We heard from David Freese Friday on the state of the Pirates. His message was stinging: “The demand to win just hasn’t been there.”

We heard from Josh Harrison Sunday. His message was equally disturbing: “I want to win. If that’s not the main focus, I want to go elsewhere.”

We will hear from Bob Nutting this week when he delivers his annual address to the players. To be a fly on the wall at that meeting, right? You would think it would be uncomfortable and awkward for Nutting to stand in front of a group of men who, it is clear now, look at him with the same disdain that those of us outside the organization do. But my guess is he doesn’t care. He just doesn’t care.

That’s why I have no hope that the messages delivered by Freese and Harrison will do any good to make the Pirates a relevant, competitive team. It’s not as if Nutting woke up this morning and said, “I have to do a better job as a team owner. I owe it to my players. I owe it to the fans.” It’s much more likely he woke up and thought, “How dare those millionaire players criticize me? The heck with them and the fans. I will be here long after they are gone.”

Advertise with us

That’s my greatest concern for the Pirates.

That Nutting will be here for a very long time.

That the team never will have a chance to win again.

Nutting has proved many times he is impervious to criticism. He has been called out many times by fans, media, agents and the players union and shrugged it all off. He didn’t blink when more than 40,000 fans signed a petition begging Major League Baseball to force him to sell the Pirates. He often has been compared to the Rooneys and to Ron Burkle and Mario Lemieux and been ridiculed for not doing his part to make Pittsburgh an even better sports city. He is not the least bit shamed. He has been called cheap too many times to count. Do you think that bothers him? Not on his way to the bank. Would it bother you if you were making millions on your franchise?

This seems like the right time to pause and give Nutting his due: He might be a lousy team owner, but he is a brilliant businessman.

Advertise with us

I have more faith that Clint Hurdle will benefit from Freese’s message. When Freese talked about a need for “urgency” and “accountability” on the Pirates, he all but called out Hurdle. It sounds as if Hurdle needs to spend a little more time in his clubhouse to find out what’s going on in there. Freese made it sound dysfunctional, if not toxic, with many players wanting out and many not caring about anything but their paychecks. If I had to guess, I would put Freese in that first group. I can imagine how envious he is of Gerrit Cole and Andrew McCutchen escaping purgatory. Like Harrison, he has to be praying that his time is coming.

Freese’s portrayal of the clubhouse is a poor reflection on Hurdle, who is supposed to be a players’ manager and a good communicator. It sounds as if he has been doing anything but communicating. It seems incredible now that he actually talked about how Pittsburgh “is going to explode when we win it all” just hours before Freese delivered the actual truth. Hurdle looks so foolish.

What’s most amazing to me about Freese’s message is that he delivered it in a calm, reasoned, measured way. Somehow, that carries more weight than a combustible rant. Freese spoke in a thoughtful way that demanded attention.

If I’m Nutting, I’m troubled by what Freese said about the organization doing McCutchen wrong by not “surrounding him with a group that wanted to beat some [butt] for him … [by not being able to say] we honestly went for it.”

If I’m Nutting, I’m troubled by what Freese said about the future of great young players in the organization: “You look at a guy like Jameson Taillon. It [stinks] that if you pan out, you have your future written for you in an organization like this. You either fold and sign a team-friendly deal or you’re bounced out of here. I think that’s unfortunate.”

Advertise with us

If I’m Nutting, I’m troubled by what Freese said about the opportunity the Pirates have wasted and are wasting: “As an organization, you have the ability to excite thousands of people. I don’t understand why you don’t take advantage of that. It just boggles my mind.”

Of course, I’m not Nutting.

I can’t wait to hear the spin that Nutting comes up with this week. He, Frank Coonelly and Neal Huntington have a lot of manure to sift through and dispense. I can’t remember the Pirates clubhouse being in worse shape since the Pittsburgh Drug Trials days of the mid-1980s. I can’t remember less excitement for the team or less interest in the team.

Not surprisingly, Harrison doesn’t seem to be expecting much from Nutting and the others. He relayed his spot-on assessment to Huntington when they spoke after Cole and McCutchen were traded and he asked to also be moved.

“At the end of the day, I said it’s about action, not speaking.”

Advertise with us

That won’t stop Nutting from trying to talk his way out of this mess.

Good luck to him finding someone to believe him.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.