These are challenging times for Neal Huntington. He has much to decide before the trade deadline at the end of the month. Not about this season’s Pirates team. It’s clearly not good enough, 42-47 at the All-Star break, 7 games behind first-place Milwaukee.
I can’t believe so many are saying Huntington should buy before the deadline. Really? I’m talking about next season’s club. Will it have a chance to contend for a championship with Starling Marte for a full season and perhaps Jung Ho Kang? Should Huntington keep Andrew McCutchen and Gerrit Cole to enhance that team’s chances or look to trade one or both this month in an attempt to build an even brighter future a little further down the road?
Huntington says he’s not actively looking to move McCutchen and/or Cole because he believes they will provide a strong foundation for the 2018 team.
I like that thinking.
Huntington also says he will listen to offers for any player — presumably, even McCutchen and Cole — and won’t be afraid to make a bold move if he believes it will help the team. Think Mark Melancon for Felipe Rivero.
I like that thinking, too.
Read More
We’ll never know how much better these Pirates would be if they had Marte and Kang. I’m thinking significantly better. Their absence didn’t just take two of the team’s better bats out of the starting lineup. They forced role players such as David Freese and Adam Frazier to get too much playing time. Can you believe Max Moroff had 44 at-bats going into the game Sunday in Chicago despite a .091 batting average and was in the lineup again? I’m not sure I can remember a worse bench.
But not having Marte and Kang doesn’t excuse the unexpected failures of other players. Tony Watson — arguably, the team’s most consistent player before this season — heads that list and has been the biggest perpetrator of a lousy bullpen. Daniel Hudson, who signed a two-year, $11 million contract before the season, is high on the list. Tyler Glasnow bombed. Gregory Polanco has been a major disappointment, although he has heated up in July. Cole has been wildly inconsistent. Even McCutchen, who has been amazing for seven weeks and maybe the best hitter in baseball, was hitting .200 through May 23. Those early games count, too.
All of those reasons are why it’s silly for anyone to think Huntington should be a buyer at the deadline. He shouldn’t give up even one prospect in an attempt to make this team better. It is not going to win the National League Central Division, weak as it is. If anything, Huntington should be looking to move a veteran player with an expiring contract for a prospect or two. Juan Nicasio and John Jaso are fine role players and could help any contender. So could Watson, although I admit I’m stubbornly more pro-Watson than a lot of people these days.
But with next season’s Pirates in mind?
Huntington is expected to keep Cole, who has two years of salary arbitration left before he can become a free agent after the 2019 season. That is the smart move. A rotation with Cole, Ivan Nova and Jameson Taillon at the top isn’t bad. Trevor Williams and Chad Kuhl have improved ever so slightly. Huntington has not given up on Glasnow even if a lot of others have. Starting pitching still wins. Keep Cole.
It’s hard to imagine Kang being back next season, but the lineup still should be much better with Marte. Huntington believes Polanco is back on track to be the player the Pirates gave a five-year, $35 million contract extension before the 2016 season, using the words “incredible natural ability” to describe him. Josh Harrison and Jordy Mercer are winning players. So is Francisco Cervelli — his pitchers worship him — if he’s healthy. Josh Bell has the kind of power the Pirates desperately need, although he has to hit better than .240. Jose Osuna has showed he deserves consideration for more playing time, perhaps at third base if he can learn the position in the offseason. McCutchen is McCutchen again.
But I am not as opposed to a McCutchen trade as a Cole trade. I know McCutchen has been largely great here — an MVP winner on the field, a Roberto Clemente Award winner off it. He was the biggest part of the Pirates ending 20 years of losing and has been pure class in the community. It would hurt to lose him every bit as much as it did for the Penguins to lose Marc-Andre Fleury.
But McCutchen’s contract is up after next season. Many fans want the Pirates to give him a multiyear extension in the neighborhood of $20 million a year, although they weren’t saying that May 23 or during the first four months of the 2016 season when McCutchen was awful. It’s funny how that works. The Pirates almost certainly won’t go that high to keep him.
That’s why Huntington should listen to offers for McCutchen. He listened in the offseason and didn’t like the return so he kept McCutchen. If Huntington still doesn’t like the return at the end of the month, he should keep him again. What Huntington can’t do is a Neil Walker-for-Jon Niese type of trade. That was a nightmare. Again, think along the lines of Melancon for Rivero.
“We think we can be serious contenders next year,” Huntington recently told Peter Gammons of GammonsDaily.com. “There’s no reason we can’t be better with Cole and McCutchen going into next year.”
I’m OK with that thinking if that’s how it plays out.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.