Sports figures say all the time that they are their own worst critics. No one in this town does harsher public self-assessments than Jim Rutherford. Remember after the 2014-15 season when he said he regretted trading Simon Despres for Ben Lovejoy? Lovejoy certainly does. He used it as motivation to become a key contributor on the Penguins’ Stanley Cup team last season.

Rutherford was back at it this week.

In a stunning, candid interview with the Post-Gazette’s Hall of Fame hockey writer Dave Molinari, Rutherford conceded the Penguins aren’t getting what he had hoped from their two goaltenders, Cup winners Matt Murray and Marc-Andre Fleury. It wasn’t exactly an admission that he wished he had traded Fleury during the off-season. But it sure seemed close.

I get Rutherford’s angst after watching Murray clearly emerge as the No. 1 goalie and Fleury struggling to deal with it. But I’m not sure that was the Penguins’ biggest problem through the first quarter of the NHL season. Something has been missing despite the team’s solid 13-6-3 record. It has been terribly inconsistent, playing terrific hockey at times and miserable hockey at other times, often within the same game. Mike Sullivan’s frustration has been visible on numerous occasions.

Advertise with us

If Rutherford made an off-season mistake, it was bringing back the Penguins virtually intact from their Cup season. Lovejoy was the only key player to leave. It’s nice to give a team a chance to repeat, but it’s better to bring in at least a little new blood to keep things from getting stale. Rutherford has to know that. That’s why I believe he will be active with trades long before the Feb. 28 trade deadline.

It’s easy to suggest Rutherford could solve that new-blood thing by moving Fleury. Murray, at 22, isn’t just 9½ years younger than Fleury, who turned 32 Monday. He is a better goaltender. He showed that last season by leading the Penguins to the Cup with 15 post-season wins and is showing it again this season. He has started eight of 13 games since rejoining the team after a hand injury and is 7-1 with a .939 save percentage and 1.75 goals-against average. Fleury’s numbers are 6-5-3, .901 and 3.38. We’re talking a vast difference.

Fleury has said the reduction in playing time has been a difficult adjustment. But he had to know this situation was possible — if not likely — going into the season. Sullivan is a tremendous communicator and would have made that clear. Yet Fleury elected not to ask to be traded, saying the Penguins were his team and Pittsburgh was his home, the place where he wanted to keep his family and raise his two young daughters.

Now, perhaps, Fleury is feeling the same regrets as Rutherford.

The one thing that’s unexplainable is why the Penguins play so much better in front of Murray. They adore Fleury. I’ve been in this business more than 100 years and the only other player I can remember as beloved was Jerome Bettis. You would think teammates would want to do better by Fleury. As it is, they are driving him out of town. They will be incredibly sad when he’s gone.

Advertise with us

Trading Fleury is a complicated deal for Rutherford. Fleury has a no-movement clause in his contract, although he likely would waive it for the right trade. There’s also the NHL expansion draft after the season. The Penguins can only protect one goalie and, as of now, it would have to be Fleury because of that no-movement clause. But there’s no way the team is going to expose Murray. It just signed him to a three-year, $11.25 million contract extension through 2019-20 before the season. It wants him to be the franchise’s go-to goalie for a long time.

Rutherford also must weigh the long-term value of having two top goaltenders. Last season, the Penguins needed three to win the Cup — Murray, Fleury and Jeff Zatkoff, who won their first playoff game against the New York Rangers. They are good enough to repeat. The last thing the team wants is to trade Fleury and then have Murray go down with an injury. It seems certain it would have to acquire a cheaper, veteran goaltender in any deal involving Fleury.

Go back to the Lovejoy-Despres trade. That ended up working out spectacularly for the Penguins despite Rutherford’s initial regrets. So did virtually every move he made last season. He was named NHL General Manager of the Year soon after the Penguins hoisted the Cup.

Rutherford needs to stay on that roll. Solving the Murray-Fleury conundrum will be his greatest challenge.

rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.