Coming soon to a bookstore near you:
Tennessee Turmoil: How to turn a search for a football coach into an absolute fiasco
It’s inevitable.
It will be a blockbuster.
Tennessee isn’t the first major university to botch hiring a coach. Do we know that in Pittsburgh or what? Not long ago, Pitt hired Fraud Graham, who left his first head job at Rice after just one season and would pull the same despicable move on Pitt. Before that, Pitt hired Michael Haywood — remember him? — who never smiled one time during his introductory news conference and lasted about 56 minutes on the job before an alleged domestic-abuse situation took him down. You bet we know coach-hiring nightmares.
But Tennessee took it to a new low during the weekend. It reached agreement with Ohio State defensive coordinator Greg Schiano to be its head coach then, just hours later, reneged on the offer, weakly caving to massive pressure from fans, alumni, boosters and state politicians who didn’t like the hiring because Schiano coached at Penn State with Jerry Sandusky decades ago and therefore must have known about Sandusky’s pedophilia. Everyone at the university or connected with the football program deserves to be ridiculed. They are a bad joke.
I guess I get it that a university might not want to take a chance on a Penn State man because of the Sandusky tragedy, although that wouldn’t stop me from hiring someone whom I’m convinced is a good person and a good coach. Hearsay, rumor and innuendo should never bring down anyone. Hard proof should be required to ruin a man’s reputation and career. Of course, there isn’t any hard proof in the Penn State situation with Schiano, who has denied knowledge of Sandusky’s crimes.
Tennessee athletic director John Currie believed in Schiano, who coached for Joe Paterno at Penn State from 1990-95, after he “carefully interviewed and vetted him.” If Currie made a mistake, it was not lining up high-ranking officials at Tennessee as allies in the hiring. Maybe associates are running from him as fast as they can to avoid the negative fallout, but they portray him as a man who made the decision to go with Schiano on his own. Tennessee chancellor Beverly Davenport has been absurdly quiet since the revocation, other than releasing a lame statement saying she still believed in the university’s “commitment to excellence” and still supported Currie in his attempt to find the right coach. Sure, she does. She strikes me as being pretty gutless.
Schiano appeared to be the kind of coach Tennessee needs. Yes, he failed miserably with his tough-guy style as coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers from 2012-13. But coaching pros is different than coaching college kids. Schiano performed miracles at Rutgers from 2001-11, actually producing a winning record and six bowl trips at that coaches’ graveyard. Don’t take my word for it. Ask Bill Belichick, whose son, Stephen, played for Schiano at Rutgers. “He’s one of the very best coaches, I think, in our profession,” Belichick said, adding he will vouch “100 percent” for Schiano’s character and has “zero reservations” about him. Ask Ohio State coach Urban Meyer. “[Schiano] is an elite father, an elite football coach and an elite friend. I stand by my coach.”
Critics of the Schiano hiring didn’t want to hear any of that. They were too busy going after him brutally. One painted on The Rock, a huge dolomite stone on the Tennessee campus, “Schiano covered up child rape at Penn State.” Not surprisingly, pictures of that message went viral. Again, there was no proof offered. Social media can be so cruel, so evil and, frighteningly, so powerful.
Currie/Tennessee couldn’t dump Schiano fast enough.
Shame on those people.
Shame on them for allowing outsiders to run their athletic department.
I understand big money is at stake. I don’t care that politicians impudently feel the need to have their say because everyone knows they have their agendas. Unhappy donors are a different, more complicated matter. They can put a chancellor and an athletic director in a really tough spot if they threaten to withhold their financial contributions. We’re talking about millions. I get that. But I would be damned if I let the donors make the hires that I should be making. If I make a mistake, I should be fired. But if I let outsiders make the hire, I couldn’t sleep at night and I’d probably be fired sooner, anyway.
It’s hard to imagine Currie lasting long at Tennessee. Fans and boosters have lined up calling for his firing. The university has proven without a doubt that it has no strength in the face of public criticism. If I’m Currie, I would resign. I wouldn’t want to work for Davenport and others who don’t support me. Good luck to Tennessee finding the next athletic director to work under those circumstances.
The same is true of getting a coach to come to Knoxville. It’s laughable that some in the Tennessee fan base really believe the university can lure Jon Gruden or Bob Stoops. The job isn’t that good, isn’t even that close. Duke’s David Cutcliffe said thanks, but no thanks, earlier this week to Tennessee’s interest. Multiple reports have mentioned Oklahoma State’s Mike Gundy, North Carolina State’s Dave Doeren and Purdue’s Jeff Brohm as candidates for the job, but is any of the three really that desperate? Is any a proven head coach?
As for Schiano, he will coach the Ohio State defense against unbeaten Wisconsin on Saturday night in the Big Ten Conference championship game. I’m thinking the Tennessee fiasco worked out for the best for him. He’s not the big loser in this sad story. The University of Tennessee is the only loser.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.