I have one serious concern about the ransom the Penguins finally paid Friday night after climbing over a mountain of NHL red tape to get Ottawa center Derick Brassard in a trade. I have no problem giving up Ryan Reaves. Management will tell you Reaves served his role as a deterrent to other teams taking liberties against the Penguins stars, but he hardly played. At the risk of sounding like Neal Huntington, I don’t like giving up a No. 1 draft pick and young goaltender Filip Gustavsson, perhaps the most coveted prospect in the Penguins system. But that’s hardly my main worry. I really hate taking Ian Cole out of the team room. That aspect of the deal significantly weakens the defense and potentially alters the chemistry in a hurtful way. That troubles me.

But I keep coming back to one thing and I can’t get past it …

In Rutherford and Sullivan, I trust.

I stopped doubting Jim Rutherford and Mike Sullivan a long time ago. They have earned that respect. Rutherford built the Penguins’ two Stanley Cup winners the past two years and is headed to the Hall of Fame. Sullivan is 8 for 8 in playoff series, including 2 for 2 in Cup finals. They are terrific hockey people.

Advertise with us

The Penguins are in the unique position of trying to make history by winning a third consecutive Cup, which hasn’t been done since the New York Islanders did it in the early 1980s. It might never happen again for any team — let alone Pittsburgh’s team — in our lifetime. Rutherford would beat himself beyond recognition if he didn’t think he did everything possible to enhance the team’s chances to take advantage of such a rare opportunity.

Only an idiot would think that Brassard doesn’t make the Penguins better. He is an 18-goal scorer in 58 games this season and has been strong in the playoffs with 22 goals and 55 points in 78 career games with four game-winning goals. He will fit in wonderfully as the third-line center that Rutherford has coveted.

The Penguins won the past two seasons by rolling out four lines centered by otherworldly Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin and really good Nick Bonino and Matt Cullen. By getting Brassard, they are back to that four-center model with Crosby, Malkin, Brassard and Riley Sheahan, who has played solid hockey the past two months. Thoughts of the Penguins’ top potential three lines — Conor Sheary-Crosby-Bryan Rust, Carl Hagelin-Malkin-Patric Hornqvist and Jake Guentzel-Brassard-Kessel will keep opposing coaches up at night.

I get it that Rutherford and Sullivan think Brassard is worth going all in.

Losing the No. 1 pick is no real problem. It will be late in the first round, anyway. Losing Gustavsson also isn’t much of a concern. The Penguins should be set for years at goaltender with Matt Murray and either Tristan Jarry or Casey DeSmith. It’s much better to give up Gustavsson than top winger prospect Daniel Sprong.

Advertise with us

Losing Cole is what hurts. It couldn’t have been easy for Rutherford to trade a player who wasn’t just a significant contributor to the past two Cups but is respected and popular in the room. The Penguins have had a great thing going since the first of the year. I just hope that taking Cole and Reaves, for that matter, out of the mix doesn’t disrupt team chemistry that much. Losing Cole certainly makes the team weaker on defense. I like Cole a lot better than Matt Hunwick. I much prefer his toughness, shot-blocking and superb work on the penalty kill.

Cole was expected to leave as a free agent after this season. That had to play a big part in the decision to trade him. He and Sullivan also clashed frequently to the point that Sullivan made him a healthy scratch on too many occasions for no apparent reason other than maybe Sullivan believed he was a little too chatty with the media. You ask me, that’s a pretty weak reason to get rid of a guy, but, again, I defer to Sullivan’s wisdom. He’s 8 for 8, remember?

The only other drawback to getting Brassard is it likely means there is little chance Hornqvist will be back after this season. Brassard is signed through next season with a $5 million cap hit. That’s great news because it means the Penguins will have their four centers for another year. But that probably doesn’t leave enough money to bring back Hornqvist, who is expected to strike gold as a free agent. A team can’t keep all its stars under the salary cap. Rutherford understands that and certainly won’t complain if Hornqvist helps to win that third consecutive Cup. He also knows he has Hornqvist’s likely replacement in Zach Aston-Reese.

Rutherford might not be finished. The NHL trade deadline isn’t until 3 p.m. Monday. He could go after a depth defenseman with Cole gone. As of now, Chad Ruhwedel is the only extra defenseman with proven NHL experience.

But even if Rutherford does nothing more, there is every reason to think the Penguins will be the team to beat in the postseason.

Advertise with us

Rutherford and Sullivan certainly believe it.

That’s good enough for me.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.