Going into Game 1 of the Stanley Cup final Monday night, the on-line betting site Bovada had Nashville goaltender Pekka Rinne as the favorite to win the Conn Smythe Trophy as the NHL’s postseason MVP. His 1.70 goals-against average and his .941 save percentage were the best in these playoffs. He had stopped 446 of 474 shots in series wins against Chicago, St. Louis and Anaheim.

But then Rinne got to Pittsburgh.

Unbelievable things happen to him when he plays the Penguins.

A five-on-three power-play goal that was set up by teammate James Neal’s undisciplined stupidity, a goal by a player who hadn’t scored one all spring and an own-goal by teammate Mattias Ekholm happened to him Monday night.

Advertise with us

All in the first period.

All in the span of eight shots.

But that was nothing, really.

The next shot that Rinne saw didn’t come until 3:17 was left in the game. A beautiful wrister by Jake Guentzel — a player who hadn’t scored in eight games and one many speculated would be scratched before the game — was the deciding goal in the Penguins’ 5-3 win.

That’s beyond surreal.

Advertise with us

Sidney Crosby, Patric Hornqvist on Game 1 win over Nashville

“It’s tough. He’s been a rock for us,” Nashville coach Peter Laviolette said of Rinne. “There’s no question about Pekks in net and what he’s capable of. He’s the backbone of this team.”

I have to see it to believe it.

Rinne’s rotten luck/​karma against the Penguins trumped his team’s amazing defense. No one should have been surprised. The Predators still might go on to take the Cup and Rinne the Smythe, but his next win as a starter against the Penguins will be his first. He came in with a 1-5-2 career record against them with a 3.57 goals-against average and an .880 save percentage. His lone win came in relief in January 2009.

It seems appropriate here to mention something Patric Hornqvist said before the game.

“Don’t turn down a shot. There’s never a bad shot in the final.”

Advertise with us

Not when Rinne is in the net against the Penguins, although their unwillingness or inability to shoot pucks at him nearly cost them the game.

“We weren’t very good,” coach Mike Sullivan said.

Evgeni Malkin scored the Penguins’ first goal, a gift that was set up by Calle Jarnkrok’s interference penalty on Hornqvist and Neal’s unconscionable cross-checking penalty on Trevor Daley — a close friend going back to their days with the Dallas Stars — far away from the play. Of course, Rinne was beaten by the only shot he faced on that five-on-three, just when it appeared the Predators would kill it off.

Rinne had no chance on the Penguins’ second goal. Chris Kunitz, coming off his two-goal, three-point game against Ottawa Thursday night in Game 7, set up Conor Sheary with an easy tap-in. Sheary hadn’t scored a playoff goal since Game 2 against San Jose in the Cup final last spring and was scratched in Games 5 and 6 against Ottawa. Of course, he scored against Rinne.

At that point, the Predators figured they would get out of the first period down just 2-0. That’s when Nick Bonino threw a harmless, one-handed shot at Rinne, who easily made the save. There was only one problem. The puck ricocheted off Ekholm’s knee. Of course, it ended up in the net behind Rinne.

Advertise with us

“Not even a scoring chance,” Laviolette moaned afterward.

That goal hurt, but not nearly as much as Guentzel’s.

Love our Pens coverage? Consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

It’s hard to believe the Penguins, with all of their wonderful offensive talent, could go 37 minutes without so much as one shot on net. Everybody knew the Nashville defense was terrific coming in, the best in these playoffs. It gave up an average of 1.81 goals a game in the first three series. It held Chicago’s Patrick Kane to two points, St. Louis’ Vladimir Tarasenko to three points and Anaheim’s Ryan Getzlaf to no goals. That’s beyond terrific.

Advertise with us

But what the Nashville defense did to the Penguins Monday night was ridiculous. It did everything but win the game. By rights, it should have won the game. Sullivan all but acknowledged that.

“We got outplayed in a lot of aspects of the game. Our players are well aware of it. Our expectations are higher. We got a favorable result, but we know we have to be much better to get to where we want to go. None of us in our dressing room are fooled by the score tonight.”

Thank goodness for what appears to be the Penguins curse against Rinne.

Guentzel blew down the right wing after taking a pass from ageless Matt Cullen and beat Rinne with that wrist shot. Guentzel appeared to be out of gas in the Ottawa series and easily could have been scratched for the game with Hornqvist returning to the lineup after missing six games with an upper-body injury. But Sullivan elected to stick with Guentzel and sat Carl Hagelin instead. It was another decision that worked for an amazing coach who is now just three wins from a second consecutive Cup.

Sullivan is right, though. The Penguins are going to have to play a lot better in Game 2 Wednesday night and beyond. They can’t count on Rinne’s demons forever.

Advertise with us

At least I don’t think they can.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.

On the Clock: Good Predators defense or bad Penguins offense?