Darrelle Revis is an all-time great, a certain Hall of Famer who should be voted in on the first ballot.

I thought you would agree.

But it’s going to be much harder to reach a consensus about where Revis ranks among football legends. Among NFL cornerbacks. Among Pitt greats. Among Western Pennsylvania icons.

I have Revis as the best player to come from Aliquippa High School, although that’s hardly a unanimous opinion. I’m only considering players from the past 50 years, which eliminates Hall of Famer Mike Ditka. A mind-numbing total of 11 players from Aliquippa have played in the NFL, including Hall of Fame finalist Ty Law and former No. 1 draft picks Sean Gilbert and Jon Baldwin. Revis was the best.

Advertise with us

Remember the 2003 PIAA Class AA championship game? Revis played receiver, running back, quarterback and defensive back and returned kicks in Aliquippa’s 32-27 win against Northern Lehigh. He scored all five of Aliquippa’s touchdowns, including a 64-yard run that won the game, an 89-yard kickoff return and a 33-yard interception return.

“I was Ron Turcotte,” Aliquippa coach Mike Zmijanac said after the game. “He was the jockey who rode Secretariat years ago to the Triple Crown. We had a horse and I just said, ‘Let’s ride him.’”

It says something about Western Pennsylvania high school football that I can’t put Revis in my top five. Tony Dorsett, Joe Montana and Dan Marino might never be topped. If we’re talking strictly high school football, I also would put LaVar Arrington and Terrelle Pryor ahead of Revis. But he’s top 10, for sure.

It also says something about Pitt’s glorious football past (OK, distant past) that I again can’t put Revis in my top five, maybe not even in the top 10. Applying my half-century rule eliminates Ditka, Hall of Famer Joe Schmidt and Marshall Goldberg. Dorsett and Marino are one and two. I also have Hugh Green, Larry Fitzgerald and Bill Fralic ahead of Revis. I once asked Art Rooney Jr., scouting architect behind the Steelers dynasty of the 1970s, if he ever saw a high school player who he thought could jump right to the NFL. He said Fralic was the only one.

Revis made one of the great plays in Pitt history, a 73-yard punt return against West Virginia in 2006. It was ESPN’s play of the year in college football. But Revis played on mediocre 8-4, 5-6 and 6-6 teams. He also didn’t make first-team All-America, as did all of the others mentioned as well as Jim Covert and Mark May. And it’s not as if Revis will jump into a different category once he is elected to the Hall of Fame. Pitt has sent eight players to the Hall — tied for fourth-most with Alabama, Michigan and Syracuse behind Notre Dame (13), Southern California (12) and Ohio State (10) — including Curtis Martin, Rickey Jackson, Chris Doleman and Russ Grimm in addition to Dorsett, Marino, Ditka and Schmidt. Revis will make nine and Fitzgerald 10. There’s a good chance Aaron Donald — arguably, the most decorated Pitt player in terms of awards — will be the 11th.

Advertise with us

What a fabulous history.

I am putting Revis in my top five among NFL cornerbacks. Remember, there’s my half-century rule, which eliminates Willie Brown, Herb Adderley and Dick “Night Train” Lane. Mel Blount is No. 1. He made the NFL change its rules to protect wide receivers because he beat them up so badly. Deion Sanders is No. 2, the best cover corner of all time, so good that it made it easy to look past his critics who joked late in his career that his next tackle would be his first. I have the Woodsons — Rod and Charles — as Nos. 3 and 4. I thought long and hard about going with Darrell Green at No. 5 before settling on Revis.

I couldn’t get past Revis Island.

Revis had just 29 interceptions, a relatively low number for an 11-year NFL veteran. Rod Woodson had 71 in 17 seasons, by comparison. But, for a long time, opposing quarterbacks loathed throwing to Revis’ side of the field. It was pointless to do so. He was that good.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.

Advertise with us

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.