UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — The scoreboard said it was a blowout. My eyes told me otherwise. Penn State wasn’t nearly as good as I expected, not in the national championship contender category, certainly not good enough for arrogant James Franklin to make an ass of himself by comparing Penn State’s 33-14 win over Pitt to its 52-0 win against Akron a week earlier. Pitt wasn’t nearly as bad as I expected, certainly much better than it was last week in an embarrassing overtime win against Youngstown State. I actually thought it could have won as a three-touchdown underdog on the road in front of a huge Beaver Stadium crowd of 109,898, which is about what Pitt draws for three Heinz Field games.

I know, that’s hard to say when one team beats the other by 19 points. But that’s my story and I’m sticking to it.

Franklin didn’t want to hear it, of course. He praised Penn State for playing “a complete game,” making me think he watched a different game. He was in such a fine mood that he took a cheap and unnecessary shot at Pitt by saying, “Last year, for their win, it was like the Super Bowl. But for us, this was just like beating Akron.”

Classy.

Advertise with us

Pat Narduzzi was a bit more dignified, although the Penn Staters will tell you he had to be dignified because he was the losing coach. He praised Franklin, the other Penn State coaches and the Penn State team. “We weren’t playing William & Mary out there today.”

But Narduzzi nailed it when he mentioned Pitt’s “self-inflicted wounds.” Two first-half interceptions by quarterback Max Browne, the first put on wide receiver Quadree Henderson by Narduzzi for not getting out of his break quickly enough and not going after the ball. Two drops by senior captain Jester Weah and another by tight end Chris Clark. Five sacks allowed. A couple of untimely penalties. A bad decision by Henderson — an All-American kick returner last season —– to call for a fair catch at the Pitt 5 early in the third quarter. Penn State got the ball back at Pitt’s 46 after Pitt’s three-and-out and needed just one play to stretch its lead to 21-3 on a 46-yard touchdown pass to exquisite running back Saquon Barkley, who caught Pitt in a bad defense and abused helpless linebacker Saleem Brightwell by beating him easily down the middle.

That sequence was typical of the game in a couple of ways.

One, Pitt had lousy field position all day, starting its first 10 drives on average at its 14. Penn State scored touchdowns after starting possessions at the Pitt 8 and Pitt 46 and a field goal after beginning a drive at the Pitt 40. It also scored late on a safety when safety Marcus Allen tackled running back Darrin Hall in the end zone after a swing pass; Pitt’s drive started at its 4.

“We probably lost [the field-position game] by 200 yards,” Narduzzi said. “Maybe it was 300 yards.”

Advertise with us

And two, Penn State had Barkley, well on his way to becoming the greatest running back in Penn State history. I’m thinking it was inexcusable for the Penn State scoreboard ops to misspell his name as “Barkely” during the pregame introductions. That sort of thing can’t help his Heisman Trophy candidacy, right?

Pitt’s defense, which I thought had a chance to be almost as bad as last season’s version, did a nice job early against Barkley, holding him to 22 yards on five carries in the first half when Pitt had more yards (150-108), more first downs (13-5) and more time with the ball (21:51-8:09). But, as great players often do, Barkley took control of the game in the second half. He finished with 88 rushing yards and that easy touchdown catch. His 8-yard touchdown run, which stretched Penn State’s lead to 28-6 early in the fourth quarter, was a thing of beauty. He ran over just about every Pitt defender.

“He’s got some wheels,” Narduzzi said with genuine respect.

Pitt also did a nice job against quarterback Trace McSorley, who wasn’t as sharp as usual. He completed 15 of 28 passes for just 164 yards, although he did throw three touchdown passes, two to terrific tight end Mike Gesicki.

I really thought Penn State would score 52 points, but it didn’t happen. I guess that means Pitt is better than Akron, although we will find out more about it when it plays No. 11, sling-it-down-the-field Oklahoma State Saturday at Heinz Field.

Advertise with us

Penn State, meanwhile, will play its next “Super Bowl” — Franklin’s description of each opponent — Saturday night against Georgia State at Beaver Stadium. Maybe it’s just me, but I don’t think the Penn State crowd will enjoy that win as much as it did the Pitt win — no matter how the condescending Franklin tries to sell it.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.