The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Ed Bouchette is reporting that Mike Tomlin and Kevin Colbert are due for contract extensions. The news comes a couple of weeks after the Pirates were asked about extensions for Neal Huntington and Clint Hurdle. My question to both Art Rooney II and Bob Nutting is the same: What are you guys waiting for?
These are really good times in Pittsburgh sports. Maybe not as good as in the 1970s when the Steelers won four Super Bowls and the Pirates two World Series, but still plenty good. The Penguins won the Stanley Cup last season and have a good shot at becoming the NHL’s first repeat champion this season in nearly two decades. The Steelers are a playoff-caliber team every season and just went to the NFL’s Final Four. The Pirates made the playoffs three consecutive seasons after 20 years of losing before taking a 20-win step back last season.
A lot of cities would love to have our sports teams.
A big reason for the success is stability of management.
The Penguins acted quickly and wisely after the Cup win in June, giving Jim Rutherford a new three-year deal through 2018-19 and Mike Sullivan a three-year extension through 2019-20. I’m hoping Rutherford doesn’t realize he’s 68 and isn’t thinking about retirement. He’s been terrific. I know the NHL often doesn’t have respect for its coaches — witness the firing this season of Claude Julien and Mike Therrien, two really good hockey men — but Sullivan looks to have staying power. He has a presence that makes everyone around him feel confident in his team even in trying times.
I have no doubt Rooney II will extend contracts for Tomlin and Colbert, probably this summer. No organization in sports values continuity more than the Steelers and no organization has been more successful because of it. It’s not as if Rooney II would be stepping out on a weak limb by keeping Tomlin and Colbert for a much longer time. Tomlin is no Chuck Noll, but he has passed Bill Cowher in terms of excellence in franchise history. Tomlin is no Bill Belichick — who is? — but there is no other NFL coach I would rather have. Colbert’s draft history and personnel decisions haven’t been perfect, but they’ve been pretty darn good. Colbert also works well with Tomlin just as he did with Cowher. He has no ego, which is important because Tomlin does and Cowher did. That’s why Colbert virtually disappears from public sight during the NFL season. He’s very comfortable that the coach is the management face of the Steelers.
Read More
Huntington and Hurdle also have been a solid team. I think back to something Hurdle said after the Pirates clinched a playoff spot in Atlanta in 2014. “We don’t care who’s right. We just want to get right.” I have seen nothing to indicate that relationship has changed.
It’s easy to argue Huntington has been the best general manager in town. He doesn’t get to operate in a salary-cap system the way Rutherford and Colbert do. He doesn’t work for do-what-it-takes owners the way Rutherford and Colbert do. He works for the ultra-cheap Nutting and still has been successful. I believe Huntington when he says he likes the challenge of trying to do more with less. I just hope, for the Pirates’ sake, that Nutting has the good sense to lock him up long term before he changes his mind.
Only Hurdle makes me pause for just a second when it comes to a contract extension. I would think his loud, forceful personality eventually could wear on a team and cause his players to tune him out. He admitted he lost his Colorado team and deserved to be fired early in the 2009 season despite taking the Rockies to the World Series in 2007. It certainly didn’t look as if his Pirates were all in last September and October when they went 11-19 to finish with a 78-83 record.
But I like to think Hurdle has learned from his mistakes and is a better manager because of what happened to him in Colorado. The energy and enthusiasm he brings to the Pirates more than offset his faults. That’s why I have no problem giving Nutting the same unsolicited advice as Rooney II:
Sign up your guys for the long haul. They are worth the extra years. They will be worth every penny.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.