

But it’s time to go back to Pickett.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.