The worst trade in Pirates his­tory be­came a lit­tle worse shortly af­ter 7:10 Mon­day night. That’s when Shane Baz walked to the Trop­i­cana Field mound for the Tampa Bay Rays and threw his first pitch in the big leagues to To­ronto Blue Jays des­ig­nated hit­ter George Springer. Baz is just 22 and sky­rock­eted through the Rays’ mi­nor-league sys­tem af­ter join­ing the or­ga­ni­za­tion from the Pirates at the trade dead­line in July 2018. He is con­sid­ered the best pros­pect on a team that has all but clinched the rug­ged Amer­i­can League East Divi­sion.

And to think, Baz was con­sid­ered a throw-in in the deal that also sent Austin Mead­ows and Tyler Glas­now to the Rays for vet­eran pitcher Chris Archer.

Who knows? Baz might turn out to be the best player in the trade, al­though he has a ways to go to sur­pass Mead­ows and Glas­now. Mead­ows had 33 home runs and 89 RBIs in 2019 and had 25 home runs and 100 RBIs go­ing into the game Mon­day night. Glas­now was con­sid­ered a Cy Young con­tender be­fore get­ting hurt this sea­son and hav­ing Tommy John sur­gery in Au­gust.

What we know for sure is Archer was a com­plete bust for the Pirates and that the trade set the team back in the most hurt­ful way.

Advertise with us

Go­ing into Mon­day night, the Rays have been 264-163 since their heist, went to the play­offs in 2019, lost in six games in the World Ser­ies to the Los An­ge­les Dodgers in 2020 and are clos­ing in on that di­vi­sion ti­tle this sea­son.

The Pirates were 170-254 since the deal and fin­ished fourth, fifth and fifth in the Na­tional League Cen­tral stand­ings from 2018-20 and are go­ing to be last in the di­vi­sion again this sea­son with the very real po­ten­tial of los­ing 100 games.

Did I men­tion the Rays com­mit­ted bla­tant rob­bery?

I used to think the Aramis Ramirez trade in July 2003 was the worst in Pirates his­tory. They sent him and Kenny Lofton to the Chi­cago Cubs for Jose Her­nan­dez, Matt Bruback and Bobby Hill. Ramirez went on to have a strong big-league ca­reer.

But Pirates gen­eral man­ager Dave Lit­tle­field made that trade un­der du­ress. I be­lieve he was or­dered to dump Ramirez’s sal­ary that night — July 23, a week be­fore the dead­line — and get back what­ever he could, which turned out to be al­most noth­ing.

Advertise with us

But Baz’s rapid as­cent to the Rays sealed the Archer trade as the Pirates’ worst. He started this sea­son with Class AA Mont­gom­ery and went 2-4 with a 2.48 earned run av­er­age in seven starts. He pitched in the MLB Fu­tures All-Star game in July and for Team USA in the To­kyo Olym­pics in July and Au­gust. In five starts with Class AAA Durham af­ter re­turn­ing from To­kyo, he had a 1.57 ERA with 31 strike­outs and three walks in 23 in­nings. He has a fast­ball that can touch 100 mph and a plus-slider that can hit 90 mph.

“To move through Dou­ble-A and Tri­ple-A, he ad­vanced his pro­gres­sion about as much as any of us could have imag­ined,” Rays man­ager Kevin Cash told the Tampa Bay Times. “We’re ex­cited to get him up here and hand him the ball.”

What re­ally must pain Neal Hun­ting­ton, who made the trade for Archer, is that it went against all of his in­stincts. He cov­eted his young pros­pects and made the deal only be­cause the Pirates went on a 15-4 run, in­clud­ing an 11-game win­ning streak, to climb into wild-card con­ten­tion.

I ad­mit, I was all for the trade at the time.

“What a dif­fer­ence this day was from the aw­ful Jan­u­ary week­end when [Hun­ting­ton] traded Ger­rit Cole and An­drew McCutchen in what looked to be sal­ary dumps,” I wrote. “Those deals were widely crit­i­cized — in­side the club­house and out — lead­ing many fans to boy­cott the team. [This deal was] cheered in the club­house and should go a long way to­ward win­ning the fans back. I know they won me back. I was a guy who wrote many times it’s al­ways about next year with the Pirates. Now, fi­nally, it’s about now.”

Advertise with us

What non­sense.

Archer went 3-3 with a 4.30 ERA in 10 starts with the Pirates in 2018. The team went 26-27 af­ter the trade. So much for that wild-card spot. Archer was 3-9 with a 5.19 ERA in 23 starts in 2019 and missed all of the 2020 sea­son af­ter tho­racic sur­gery. The team de­clined to pick up his $11 mil­lion op­tion for this sea­son.

So Hun­ting­ton and I were very wrong about the Archer trade.

But there was a big dif­fer­ence be­tween the two of us.

My opin­ion didn’t mat­ter. Hun­ting­ton was paid to get it right. He didn’t.

Advertise with us

No need to won­der why Hun­ting­ton no lon­ger is on the Pirates’ pay­roll.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.