They say it’s true, not just in sports, but in life. You get what you pay for.
Not always.
Do you realize Francisco Liriano is making almost $3 million more this baseball season than Jake Arrieta?
Unfortunately, the Pirates aren’t getting their money’s worth from Liriano and his $13.67 million salary. The same is true of Andrew McCutchen and his $13 million pay. The narrative around town is owner Bob Nutting’s cheap ways are why the Pirates struggled at times through the first half. There might be some truth to that, but let’s put the blame where it really belongs. It’s not about what Nutting isn’t paying. It’s about what he isn’t getting for his dollars. Liriano and McCutchen — the Pirates’ two highest-paid players — have been the two biggest disappointments. They haven’t earned their money.
Liriano gets a chance to start resurrecting his season tonight when the Pirates resume play after the All-Star break in Washington against the Nationals. He has to be better in the second half if only because he can’t be worse. His earned-run average is 5.15, up from 3.38 last season. His WHIP is 1.62, up from 1.21. He leads baseball with 58 walks in 92⅔ innings.
The Pirates won Liriano’s past two starts after losing eight of his previous nine, but he hardly impressed in those two games, going five innings in each. That’s hardly enough for a rotation that averaged 4.9 innings with a 6.53 ERA in the previous 25 games.
“One of the biggest things is Frankie has a tendency to try to improve his pitch in the course of the game, which gets him into trouble,” pitching coach Ray Searage said. “It’s about executing the pitch and trusting your ability and the stuff and talent that you have instead of trying to make the fastball go at a higher velocity, trying to make the slider go with a quicker break, trying to make the changeup dance more. Just be consistent and compete in the zone.”
Liriano really will have to fight the urge tonight to try to do much. Stephen Strasburg gets the start for the Nationals. He’s 12-0 with a 2.62 ERA and 1.01 WHIP.
It’s easier to feel good about McCutchen in the second half. He was good last weekend — at least offensively — against the Chicago Cubs, attacking the ball like he used to and going 6 for 12 with two home runs and six RBIs. Still, his batting average is .247, down from .292 last season and .314 in 2014. His OPS is .745, down from .889 last season and .952 in 2014.
“It’s vintage Andrew,” Clint Hurdle gushed Sunday after McCutchen’s big weekend. “This is nothing new. We’ve seen more of this than we have the other …
“I think he’s going to get hot and stay hot.”
I won’t argue with Hurdle on that point. Before this season, McCutchen was the biggest bargain in baseball for four years. There’s reason to think he’ll hit much better in the second half. Rest from the All-Star break should benefit him more than most players. He had been playing with a bad heel and a bad thumb that he said impacted his swing.
But McCutchen needs to improve more than just his offense. I disagree strongly with Hurdle about McCutchen’s defense. Hurdle said last weekend that he ahs never seen McCutchen play better in center field. I’ve never seen him play worse. In the game Sunday, he could have made two plays — one on a ball hit over his head, the other on a ball in front of him — but didn’t make the catch either time. The Cubs scored two runs as a result.
McCutchen doesn’t seem to run nearly as well. That’s evident in the field and on the bases. He has just two stolen bases. Starling Marte has 30, by comparison. The Pirates want McCutchen to pick his spots on the bases to save his body the abuse, but two stolen bases through 89 games?
Despite the struggles of Liriano and McCutchen, the Pirates are 46-43, still a legitimate playoff threat. They trail the Cubs by 7½ games in the National League Central Division after being 15 back on June 20. They are 1½ games behind the New York Mets and Miami Marlins and ½-game back of the St. Louis Cardinals in the race for the league’s second wild-card slot.
“I like the grit that we have. Always have,” Hurdle said. “I love the belief in that clubhouse. I love the way we go about the game and the noise in the dugout. I love the energy that we bring every day. We never count ourselves out.”
Hurdle mentioned the return of Gerrit Cole, who will start Saturday night against the Nationals. He also mentioned Francisco Cervelli, who should come off the disabled list sooner rather than later.
“We’ve got some things coming back our way,” Hurdle said.
It’s true, all true.
Now, if the Pirates can just get Liriano and McCutchen back to what they were …
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.