How much would you have bet the Pirates wouldn’t be the team in town to give a player the most guaranteed money in Pittsburgh sports history?
I would have bet $106.75 million against it.
That’s the guaranteed money the Pirates are giving to Bryan Reynolds. That’s slightly more than Sidney Crosby received in his 12-year, fully guaranteed $104.4 million contract with the Penguins, signed before the 2012-13 season. It is significantly more than the $80 million in guaranteed money T.J. Watt received in his then-record four-year, $112 million contract with the Steelers, signed before the 2021 season. And it is way more than the $37.5 million in guarantees that Ben Roethlisberger took home in his most lucrative deal with the Steelers, signed before the 2019 season.
The Pirates.
Really.
Yet the deal seems like a big win for the team. Reynolds’ salary for the next eight years will average about $13.3 million a year. That’s not only less than half of Watt’s yearly pay, it would rank 20th among MLB outfielders this season. Reynolds quickly will drop down that list the way salaries go up each year.
Read More
The Pirates also were able to get the deal done without agreeing to Reynolds’ wish for an opt-out after the fourth season. Beyond that, they retained the right to trade him at any point of the contract. They have protection knowing they can move him if they don’t like his production or if one of the young outfielders in their farm system proves to be a better option in their lineup.
Not that anybody was thinking about a trade Tuesday.
“I hope Bryan Reynolds is here for a long time,” manager Derek Shelton said soon after news of the Reynolds’ deal broke.
I know, there are no guarantees for the team when it comes to these big contracts.
Kevin McClatchy signed Jason Kendall to a six-year, $60 million contract in November 2000, a few months before PNC Park opened. Kendall was popular among Pirates fans and played the game hard every day. But he was a singles hitter. The deal set the franchise back for years.
More recently, the Pirates signed Gregory Polanco to a five-year, $35 million contract before the 2016 season. It seemed like a steal for the team at the time because Polanco was just 24 and had the look of a future star. But he never lived up to the contract. It turned out to be a bad deal for the Pirates.
Not every contract works out for a team the way Andrew McCutchen’s did with the Pirates. He signed a six-year, $51.5 million contract before the 2012 season, became the face of the franchise’s resurrection from 20 consecutive years of losing and was National League MVP in 2013. He outperformed his contract to the point he probably cost himself millions.
I’m guessing we’ll look back at Reynolds’ contract and evaluate it somewhere between Polanco’s deal and McCutchen’s deal.
Reynolds is a good player, maybe even a really good player. But he is not a star player. He’s also going to be 29 before next season. Production for many players tends to drop off in their early-30s. It’s almost impossible to believe the Pirates will pick up Reynolds’ $20 million option in 2031, when he will be 36.
That’s why Reynolds also wins with this contract. He is set for life financially regardless of how he plays during the next eight years or if he gets injured. His kids are set. So are their kids.
There is plenty to be said for that kind of security.
There are no losers here.
That includes Pirates fans.
For years, people around here have been screaming for Bob Nutting to pay and keep his better players. He hasn’t just done that with Reynolds. He has committed more guaranteed money to a player than the Rooneys or the Burkle/Lemieux ownership group ever did.
Bob Nutting.
Really.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.