It would have been so easy for Jim Rutherford to back a star player and fire his coach. That’s the way it’s done in sports, right? That’s especially true in the NHL, which has less respect for its coaches than any other professional league.

Good for the Penguins that Rutherford did the right thing, not the easy thing.

Last week, Rutherford traded Phil Kessel, a gifted player who clearly had worn out his welcome with Mike Sullivan. Friday, Rutherford gave Sullivan a four-year contract extension that will take him through the 2023-24 season.

Those are Rutherford’s two best moves of a busy offseason.

Advertise with us

Each makes perfect sense.

Each will make the Penguins better, next season and beyond.

Sullivan overcame significant odds to get his extension. I wondered if he would last if the team got off to a slow start next season after the past two playoffs when it was swept in the first round by the New York Islanders and taken out in the second round by the Washington Capitals. It’s not as if the franchise has a history of being coach-supportive. That goes back to the days when Mario Lemieux’s team chased off Scotty Bowman, the NHL’s greatest coach and maybe the best coach in any sport. Before Dan Bylsma, the Penguins, who joined the NHL in 1967, had not had a coach start and finish four consecutive seasons. The Steelers, by comparison, have had three coaches since 1969.

Now, Sullivan is a virtual lock to break Bylsma’s longevity record of 5⅓ seasons. He won’t have to look over his shoulder at Mike Vellucci, the Calder Cup-winning coach who was just hired by the Penguins for their Wilkes-Barre/Scranton farm team. Sullivan knows as well as anyone how the organization likes to promote its coaches from within. He, Bylsma and Michel Therrien all were at Wilkes-Barre/Scranton.

There had been speculation that the Rutherford-Sullivan marriage had soured significantly since the Sullivan-coached Penguins won the Stanley Cup in 2016 and 2017. Much of it had merit. Rutherford traded for Ryan Reaves, but Sullivan didn’t play him. Rutherford talked up Daniel Sprong, but Sullivan didn’t play him. Rutherford signed Jack Johnson as a free agent and passionately defended his play, but Sullivan made him a healthy scratch for Game 1 against the Islanders.

Advertise with us

Rutherford also took what appeared to be a veiled shot at Sullivan’s coaching after that Islanders series by saying the Penguins produced an “uncomfortable” 100 points and never really came together as a team. If there was a chemistry issue in the room, doesn’t Sullivan have to take at least partial blame for it? Doesn’t he have to ask what he could do better for the team? Doesn’t he have to at least consider tweaking his coaching style?

Sullivan is a smart man and a terrific coach.

I’m guessing that’s exactly how he is spending his offseason.

There was no reason to break up the Rutherford-Sullivan marriage. Sullivan’s extension is proof that each is comfortable working with the other. Each is driven to win another Cup.

I’m not ruling that out.

Advertise with us

Rutherford promised changes after the debacle against the Islanders and delivered. Out are Kessel and Olli Maatta and, perhaps soon to follow, Nick Bjugstad or Bryan Rust. In are forwards Alex Galchenyuk, Brandon Tanev and Dominik Kahun.

I like all of the moves.

Kessel devotees disagree, of course. I can think of only a handful of Penguins who were more popular among the fans. They like that Kessel looks a lot like many of us — balding and paunchy. They loved his production, not just last season when he averaged a point a game, but in the Cup years. The Penguins wouldn’t have won either without him.

But it was time for Kessel to go, just as it was in Toronto before he came here and in Boston before that. He is difficult to coach. He doesn’t like to practice. He too often would have defensive lapses. He eventually will drive his new coach, Rick Tocchet, crazy in Arizona.

Sullivan will be a better coach without Kessel at this point of Kessel’s career.

Advertise with us

Give Rutherford credit for recognizing that and betting big on Sullivan.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.