I’ve watched sports in Pittsburgh all my life. I’ve seen all of the coaches/managers, good and bad. I put Mike Sullivan near the very top of the best, right there with Jim Leyland, right behind Chuck Noll. But Sullivan didn’t have a good spring. Because the Penguins came up short against the Washington Capitals, sure. But more because his relationship with Phil Kessel appeared to go bad. I believe that contributed significantly to Kessel’s lousy play in the playoffs.
Kessel deserves much of the blame. He’s not an easy player to coach. His ego too often needs stroked. That’s why former assistant Rick Tocchet was so valuable on Sullivan’s staff. He was known as the Kessel Whisperer for good reason. But even with Tocchet, Sullivan had to be careful with the players he played with Kessel out of concern Kessel would pout if he wasn’t pleased. I think that was a problem in these playoffs. Kessel wanted to play with Evgeni Malkin. Sullivan believed Malkin was better with Patric Hornqvist. Kessel was left to play with Derick Brassard or Riley Sheahan. Like Kessel, Brassard and Sheahan did next to nothing. There was a correlation.
Kessel’s health also was an issue. Jim Rutherford said as much after the Penguins were eliminated by the Capitals in six games. “He’s actually dealt with injuries all year. I know some of the things that he dealt with caught up with him.”
That was a reasonable observation. Kessel didn’t look like the same player who had a terrific first half of the season and finished with 34 goals and a career-best 92 points. He played as if he were injured against the Capitals and the Philadelphia Flyers. It’s not just that he scored one goal in 12 games and had six of his eight assists on the power play. He didn’t shoot the puck despite having one of the best releases and best shots in the game. He attempted just 53 shots, getting 18 on goal. In last season’s run to the Cup, he had 153 attempts with 68 on goal on his way to an eight-goal, 23-point tournament. He was even more dynamic in the 2016 Cup run with 175 attempts and an NHL-best 98 on goal, finishing with 10 goals and 22 points.
Kessel had to be hurt, right?
Not so fast, Sullivan said.
Read More
Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
In a rare public disagreement with Rutherford, Sullivan didn’t allow Kessel any excuses, saying: “He was dealing with bumps and bruises just like some of our other guys. It was nothing significant, I can tell you that.” That assessment made Kessel look really bad. I’m sure Kessel really appreciates it.
My guess is Sullivan feels as if Kessel let him down. Sullivan said he talked frequently with Kessel about his late-season injuries and allowed him to keep playing — probably against his better judgment — so Kessel could keep his mind-boggling, consecutive-games streak going. It is at 692, the ninth-longest streak in NHL history. It’s 760, if you include playoff games. Kessel hasn’t missed a game since he sat out the first 12 of the 2009-10 season with Toronto after offseason shoulder surgery.
You would be disappointed and angry, too, if you were Sullivan after watching Kessel perform so poorly in the postseason.
It’s admirable that Kessel wanted to keep playing. I’ll never forget Cal Ripken Jr., saying of his 2,632-game ironman streak in baseball, “What means the most to me about it is my teammates know that I will be there for them every night.” Who can’t appreciate that?
Mike Sullivan talks about his relationship with Phil Kessel
But the streak can’t be more important than the team. I believe Kessel’s became a monster for the Penguins. I think he hurt them by not taking a few games off and getting healthier before the playoffs. I believe Sullivan, if he could do it all over again, would force Kessel to sit out a few games. Certainly, Rutherford would have preferred that. He has always said the regular season doesn’t matter as long as the team makes the postseason. It’s all about the postseason.
Kessel probably will be back with the Penguins next season even though I expect Rutherford to seriously look into trading him. Rutherford would have moved him for the right offer after the 2016-17 season but couldn’t find any takers because of Kessel’s sizable contract which runs through 2021-22 with an annual cap hit of $6.8 million. That contract again will be a problem for other teams with Kessel a year older. He turns 31 Oct. 2.
Sullivan will have a lot of work to do with Kessel before next season if Kessel is back. His biggest challenge will be clear: Rebuilding their sour relationship.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.