9-8.
Third place in the AFC North.
No playoffs.
That’s my story, and I’m sticking to it.
Sorry.
I’m not quite ready to buy into the hysterical hype surrounding the Steelers, based mostly on their strong offensive showing in three wins in three meaningless exhibition games. I’m not quite willing to think Kenny Pickett will become a Top 10 quarterback this season after ranking 24th in completion percentage and 33rd in passer rating last season despite his heroics on late-season, game-winning drives against the Las Vegas Raiders and Baltimore Ravens. And I’m definitely not ready to think Matt Canada will become the NFL’s next play-calling genius after his offense averaged just 18.1 points per game last season and was described as “amateurish” and “Saturday-ish” by a couple of league insiders.
But that’s just me.
I mean, it really does feel like it’s just me.
I turned on ESPN late last week and heard the experts gush about Pickett. Louis Riddick, an unapologetic Pitt man, said, “The guy is ready to explode.” Harry Douglas said, “I love Kenny Pickett.” And this from Damien Woody: “If Kenny Pickett is anything like he was in the preseason, a lot of teams are going to be in trouble.”
Pickett was superb in those three games. He led five drives that produced five touchdowns. He had nice touchdown passes down the middle to George Pickens and Pat Freiermuth. He had equally impressive deep sideline throws to Diontae Johnson and Pickens. His passer rating was a perfect 158.3.
“You couldn’t script it better than what happened,” Canada said on Thursday, acknowledging that the wins don’t count in the standings.
Here’s my hang-up with the hype:
Pickett played just 26 snaps in those five drives, 19 of which came against the second defense of bad Tampa Bay and Atlanta teams.
Is that enough to think Pickett is ready to become the next Joe Burrow?
Not for me.
Clearly, Pickett has all of the intangibles. His knowledge and understanding of the game are top-notch. His work ethic is second to none. His teammates think enough of him that they voted him the offensive captain last week in just his second season. There is no reason to doubt Canada, who called Pickett “a commanding leader.”
“I’m not looking to prove anything,” Pickett said. “I’m looking to go out and win; find a way to win.”
Perfect attitude, right?
Pickett still has much to prove.
So does Canada.
The man is in a rough spot. If Pickett and his playmakers thrive, they will get all of the credit. If the offense fails, it will be all Canada’s fault. No one will blame Pickett, who has been beloved here since his terrific senior season at Pitt.
Canada and Mike Tomlin, for that matter, need to give Pickett his best chance to succeed. They need to trust him and give him the freedom to change plays at the line of scrimmage. They need to trust him to throw down the middle of the field and take some deep shots, the risk of interceptions be damned. They need to give him a little freedom if he is going to develop into a Top 10 quarterback.
“We all love the game plan,” Pickett, a noted Canada supporter, said Wednesday. “We’re definitely confident and way ahead of where we were a year ago. I think everyone is buying in.”
That was easy to do in those exhibition wins. It will be a little harder in the opening game Sunday against San Francisco. The 49ers had the NFL’s best defense last season and made it to the NFC championship game. They will have edge rusher Nick Bosa, the league’s Defensive Player of the Year last season, who was rewarded last week after his summer-long holdout with the richest contract for a defensive player in NFL history. They are 2½-point favorites despite the game being in Pittsburgh.
“There’s a good vibe with our guys,” Canada said. “We’re coming into it with the right mindset. We’re healthy right now. The guys are excited to play.
“We feel really good about the weapons we have on the outside, the pass-catchers, the running backs. They take one guy away, we should be able to go somewhere else to have success on the play.”
I want to believe. I really do. I’m just not quite ready.
I need to see more.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show on weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.