Don’t let anyone tell you there is nothing positive to say about Francisco Liriano, the Pirates’ highest-paid player and biggest disappointment.

Liriano is a heck of a hitter, his .300 batting average this season 59 points better than Andrew McCutchen’s .241 average, better than all of the team’s regular position players but Starling Marte.

What?

You didn’t enjoy the majestic home run that Liriano hit into the center-field topiary Tuesday night at PNC Park off former Cy Young winner Felix Hernandez?

Advertise with us

I guess not.

You’re right, the Pirates aren’t paying Liriano nearly $13.7 million to be a hitter.

That’s the problem.

You might argue McCutchen is the biggest reason the Pirates are facing the difficult challenge of having to climb over three teams to make the playoffs for the fourth consecutive season. It’s a reasonable argument, especially on the morning after McCutchen took another 0 for 4. I get that he’s the face of the franchise and has been one of the game’s best players, a former National League MVP. But he is not anything close to that now. He is hurting the team as its No. 3 hitter. It’s time Hurdle sets aside ego and does what’s right for the club by moving McCutchen down in the lineup.

But I’m still saying Liriano has been the worst underachiever. He gave the Pirates no chance in a 7-4 loss to Seattle on a night when Hernandez didn’t look anything like King Felix and was very beatable.

Advertise with us

Have we seen that before from Liriano or what?

The Pirates can get that kind of performance from Jeff Locke for a heck of a lot less money.

“I’ve got to look at some tape,” Hurdle said. “I don’t have the answers right now. I saw enough in 3⅓ innings to know it wasn’t right.”

Once again, Liriano had no command. So much for the progress he made in his previous start against Milwaukee Thursday night when he struck out 13 and didn’t walk a batter. Just 10 pitches into this start he had walked two and thrown a wild pitch. Thirty-four of his 72 pitches were balls. When he did throw a strike, the Mariners hit rockets, including home runs in the third inning by Franklin Gutierrez and Kyle Seager. Liriano left after getting one out in the fourth, giving up seven runs on eight hits and four walks. It’s fair to think he wasn’t thinking about his long home run when he handed the ball to Hurdle.

“I didn’t see him get into a really consistent rhythm out on the mound,” Hurdle said. “Obviously, he couldn’t get much down in the zone. When he got in the zone, it was up. Pretty much with all three pitches. That just takes you to bad place. When you’re not ahead and you’re not down, it’s hard up here.”

Advertise with us

Adding to the frustration was that Liriano blew a big lead for the third time in his past seven starts. He couldn’t hold a 5-1 lead after two innings against San Francisco June 22 and a 4-0 lead after one inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers June 27. This time, he wasted a 3-0 lead after one inning and a 4-1 lead after two. Those are brutal losses. If the Pirates had won those three games, they would be in control of a wild card. As it is, they have a glaring need for a starting pitcher with Monday’s trade deadline quickly approaching.

It’s a shame.

A productive Liriano would be so much better than anything the Pirates could get in a trade without drastically overpaying.

I keep saying Liriano will find his game and lead the Pirates back to the playoffs. He keeps making me look like a fool. But I have to admit I’m looking forward to his next start Sunday in Milwaukee. I’m excited to see what’s coming next.

I just hope Liriano stays in the game long enough to get more than one at-bat.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.