I never thought I would see another homecoming to Pittsburgh quite like Marc-Andre Fleury’s in February. Fans at PPG Paints Arena chanted his name during pregame warm-ups. The Penguins did a classy two-minute video tribute on the big scoreboard, as only they can, during the first television timeout. The big crowd wrapped their arms around Fleury, one of Pittsburgh’s all-time favorite athletes, with a minute-long standing ovation. And, of course, there were tears from the man of the hour. “I was happy I had a mask on,” he said after his Vegas Golden Knights lost to the Penguins, 5-4.
What an amazing evening.
There was another Friday night.
Andrew McCutchen’s homecoming was just as good, just as moving and just as powerful. Fans at PNC Park gave him a standing ovation when he took to the lawn for warm-ups and chanted “M-V-P” before he batted in the first inning. The Pirates did not one, but two nice “Thank You 22” scoreboard tributes, the crowd responding each time by pouring down its love on the player it knew, simply, as “Cutch.” And, of course, there appeared to be tears from the man of the hour. “If I cry, I cry. Big whoop. Whatever emotions I have are the emotions I’m supposed to have,” he said before his San Francisco Giants played the Pirates.
I’m lucky I was at both homecomings. I’m even luckier to have been able to watch Fleury and McCutchen and get to know them personally. For all their wondrous athletic talents, they are even better people. Good for them.
There are so many comparisons.
Read More
Fleury came to the Penguins as the NHL’s No. 1 overall draft choice in 2003. The franchise wasn’t winning Stanley Cups back then and wasn’t going to the playoffs every year. It finished with the league’s second-fewest points the season before Fleury arrived and had the fewest in his first season here. It would have left town if not for three things: The NHL lockout in 2004-05, which leveled the financial playing ice for all teams; winning the Sidney Crosby ping-pong ball lottery in 2005; and the construction of a new arena to replace aging, decaying Civic Arena.
The Pirates weren’t moving when McCutchen was their No. 1 draft choice in 2005, but they were a joke as a franchise. He made his big-league debut in 2009, a 99-loss season. The team lost 105 games under John Russell in 2010 — its 18th consecutive losing season — before starting its turnaround under Clint Hurdle in 2011.
Fleury had a lot of help in making the Penguins a Cup finalist in 2008 and Cup champion in 2009. There was Crosby, obviously, and Evgeni Malkin, the No. 2 overall pick a year earlier. Fleury wasn’t one of the NHL’s best regular-season goaltenders. He made two All-Star games with the Penguins and received Vezina Trophy votes just twice, in 2010-11 when he was eighth and in 2011-12 when he was seventh.
McCutchen was an absolute star and most responsible for the Pirates getting back to respectability and to the playoffs in 2013, 2014 and 2015. He finished third in National League MVP voting in 2012, won in 2013, finished third in 2014 and fifth in 2015. I thought he was on his way to taking his place next to Pirates icons Clemente, Stargell and Mazeroski in the Hall of Fame before his career slowed.
Fleury was the better postseason player. Pittsburgh will never forget his saves on Alex Ovechkin and Nicklas Lidstrom in the 2009 run to the Cup or the way he carried the Penguins for the first two rounds against Columbus and Washington last spring. In all, he was a part of three Cup teams.
McCutchen failed in the postseason, although eight games is a small sample size. He hit .321 but didn’t have a home run or RBI. He hardly was alone in coming up small — Neil Walker went 2 for 31 and Starling Marte 4 for 32 — but he was — everybody say it — the face of the franchise.
Fleury has found a terrific new home in Las Vegas. The Golden Knights have made it to the Western Conference final and open a series against Winnipeg Saturday night in large part because he has been the best goaltender in the playoffs. His 1.53 goals-against average, .951 save percentage and four shutouts are staggering. His 70 career postseason wins rank 10th in NHL history, his 404 regular-season wins 11th. He is headed to the Hall of Fame.
McCutchen got off to a slow start with the Giants — did we see that here or what? — but took a nine-game hitting streak into Friday night and had reached base safely in his previous 20 games. His .250 average, 3 home runs, 14 RBIs and .757 OPS still were far worse than the man who replaced him in the Pirates outfield, Corey Dickerson (.323, 5, 26, .895).
Here’s the best comparison:
Fleury and McCutchen did fabulous work in the Pittsburgh community.
Fleury has dedicated countless hours and dollars to Children’s Hospital, not just here but in Montreal. His lasting gift was construction of a new playground last summer in McKees Rocks for the Sto-Ken-Rox Boys and Girls Club.
McCutchen, who still makes Pittsburgh his home, won baseball’s Roberto Clemente Award in 2015. To me, that’s better than his MVP award because it represents not just greatness on the field, but wonderful humanitarian work off it. “I won’t say it’s a responsibility because that kind of makes it seem like work,” McCutchen said a few days before winning the Clemente Award. “It’s not a responsibility. It’s a pleasure, honestly. To be able to do this. It’s a blessing to be able to put on a uniform and be able to make a difference in someone’s life.”
So who is more popular in Pittsburgh? I say Fleury by a little bit. Who was more responsible for his team’s success? I say McCutchen by a nose. But there’s no wrong answer to either question just as there’s no debating how fortunate we were to have both men in town for as long as we did.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.