It happened almost nine years ago, but, in many ways, it seems like it was yesterday, especially at this time of year, what with March Madness and all. March 28, 2009. I was there in Boston that hurtful night and still can feel the frustration, disappointment and pain on Pitt’s side of TD Banknorth Garden. It was there for all to see on the sad, tormented faces of Jamie Dixon and DeJuan Blair.
“We really felt like we should have won the game,” Dixon said.
“We won out there,” Blair said in a voice barely above a whisper. “They just had more points than us.”
Moments earlier, Villanova’s Scottie Reynolds had ended one of the great games in NCAA tournament history and changed the course of two programs. He split Blair and Jermaine Dixon on his drive to the basket and pulled up for the shot over Gilbert Brown that gave Villanova a 78-76 win and put it in the Final Four for the first time since 1985 when it shocked defending national champion Georgetown to win the title. The loss didn’t just end Pitt’s marvelous season, one in which it matched the school record of 31 wins, made it to No. 1 in the polls for the first time, beat a No. 1 team for the first time and started the tournament as a No. 1 seed.
Now, more than ever, it seems as if it also ended Pitt’s last chance for basketball greatness.
Villanova lost big the next weekend to eventual national champion North Carolina but went on to become one of the country’s most successful programs under Jay Wright, head coach since 2001 and a former Rollie Massimino assistant at the school. It won the national championship in 2016, getting even with North Carolina in the title game when Kris Jenkins hit the winning 3-point shot at the buzzer. It is the favorite to win the championship again this season and will play LIU Brooklyn or Radford Thursday night in a first-round game at PPG Paints Arena. It is a No. 1 seed for the third time since 2009 and comes here after another 30-win season, its fourth in a row, a feat matched only by Kansas from 2010-13 in NCAA history.
Read More
And Pitt? It was a No. 1 seed again for the 2011 tournament but lost to Butler, almost unbelievably, in the second round after a horribly timed foul call against Nasir Robinson. It made the tournament three more times in the next five years under Dixon but won just one game. Clearly stale, Dixon moved on after the 2015-16 season to TCU where, revitalized, he has done a fabulous coaching job and led his alma mater this season to its first NCAA tournament in two decades. Kevin Stallings took over at Pitt and will be remembered as one of the worst hires in college basketball history. He was fired last week after just two seasons, his second ending with an 0-19 record in ACC play.
So how did we get here?
How did the Villanova program soar so high and the Pitt program fall so low?
The answer is easy for me.
Football.
Villanova doesn’t have a major-college football program and was able to stay in the reorganized Big East Conference in 2013. Its recruiting base remained the same. Nearly all of its best players come from the fertile Philadelphia area and the Northeast corridor. That includes star swingman Mikal Bridges, a likely NBA lottery pick in June, on this season’s team.
And Pitt? It had to move to the ACC in 2013 to make sure it had a spot in a power-five football conference. It was the right move — the only move — because football pays the bills. But there’s no question it crippled the basketball program. Pitt lost much of its ability to mine its natural recruiting base, which was similar to Villanova’s. The next coach has to figure that out. It will be his toughest challenge.
A tip:
Enjoy watching Villanova’s greatness this weekend. It will be a long time before you see similar greatness from Pitt.
No need to thank me for the advice.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.