On March 12, I wrote on these pages the Penguins can’t win the Stanley Cup without Kris Letang. Not much room for misinterpretation there. Well, I’d like to amend that declaration just a bit this morning. Only a fool would write off a team coached by Mike Sullivan and led by Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin, a team with the collective heart of a champion. Of course, the Penguins can win if puck-luck is on their side and everything goes their way.
But I still don’t see it happening.
I don’t see a second consecutive Cup.
I don’t see the Penguins beating the Washington Capitals.
That’s no disrespect toward the Penguins or their group of defensemen. That’s tremendous respect for Letang, a one-of-a-kind player on his team.
I know the Capitals’ history works against them. The Penguins have won eight of nine playoff series against them, including last spring when they took the Presidents’ Trophy-winning Capitals out in six incredible games. I also know the pressure on Alexander Ovechkin and his Washington team. Crosby’s teams have won everything, including multiple Cups and multiple Olympic gold medals. Ovechkin’s teams have won nothing. The Capitals haven’t even made it past the second round of the playoffs in the Ovechkin era.
Read More
But it’s awfully difficult for a team to win the Cup without a star defenseman. The Penguins won in 2016 with Letang, who averaged nearly 29 minutes a game — easily the most on the team — and could have been the Conn Smythe Trophy winner as postseason MVP. Looking back at the eight years before that, the teams that won had Duncan Keith, Drew Doughty, Zdeno Chara or Nick Lidstrom. The Capitals brought in Kevin Shattenkirk at the trade deadline to be that guy and add to their formidable defensive group.
We saw Letang’s value to the Penguins last season. He played solid defense. He was critical to the team’s breakout, often skating the puck out of his defensive zone. He played all of the important minutes, at even-strength, on the power play and the penalty-kill, up a goal, down a goal or a tied score. And he often was a factor in the offensive zone, making play after play. His goal against Tampa Bay gave the Penguins a 2-0 lead in Game 6 of the Eastern Conference final when they were facing elimination. He had the primary assist on Conor Sheary’s overtime goal in Game 2 against San Jose in the Cup final. He scored the winning goal in the Game 6 clincher against the Sharks.
The Penguins took care of Columbus in the first round of these playoffs without Letang, but they weren’t always successful against the Blue Jackets’ relentless forecheck. They missed Letang in that regard. They allowed an average of nearly 39 shots a game, including 51 in the Game 5 clincher. Marc-Andre Fleury saved them by standing tall in net, especially in the three home games when he stopped 119 of 123 shots (as opposed to only 62 of 71 on the road). The big-bodied Capitals also will come hard at the Penguins defensemen and hit them at every opportunity if they are slow getting the puck up ice. The difference between the Blue Jackets and Capitals is the Capitals have much better finishers. Ovechkin, obviously. Big-game performer Justin Williams. Nicklas Backstrom, the top power-play points scorer during the regular season. T.J. Oshie, a 33-goal man. Marcus Johansson. Evgeny Kuznetsov. Fleury is going to have to be brilliant again for the Penguins to advance. He is more than capable, although it’s hard not to give a slight edge in goal to the Capitals’ Braden Holtby, a Vezina Trophy finalist. Holtby was especially strong in Games 5 and 6 against Toronto in the first round of these playoffs, stopping 61 of 63 shots in a pair of 2-1 overtime wins.
There are other reasons to like the Penguins. Start with Sullivan, who has it all over Capitals coach Barry Trotz, who hasn’t taken a team past the second round in nine playoff appearances with Washington and Nashville. Trotz and Ovechkin were made for each other, right? Throw in Crosby and Malkin, who are due for a big series after combining for just one goal and four points in the Washington series a year ago. Malkin, looking fresh after missing the final 13 regular-season games with a shoulder injury, had 11 points against Columbus to lead all NHL players in the first round. Finally, add the Penguins’ edge in speed, which will become even more pronounced if injured Carl Hagelin makes it back in the lineup during the series. The Maple Leafs challenged the Capitals with their speed — five of the six games went to overtime — but couldn’t quite finish the job. Of course, they didn’t have Crosby and Malkin.
That’s a lot of reasons to like the Penguins. There’s only one reason not to like them. No Letang. I can’t get past it.
Capitals in seven.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.