Remember when sports were simple and fun to watch? When you actually knew who won and lost?

The thrill of victory and the agony of defeat, right?

I miss those days.

What a start to 2019 it has been in sports. The wrong team went to the Super Bowl because of a horribly blown call by the officials that wasn’t reviewable. The wrong team won the national championship in men’s basketball because of a botched call that wasn’t reviewable and one that was but took forever to finalize. The wrong team advanced in the Stanley Cup playoffs because of a missed, non-reviewable call that was so bad it forced the NHL to apology to the losing team. And, finally, the topper Saturday night, the wrong horse won the Kentucky Derby — the fastest 2 minutes in sports — based on video review that went on and on and on …

Advertise with us

The slowest 22 minutes in sports?

This is fun?

I always have been a replay guy, a devoted “get-it-right” guy. I hated, for instance, that Tigers pitcher Armando Galarraga was denied a perfect game by an obvious blown call at first base by umpire Jim Joyce and that Johan Santana was given the undeserved gift of the only no-hitter in Mets history because third-base umpire Adrian Johnson couldn’t tell a fair ball from a foul ball. But I’m wavering. The Derby might have put me over the edge. My eyes told me Maximum Security was the easy winner. The Churchill Downs stewards eventually told me differently after going to the video tape again and again and again before determining Maximum Security veered off his path and had to be disqualified. That made 65-1 long shot Country House the winner even if he wouldn’t have caught Maximum Security if they had run another mile-and-a-quarter.

Talk about anticlimactic.

Not even Country House’s connections wanted to win that way.

Advertise with us

It could have been worse for me, I guess. I could have been in Maximum Security’s camp and thought I had made racing history only to have it snatched away. Or I could have been among those who bet a total of $6.2 million on Maximum Security to win. That would have really hurt.

My biggest problem with replay is I no longer have any idea what is reviewable and what isn’t. The missed pass-interference call that sent the Los Angeles Rams to Super Bowl LIII instead of the New Orleans Saints was not reviewable. Nor was the phantom major cross-checking penalty against Vegas’ Cody Eakin that led to four power-play goals by San Jose and sent the Sharks to a Game 7 win. I’m guessing the apology from the league did not make the Golden Knights feel much better.

No team benefited more from replay — or lack of it — than national champion Virginia. In a semifinal game at the Final Four, officials missed a blatant double-dribble violation by Virginia’s Ty Jerome that led to its 63-62 win against Auburn. The play was not reviewable. In the championship game, Virginia’s De’Andre Hunter knocked the ball away from Texas Tech’s Davide  Moretti, out of bounds. But extensive and exhausting replay — emphasis on exhausting — showed the ball grazed off Moretti’s pinky. Virginia took possession and went on to win, 85-77, in overtime.

After that fiasco and the farce at the Derby, I’m ready to ditch all replay and live once again with the human element of sports. There’s no way replay should be allowed to take that long to finalize a call. It was designed to correct obvious mistakes, not to be studied as if it were the Zapruder tape.

But I know we’re not going back. Replay is here to stay, fallible as it is. The only solution is to make everything reviewable. That includes having balls and strikes called by computer. I hate the thought, but that’s where we are headed.

Advertise with us

The NFL is leading the way. Bowing to pressure from the Saints and their fans and presumably against its better judgment, it will allow, for the first time, coach’s challenges on pass-interference plays next season, including when a call isn’t made on the field.

I have two thoughts:

One, don’t we see enough of Al Riveron as it is? Now we have to watch him throw a flag from his New York office?

And two, this challenge will be one more that Mike Tomlin will get wrong.

Not to be critical.

Advertise with us

The Saints and their fans must be thrilled even though it’s too little, too late to get their team to the Super Bowl. The Saints tweeted out a single emoji after the Derby that seemed to applaud the stewards for using replay correctly. Their fans also were happy for Country House’s connections and fans even though they, better than anyone, could appreciate the misery of Maximum Security’s side.

I saw two tweets Saturday night that made me laugh out loud. The first came from national betting expert Todd Fuhrman:

“Saints fans have now filed an inquiry at Churchill Downs hoping for an overrule.”

The second — the perfect follow-up, if you will — was from sports analyst Eric Rosenthal:

“The Kentucky Derby officials just announced it was pass interference and the Saints are going to the Super Bowl.”

Advertise with us

Laughing beats crying, right?

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.