Baseball always has been my favorite sport. I hate when I hear people say it’s in trouble, but I know it’s true. Attendance and television ratings are down. The games are too long. There isn’t enough action. There are too many strikeouts.

I went searching for solutions this week.

The first person I called was Jim Leyland, the smartest man I’ve known in baseball.

“It’s a great game and I love it and it’s going to be fine, but, no, I don’t like where it is right now,” he said.

Advertise with us

Let’s start with Leyland’s two pet peeves: five-inning starting pitchers and strikeouts.

“I hate when a starting pitcher goes five innings and they say he gave his team a chance to win. Five innings and 100 pitches every night? That makes me sick. That’s not a good performance. That’s killing the bullpens. …

“I like home runs, but it’s not OK for all guys to strike out. It was OK for Babe Ruth and Mickey Mantle. It’s OK for some of today’s big home run hitters. But there are too many little guys in every lineup who can’t hit home runs and are swinging for the fences. We’re not setting up the big guys. I think it’s bad for the game.”

The strikeouts have a negative impact on baseball’s two biggest problems – length of game and a lack of action.

Leyland said he understands baseball’s desire to make the game more attractive to a younger audience.

Advertise with us

“I know our job is to entertain our customers. I support that 100 percent,” he said. “But I’m not in favor of changes that take strategy out of the game.”

Baseball will implement a rule next season that will force a relief pitcher to face at least three batters unless it’s the end of an inning or if there’s an injury. That’s to prevent the endless procession of three or four relievers coming into a game in one inning.

“I don’t like it at all,” Leyland said. “That’s not allowing a manager to do what he thinks is necessary to win a game. You can’t take away strategy like that. …

“You want to speed up the game? Have the hitter get in the batter’s box and hit. They’re waiting for their walk-up music. They’re playing with the donut on their bat in the on-deck circle. They’re messing with their batting gloves. Hitters slow down the game a lot more than the pitchers. Get ’em up to the plate. That will speed up the game as much as anything.”

Leyland also has a suggestion about the showboating in baseball. Guys are flipping their bat after a home run and standing at the plate and admiring it. Pitchers are taking offense and staring down the hitters. Or worse, they’re throwing at them. We saw the Pirates’ Chris Archer throw behind Cincinnati’s Derek Dietrich after a home run April 7.

Advertise with us

“I had a conversation with [chief baseball officer] Joe Torre about this a month ago,” Leyland said. “I recommended he get together with the players and the managers and let them decide if this is all right. My problem is, one guy flips the bat for one team and nobody says anything. Somebody else does it for the other team and they want to drill somebody. It can’t be that way. Get everybody together and say, ‘What do you guys want? Come to an agreement. This is acceptable and this is not. Let’s play baseball.’”

That doesn’t mean pitchers can’t pitch inside, Leyland said. It’s not intentional every time a batter is hit by a pitch. Batters have to realize that.

“I think sometimes when a guy gets hit, his first reaction might be to get a little upset because it hurts,” Leyland said. “He might not think the pitcher threw at him, but he’ll make a gesture. Just don’t overreact. Use common sense.”

As for Pirates starter Joe Musgrove’s ejection June 10 after a stare-down with Atlanta’s Josh Donaldson, who started toward him?

“Based on what I saw happen, I don’t think Musgrove should have been thrown out,” Leyland said.

Advertise with us

A few other topics and Leyland’s thoughts:

• On the Pirates: “I still like them. I think it’s a little too early to quit on them and start selling off players. [Trevor] Williams is back. He’s a very good pitcher. [Felipe Vazquez] might be the best closer in baseball. If they can put together six out of eight or seven out of 10 and do that a couple of times, I truly believe they can get back in this thing. I think they’re talented enough to do it, especially because of the closer.”

• On Josh Bell: “He’s centering the ball all the time and putting a good stroke on it. He’s turning on it when he needs to and staying back and going the other way when he has to. He’s just a pleasure to watch.”

• On Archer: “His stuff is plenty good enough. I just think sometimes pitchers get too proud of their stuff. They think they can just throw it anywhere and get away with it. I think that’s what might be happening with him. You don’t get away with that in the big leagues.”

• On replay: “I think it’s great. The idea is to get it right so the right team wins the game. I don’t think fans care if it takes a few extra minutes as long as their team wins. Pirates fans just want to raise the Jolly Roger.”

Advertise with us

• On computers calling balls and strikes: “I don’t ever want to see that. I think the umpires do an unbelievable job. They’re going to miss a pitch here and there. Some go in your favor, some go against you. But I think they’re better than ever, especially with so many relief pitchers coming in throwing it 98 or 100 mph.”

• On shifts: “I’m not saying there isn’t something to them. But I’ve also seen shifts cost a team a game when they give up an extra out because there’s nobody to cover second base for a double play. I think they’re overrated.”

• On competitive balance: “It’s a problem right now. Too many teams are in a rebuilding situation. With the extra wild card, there should be more teams that have a chance. It’s great for baseball to have teams involved going into September. We don’t have enough. If you put a winning product on the field, the fans are going to come out.”

Leyland still lives in Pittsburgh and goes to games at PNC Park. He will be 75 on Dec. 15 and is mostly retired, although he still does work for commissioner Rob Manfred and talks regularly with Torre.

“I’m not at the head of their class by any means,” Leyland said. “I’m more like the low man on the totem pole.”

Advertise with us

Manfred and Torre should take a lesson from me.

They should call Leyland first and listen to him.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.