Whatever happened to the best outfield in baseball?

That’s what I called the Pirates’ outfield of Starling Marte, Andrew McCutchen and Gregory Polanco early in the 2015 season.

I’m thinking I might have been a bit premature.

I didn’t see McCutchen declining so quickly after he was National League MVP in 2013. I also thought Marte and Polanco would be better than they are. I don’t believe there would be the same level of angst surrounding the Chris Archer trade if Marte and Polanco were playing better. As it is, there’s an inescapable feeling the Pirates picked the wrong outfielder – Austin Meadows – to trade because Meadows is tearing it up for the Tampa Bay Rays.

Advertise with us

McCutchen had another fine season in 2015 before his game started slipping. He always should be remembered as a sports hero in Pittsburgh because he led the Pirates to three consecutive playoff appearances after 20 consecutive losing season. But the team made a smart call in trading him to San Francisco after the 2017 season, getting Bryan Reynolds and Kyle Crick in return. That might be Neal Huntington’s best trade.

Confounding is the best word to describe Marte. The man oozes athleticism, more than anyone on the Pirates. He showed that again Sunday when he forced Milwaukee pitcher Zach Davies to throw away his bunt single and easily ended up on third base. But Marte too often wastes some of his fabulous talent, being benched last season for failing to hustle and getting suspended in 2017 for 80 games because of performance-enhancing drugs. At the plate, he’ll often chase unhittable pitches. On the bases, he’ll lose track of the outs or foolishly try to take an extra base when it’s not there. I have questioned his baseball I.Q. for years.

Marte’s day Saturday against the Brewers was fairly typical of his career. He had four hits, including a rocket of a three-run home run off terrific closer Josh Hader that gave the Pirates a 10-8 lead in the eighth inning. But when Marte batted in the 12th inning with the bases loaded and one out in a 10-10 game, he bounced into a force out at the plate.

No matter what Marte does, we’re left wanting more and expecting more.

The same is true of Polanco, who has been consistently inconsistent. He had decent numbers last season – 23 home runs, 81 RBIs – before injuring his knee and shoulder with one of the worst slides in baseball history. He missed most of the first month this season and has yet to find his way. He hasn’t had a multi-hit game since May 12 and is hitting .175 with 23 strikeouts in 57 at-bats since then. He went 2 for 15 with eight strikeouts in the weekend series against the Brewers.

Advertise with us

It’s easy to suggest Reynolds and Melky Cabrera should get a lot more playing time than Polanco.

It’s even easier to suggest the Pirates would be better off with Meadows in one of their outfield spots. He was considered McCutchen’s heir apparent all along, but Huntington presumably felt comfortable trading him along with Tyler Glasnow for Archer — a disappointment to this point — because he believed the team would get more from Marte and Polanco. Meadows is hitting .357 with 12 home runs, 37 RBIs and a 1.085 OPS for the Rays.

Marte is signed for $11.5 million next season and $12.5 million in 2021, although the Pirates have a $2 million buyout option each season. I will not be surprised if Huntington looks to trade him before the deadline at the end of July. One of the outfielders almost certainly is going to have to go when Corey Dickerson — a free agent at the end of the season — finally returns from the injured list. I’m not trading Reynolds, who looks like the real deal at the plate and in the field. Cabrera should be highly attractive to contending teams as a bench player but wouldn’t bring much in return.

Polanco is signed for four more seasons at $8.6 million, $11.6 million, $12.5 million and $12.5 million. The Pirates have a $3 million buyout option in 2022 and one for $1 million in 2023. I’m not sure how tradeable he is, not just because he’s so streaky as a hitter, but also because he’s below-average in the field and can’t throw well because of his shoulder surgery.

All of that means there’s a good chance the Pirates’ outfield next season will be Reynolds, Marte and Polanco.

Advertise with us

No, I won’t make the mistake of calling it the best outfield in baseball.

You can’t accuse me of not being a fast learner.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.