Pitt fans like to believe their team’s win against Penn State early last season cost Penn State a chance to play in the College Football Playoff. There is some truth to that, but Penn State’s 49-10 loss at Michigan two weeks later was much more damaging. It was impossible for the selection committee to ignore. Penn State was relegated to the Rose Bowl, which wasn’t a bad consolation prize.

Penn State plays Michigan on Saturday night in Happy Valley.

Penn State made its 2016 season with a 24-21 home win against Ohio State Oct. 22. It wasn’t just its biggest win since a seemingly finished Joe Paterno led the Nittany Lions to a throbbing home win against Ohio State in 2005. It sent the team on its way to a Big Ten Conference championship.

Penn State plays at Ohio State Oct. 28.

Advertise with us

The same two games that determined Penn State’s fate in 2016 will do so again in the next 10 days.

I see a different result in each game.

Penn State, No. 2 in the nation, will beat No. 19 Michigan. Maybe not by 39 points, but fairly handily. It’s not just because there will be a “white-out” crowd of nearly 110,000 at Beaver Stadium, although that surely will be one of the more amazing scenes of the college football season. It’s because Michigan, without injured quarterback Wilton Speight, can’t score. It’s because the Penn State defense is healthy and stacked, giving up an NCAA-best nine points a game. Neither was true a year ago when Michigan rang up 515 yards on Penn State, which was playing without injured star linebackers Brandon Bell and Jason Cabinda.

“Literally, we’re playing the Michigan game and we had a fifth-team Mike linebacker on the field who had never taken a rep with the varsity or in a game,” Penn State coach James Franklin said before this season. “That was the situation. I remember being on the headset talking to the defensive coordinator and saying, ‘Do I put the sixth team Mike linebacker on the field or do I put in our starting Will linebacker who had never played Mike linebacker ever?’ That was the discussion we were going through.”

The loss still was humiliating. It left Franklin, in his third season, with an 0-7 record against Michigan, Ohio State and Michigan State, with Penn State outscored in those games by an average of 36-14. It also led to a dreaded vote of confidence for Franklin from Penn State athletic director Sandy Barbour.

Advertise with us

“I saw the progress that we were making,” Franklin said. “It needed to transform into wins on the field, I get that. But I felt like we were headed in the right direction.”

Franklin was right.

Penn State is 14-0 in regular-season games since that Michigan whipping. Its only loss was to Southern California, 52-49, in the Rose Bowl after it blew a two-touchdown lead late in the third quarter.

The turnaround started the week after the Michigan game when Penn State came back from a 23-20 deficit at home in the final minute against Minnesota to win, 29-26, in overtime. But it was the win three weeks later against No. 2 Ohio State that pushed Franklin and Penn State over the top. Ohio State wasted a 14-point lead in the fourth quarter, losing for the first time in 79 games when it led by two touchdowns or more in the final quarter. Marcus Allen blocked Ohio State’s 45-yard field goal try with fewer than five minutes left and Grant Haley turned it into a 60-yard return for the winning touchdown.

Franklin, who criticized Pitt for treating its win over Penn State as if were the Super Bowl, treated the win as if it were the Super Bowl.

Advertise with us

Hypocrite?

“I just want to soak this all in,” he gushed, breaking down during his post-game press conference. “I told these guys in the locker room … ‘Nights like this don’t happen very often. Savor it. Stay in this locker room. Turn the music up. Enjoy each other.’ ”

Ohio State still edged out Penn State for a spot in the four-team national championship field despite Penn State’s head-to-head win and its win against Wisconsin in the Big Ten championship game. Penn State’s loss to Pitt was a factor, sure, but that 39-point loss to Michigan was a bigger factor. It didn’t help Penn State’s angry fans get over the perceived slight when Ohio State was crushed by Clemson, 31-0, in one of the semifinal games.

There will be no such controversy this time. No. 6 Ohio State will beat Penn State in a close game. It has extra time to prepare with this weekend off while Penn State is taking on Michigan and its rugged defense, which, at least statistically, is the best in the country. There will be no “white-out” crowd to support the Nittany Lions. The venue is Ohio Stadium where Penn State has lost the past two trips, 38-10 and 63-14.

A perfect season will be perfect no more.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.