June has turned into July, leaving behind fascinating headlines that went beyond Justify becoming the 13th horse to win the Triple Crown, party animal Alex Ovechkin and the Washington Capitals winning their first Stanley Cup in their 44-year history and the Golden State Warriors taking their third NBA title in four years to become sports’ latest dynasty.
Three stood out, all concussion-related:
• Favre, Roethlisberger don’t want kids playing tackle football
Hall of Famer Brett Favre supports Illinois legislation that would ban tackle football for kids under 12. The bill is called the Dave Duerson Act to Prevent CTE (chronic traumatic encephalopathy, which has been linked to repeated hits to the head in football). It is named after the Chicago Bears safety who committed suicide in 2011 after battling the brain disease.
“The state level is a start, but we have to adopt this plan and all do it together,” Favre told the Daily Mail. “The body, the brain, the skull is not developed in your teens and single digits. I cringe. I see these little kids get tackled and the helmet is bigger than everything else on the kid combined. They look they’re going to break in half.”
Hall of Famer-to-be Ben Roethlisberger has two young sons, 5 and 2, and said he won’t allow them to play tackle football before fifth grade. He spoke to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Omari Sankofa II at his annual football camp for kids.
“I think early on, you need to teach the fundamentals of football — how to properly tackle, how to properly hit, throw and catch, all those things. To me, when you learn the fundamentals of football, football becomes a safer game. The kids are better prepared for it. Too many times I think the game of football is played too early in terms of full contact hitting. I’ve heard of second and third graders playing full contact football. That’s too early.”
I couldn’t agree more with Favre and Roethlisberger. I might take it a step further: No tackle football before seventh grade. Strictly flag football until then, based on what we know now about the dangers of concussions.
Favre and Roethlisberger aren’t the first prominent players to speak on this troubling issue, only the latest. Hall of Famers Terry Bradshaw, Mike Ditka, Harry Carson and Fran Tarkenton have spoken out in even stronger terms, saying they wouldn’t allow their young sons or grandsons to play football. “I think the risk is worse than the reward. I really do,” Ditka said.
I hate to hear that. I’m really worried about the future of football. It’s an amazing game and the rewards of it are tremendous. Being part of a team. Learning discipline. Getting back up when you get knocked down. Those are priceless lessons.
If I had a son, I still would let him play football if I thought his coaches were qualified and taught the proper fundamentals that Roethlisberger espoused. I’d also make sure the helmets and equipment were up-to-date and safe. I wouldn’t deprive my kid of playing football if he had a love and passion for it.
I have to admit this next headline gives me pause.
• Former Washington State quarterback diagnosed with CTE after his January suicide at 21
The parents of Tyler Hilinski said an autopsy performed after his death showed evidence of Stage 1 CTE.
“Did football kill Tyler. I don’t think so,” Kym Hilinski said in a Sports Illustrated documentary. “Did he get CTE from football? Probably. Was that the only thing that contributed to his death? I don’t know.”
Mark Hilinski told NBC’s “Today” that the autopsy determined his son “had the brain of a 65-year-old, which is really hard to take.”
Remember, Tyler Hilinski was 21.
You don’t have to be old to have CTE.
It’s easy to feel sympathy for Hilinski’s family, not so easy for the two men in the final headline.
• Boynton, Carcillo sue the NHL, claiming the league didn’t warn players about the long-term risk of fighting
Nick Boynton retired in 2011 after 12 NHL seasons, Daniel Carcillo in 2015 after nine seasons. Both are struggling with brain issues and want compensated by the NHL after making their living by trying to hurt people. Something isn’t right there. It’s fair to wonder how many opposing players are having brain issues as a result of Boynton’s and Carcillo’s illegal hits.
Boynton had 862 penalty minutes in 605 NHL games. Carcillo was involved in 103 fights – including an infamous one with the Penguins’ Max Talbot during the 2009 playoffs — and was nicknamed “Car Bomb” because of the brutal, dirty way he played the game. Each was a disgrace to hockey. Think Tom Wilson of the Capitals.
It’s true, the NHL has been much more lax with the concussion issue than the NFL. It’s the one reason you could argue commissioner Gary Bettman doesn’t belong in the Hall of Fame. The NHL continues to allow fighting and hits to the head. It almost endorses the gratuitous violence in the name of “good, hard hockey.” That’s why it’s hard to imagine the NHL ever doing the right thing by banning all hits to the head regardless of intent.
But feel sympathy for Boynton and Carcillo?
Sorry, I just can’t go there.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.