I expected so much more from Penn State-Pitt Saturday night.
It surely was the final game of the wonderful series in Pittsburgh of my 80-year career, probably of my lifetime. Darn right I wanted more.
So did Pat Narduzzi, who apologized for Pitt’s 51-6 loss.
“That was not Pitt football right there.”
Sadly, it was.
The many Penn State fans who helped to fill Heinz Field to capacity enjoyed it a lot more than I did or Narduzzi did. The previous time their team played in Pittsburgh, in 2016, Pitt won, 42-39, likely costing Penn State a chance to play for the national championship. Those title hopes remain very much alive after this latest Penn State win, although the Nittany Lions didn’t look much like a championship team to me, that ridiculous final score notwithstanding. Pitt just played a lot worse. It was embarrassingly bad, as bad as I’ve seen it in years and years.
Read More
The raw, windy conditions were a factor. The game was played in a steady, cold drizzle. You have to think that figured in a brutally rough night for Pitt punter/back-up holder Kirk Christodoulou, who failed to handle the snap on an extra-point try and a field-goal attempt and also dropped a punt snap late in the first half. Penn State quickly turned that final blunder into a 14-yard touchdown pass from Trace McSorley to KJ Hamler for a 14-6 halftime lead.
I haven’t felt that bad for a Pitt athlete since Nasir Robinson’s ill-timed foul against Butler in the 2011 NCAA basketball tournament when Pitt was a No. 1 seed. Pitt football fans must have had a nightmarish flashback to holder Andrew Janocko’s mishandling of an extra-point snap against Cincinnati in a 2009 loss that might have cost Pitt a trip to the Sugar Bowl.
But this loss wasn’t on Christodoulou alone. Pitt’s offense had twice as many yards as Penn State’s in the first half but could manage just one touchdown. Kenny Pickett, who swallowed a big dose of adversity for the first time in his young career, threw an interception on first down from the Penn State 31. Pitt running back Qadree Ollison, who had a big night with 119 yards and a touchdown, was stopped for a 3-yard loss off right tackle on fourth-and-3 at the Penn State 4. It was a baffling play-call by Pitt offensive coordinator Shawn Watson. It failed miserably, right?
“Kids want to go. I want to go. We’re playing to win,” Narduzzi said. “Probably the biggest turning point was that play right there.”
The Pitt mistakes continued in the second half, one after another. Tackle Stefano Millin was called for holding in the end zone, resulting in a safety. An illegal-block penalty on Dane Jackson nullified a long punt return by Rafael Araujo-Lopes. Pitt allowed a 39-yard punt return for a touchdown by DeAndre Thompkins after a poor punt by Christodoulou. Pitt just couldn’t get out of its own way. It’s pretty easy to say Narduzzi didn’t have his team ready to play. He said it. “In any capacity.” It’s really easy to suggest the Pitt team showed no heart or character in the second half and gave up on its coach when it was outscored, 37-0. Some will suggest Penn State coach James Franklin poured it on to excess more than he would against, say, Akron, but Pitt deserved every bit of the fanny-kicking. This is Narduzzi’s fourth season. Shame on him.
“I’ll take it all,” Narduzzi said of the criticism.
Penn State had its own problems. Its defense was gashed for 214 rushing yards in the first half, although it stiffened significantly in the second half after the Nittany Lions built their lead. An illegal-block penalty against Brandon Polk wiped out a 70-something-yard run by running back Miles Sanders and an offensive pass interference penalty against wide receiver Juwan Johnson nullified a 64-yard touchdown pass from McSorley to Sanders. Sanders still finished with 118 rushing yards.
The game really was hard to watch.
But even if this was my final Penn State-Pitt game here — the series is going on hiatus again after the teams play in Happy Valley next season with no plans for it to resume — I have no right to complain. I was blessed to watch some terrific games between the two schools in Pittsburgh.
That one in 2016 stands out. It was the first game in the series since Joe Paterno selfishly and peevishly ended it for 16 years after the 2000 game. Nathan Peterman threw three touchdown passes, James Conner rushed for 117 yards and a touchdown and cornerback Ryan Lewis intercepted McSorley in the end zone to clinch it.
The 2000 game was special, as well. Pitt won, 12-0, at Three Rivers Stadium. It wasn’t just Pitt’s first win against Penn State since 1988. It meant Paterno was the loser in the final game of the series in his lifetime. Pitt fans long will celebrate that thought.
Of course, Pitt didn’t beat Paterno very often. Its most satisfying win came in 1976 when Tony Dorsett ran for 224 yards in a 24-7 victory at Three Rivers Stadium. “We finally got Joe,” Dorsett gushed after Pitt beat Paterno for the first time in 11 tries. It was all the sweeter because it pushed Pitt a big step closer to the national championship.
But Paterno had the final laugh in the most memorable Penn State-Pitt game of all in Pittsburgh. Need I say more than the final score of the 1981 game at Pitt Stadium: 48-14. Mere mention of it has the same sickening impact that 13-9 has on West Virginia fans when Pitt people bring up that score. The surreal loss in the final regular-season game of 1981 cost an undefeated Pitt team its last, best shot at the national championship. It hasn’t lost fewer than three games in any season since that 1981 season.
I am so thankful I was there to see that game.
But Saturday night?
Not so much. Not at all, really.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 the Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.