The question came last week to the Post-Gazette’s Pitt mailbag:
“Could Pat Narduzzi, Heather Lyke both be gone next year?”
“I’d say collectively it’s probably 50-50 right now,” Pitt beat man Noah Hiles answered.
“I think it’s more likely that Narduzzi sticks around, but I wouldn’t be shocked if both were gone by the start of next season,” Hiles’ partner, Chris Carter, responded.
The topic fascinates me.
Lyke has been linked to the Ohio State athletic director’s job, which will become vacant in the spring when long-time athletic director Gene Smith retires. That is, without question, one of the top college jobs in the country. Lyke was an assistant athletic director at Ohio State from 1998-2013. She would be a fool not to take the position if it is offered.
Read More
Narduzzi has been mentioned as a candidate for the Michigan State football job, which became open Wednesday when Mel Tucker was fired. Narduzzi was defensive coordinator at Michigan State under Mark Dantonio for eight highly successful seasons from 2007-14. He would be a fool not to take the job if offered.
The Ohio State athletic department is much stronger than Pitt’s for a number of reasons, the top one being its security in the powerful and lucrative Big Ten, which has it all over the ACC.
The Michigan State football job is better than Pitt’s football job, primarily for the exact same reason.
I’m not sure Pitt will have a place in major college football when additional conference realignment happens.
I’m thinking Lyke and Narduzzi aren’t sure, either.
Ohio State would be crazy not to have Lyke near the top — if not at the top — of its wishlist. She has done marvelous work since coming to Pitt in March 2017. She has changed the culture of the Pitt athletic department. Just about all of its sports programs are better. So are its sports facilities. I’m talking a night-and-day difference.
I’m not sure about Narduzzi’s chances at Michigan State. His resume isn’t nearly as impressive as Lyke’s. His Pitt team this season was off to a 1-3 start before its game Saturday night at Virginia Tech. It is looking at another five-loss season — or worse — with a brutal schedule ahead with a home game against No. 5 Florida State and road games at No. 11 Notre Dame and No. 17 Duke. That would make seven mostly mediocre seasons for Narduzzi in his nine years at Pitt.
Would that interest Michigan State?
I have serious doubts.
Lyke would be hard to replace for obvious reasons.
Surprisingly, Narduzzi, who is under contract at Pitt through 2030, also would be hard to replace.
It is not a reach to say Narduzzi is Pitt’s most successful coach since Jackie Sherrill more than 40 years ago. Mostly mediocre seems pretty good considering where Pitt was for many of those past four decades. Walt Harris had his moments after taking over Pitt’s forlorn program in January 1997, but his success can’t match Narduzzi’s. Narduzzi has brought stability to a program that badly needed it. Pitt had eight coaches — including interims — in the five years before his arrival in December 2014.
There is something positive to be said about a coach who didn’t look at the Pitt job as a stepping stone.
But Narduzzi didn’t help himself here with his comments after an ugly loss to rival West Virginia in Morgantown on Sept. 16. He talked of Pittsburgh being “Boo City, Pa.,” after his quarterback and his offense were booed at Acrisure Stadium a week earlier during a loss to Cincinnati. I would have laughed at the pictures of fans wearing “Boo City” T-shirts at the home game against North Carolina last Saturday night if it wasn’t so sad.
My guess?
Lyke leaves.
Narduzzi stays.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.