It has become trendy after two losses in Nashville in the Stanley Cup final to bash the Penguins defensemen. Olli Maatta? “Too slow. Get him outta there!” Ron Hainsey? “Too old. Get him outta there!” Justin Schultz? “Now we know why Edmonton was so eager to trade him.” Trevor Daley? “He hasn’t been the same player since knee surgery.” …

I could go on, but you get the idea.

That’s why there was so much excitement Tuesday morning — at least briefly — among Penguins fans who learned of a report from TSN hockey insider Darren Dreger, who tweeted there is a “slight chance” Kris Letang will return before the end of the series. That’s not going to happen, of course. “Zero chance,” Mike Sullivan said Tuesday afternoon.

Sorry.

Advertise with us

What you see with the Penguins defensemen is what you get.

But that’s OK.

Maatta, Hainsey, Schultz, Daley, Ian Cole and Brian Dumoulin — “It’s going to take a village,” Daley has said — should be applauded, not criticized.

The group has defied all reasonable expectations after Letang’s season-ending neck injury in February by helping the Penguins get within two wins of a second consecutive Cup. The players have proved to me they are good enough to help the team win it. I didn’t think that was possible without Letang. Without him, I gave the Penguins zero chance.

But the defensemen won me over by standing up to a fierce forecheck from Columbus in the first round of the playoffs. They really won me over by beating Washington in the second round. The Capitals were the better team. Even some in the Penguins organization still can’t believe their team won that series.

Advertise with us

“This group of defensemen are the unsung heroes of this team,” Sullivan said after the Penguins survived Ottawa in seven games in the Eastern Conference final. “They get knocked down and they get up and they get back in the fight. I think that’s what I love about them …

“They don’t get a lot of accolades. They don’t show up on ESPN highlight reels, but they just quietly do a decent job back there are as far as helping us get out of our end zone, managing the puck the right way and defending hard when we need them to defend. As I’ve said, we don’t always make the perfect play. But our competitive spirit back there, it’s inspiring, I think. I know that our forwards and the rest of our team are appreciative of that.”

That doesn’t mean the Penguins defensemen have played great against Nashville, especially not in Bridgestone Arena. They certainly haven’t been as impactful as Predators defensemen Roman Josi, Ryan Ellis, P.K. Subban and Mattias Ekholm, the best Top Four defensive group in the NHL. Nashville has three goals and 11 points from its defensemen in the series, the Penguins no goals and seven points from theirs.

“I don’t think we have anybody back there that wows you offensively,” Sullivan acknowledged.

It’s fair to at least wonder if the Penguins defensemen have hit the wall after playing so long without Letang, although I’m not willing to go there just yet. Jacques Martin, the assistant coach in charge of the defensemen, has done a terrific job spreading the minutes out. He had an easier time last season during the team’s run to the Cup when he sent out Letang for nearly 30 minutes a game. He has been more judicious this season with the ice time, which ranges from Dumoulin’s 21:46 to Cole’s 18:55. But I’m still thinking the extra day off before Game 5 Thursday night at PPG Paints Arena will do wonders for them.

Advertise with us

Maatta, who had been the Penguins’ best defenseman in the first three series, hasn’t played well against Nashville. He was beaten for a goal by winger Pontus Aberg in Game 2 and his turnover in his end zone in the first period of Game 4 led to a goal by center Calle Jarnkrok as Maatta struggled with Nashville’s Craig Smith in front of Matt Murray. It’s possible, though not likely, Maatta could be replaced by Chad Ruhwedel in Game 5.

Maatta wasn’t the only Penguins defenseman to struggle. Dumoulin had a turnover in Game 4 that led to a scoring chance by Nashville forward Filip Forsberg. Cole lost position on center Frederick Gaudreau’s wraparound goal in Game 4 and Schultz was late coming over to help. Schultz got caught out of position on winger Viktor Arvidsson’s breakaway goal in Game 4 and finished a minus-3. Hainsey had four giveaways in Game 4.

One of those nights.

Sullivan was left to seemingly damn his defensemen with faint praise.

“They’re a simple bunch. I think they’re trying to play the game the right way. What I really like about them is their compete level. I believe that they’re doing their very best to help us at both ends of the rink.”

Advertise with us

Translation:

The Penguins defensemen have to play better in Game 5.

I believe they will. I think they will be better at getting the puck out of their end zone, not just dumping it out only to have to turn back around when the Predators send it in again, but getting it to one of their forwards on the move. That’s what happened in Game 4 when Dumoulin hit Crosby with a perfect stretch pass, leading to Crosby’s breakaway goal. More of that will help a Penguins offense that scored just one goal in each of Games 3 and 4.

I don’t think better play from the defensemen is unreasonable to expect. I saw what the Penguins did in Game 7 of the Washington series when, after losing two consecutive games, they held the Capitals to six shots in the third period of a 2-0 win. I saw what they did against Ottawa in a 3-2 win in Game 4 when they were in danger of falling into a 3-1 hole, killing four Senators power plays. I saw what they did against Ottawa in a 3-2 win in double overtime in Game 7 when they held the Senators to 29 shots, just 12 after the second period. Maatta played a staggering, team-high 31:57 that night.

“We’re confident our team will respond the right away, as they always have all season-long,” Sullivan said Tuesday. “We believe in the group that we have. They have shown all kinds of evidence that they respond the right way to adversities. We believe that we’ll do it once again.”

Advertise with us

I believe it, too.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.