The task of the College Football Playoff Selection Committee is to identify the four best teams for the national playoff. I’m hoping the committee members call and ask for my advice. Barring upsets this weekend, I have Alabama, Ohio State, Clemson and Michigan even though Michigan lost twice in the past three weeks. They clearly are the four top teams to me, but I’ll learn to live with it if the committee takes Washington over Michigan.

Perhaps you notice a prominent local team missing.

Sorry, Penn State and its fans.

The Nittany Lions won’t have a chance to make the final four — and shouldn’t — unless Clemson loses to Virginia Tech Saturday in the ACC championship and Washington loses to Colorado Friday in the Pac-12 title game.

Advertise with us

I get the argument that Penn State should go instead of Ohio State. I really do understand it. Penn State has had an incredible season, so good and so unexpected that James Franklin is a strong national coach of the year candidate. Penn State beat Ohio State, 24-21, Oct. 22 at Happy Valley. It also will be the Big Ten champion if it beats Wisconsin Saturday night in the conference title game. The committee has said it puts a heavy value on a league championship.

But when the most recent playoff poll was released a week ago — a new one comes out tonight — Ohio State was No. 2 and Penn State No. 7. Committee chairman Kirby Hocutt, athletic director at Texas Tech, said publicly the gap between the two teams was even greater because of Ohio State’s superior resume with wins against Oklahoma, Wisconsin and Nebraska. Since then, Ohio State beat No. 3 Michigan Saturday, 30-27, in double overtime in one of the great games in the series’ hallowed history. Penn State crushed three-win Michigan State at home Saturday. A win over Wisconsin hardly would be enough for Penn State to jump over Ohio State. There is no way it should.

After watching Penn State beat Ohio State in front of a white-out crowd of 107,280 at Beaver Stadium, I thought of what iconic hockey coach Herb Brooks told his U.S. Olympic team before it played the powerful Russians at the 1980 Lake Placid Games:

“If we played ‘em 10 times, they might win nine. But not this game. Not tonight.”

Penn State could play Ohio State nine more times and Ohio State might win all nine.

Advertise with us

I can’t even put Penn State ahead of Michigan in the playoff field despite Michigan’s tough loss to Ohio State and its one-point loss Nov. 12 at Iowa. Michigan blasted Penn State, 49-10, Sept. 24 in Ann Arbor. It might be good enough to beat Penn State 10 out of 10 times.

Clemson and Washington will earn their spots in the playoff field if they win their conference championship. They will be the only two one-loss teams from a power-five league with a conference title, not including unbeaten and No. 1 Alabama, which should handle Florida Saturday in the Southeastern Conference championship. That is hard to ignore. That’s why I will understand if Washington goes to the final four ahead of Michigan even though the Big Ten is much stronger than the Pac-12 with the Nos. 2, 5, 6 and 8 teams — Ohio State, Michigan, Wisconsin and Penn State — in this week’s Associated Press poll.

The story would be so much different for Penn State if it hadn’t lost to Pitt, 42-39, Sept. 10 at Heinz Field. At the time, that was an incredible win for Pitt against its most hated rival after a 16-year lapse in the series. Now, it seems like an even greater win because it should deny Penn State a chance to play for the national championship. Couple that with Pitt’s shocking 43-42 win Nov. 12 at Clemson as a three-touchdown underdog and, well, it just doesn’t get any better for a Pitt fan.

All is not lost for Penn State, though.

If it beats Wisconsin, it could end up in the Rose Bowl, likely against Colorado. If it loses, it could go to the Cotton Bowl to play undefeated Western Michigan.

Advertise with us

Regardless, this season long will be remembered as one of the most amazing seasons in Penn State history.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.