You know what they say about opinions, right? They are like noses. Everybody has one.

The Penguins are one win against the San Jose Sharks from lifting the Stanley Cup. A lot of us want to beat the rush and pick their best candidate for the Conn Smythe Trophy, which goes to the MVP of the NHL postseason. The problem is it’s almost impossible to select just one. If you ask five hockey experts, they will give you five different choices. The Penguins will tell you that’s hardly a problem at all.

I’ve got Murray in the lead.

By late Thursday night, if the Penguins win Game 5 against the Sharks at Consol Energy Center, that could change.

Advertise with us

It could be Sidney Crosby or Phil Kessel or Kris Letang or Nick Bonino.

It’s too close to call.

It’s no surprise Crosby, Kessel and Letang are on the Smythe short list, but Murray and Bonino?

You say you predicted Murray would step in for injured Marc-Andre Fleury and have the Penguins so close to the Cup that they almost can taste drinking from it? That, along the way, Murray would outplay the New York Rangers’ Henrik Lundqvist, Washington’s Braden Holtby, Tampa Bay’s Andrei Vasilevskiy and, to this point, San Jose’s Martin Jones?

You say you predicted Bonino would have 17 points, tied for second-most on the Penguins with Crosby and Evgeni Malkin? That he would score, arguably, the team’s two biggest goals of the playoffs, in overtime in Game 6 against Washington in the second round and late in Game 1 against the Sharks?

Advertise with us

I hope you are playing the Powerball.

“I think it goes to show you that you can never predict what’s going to happen,” Murray said.

It all started for Murray in Game 3 against the Rangers in the first round. In his first NHL playoff game — “At MSG, no less!” he said — he made 16 saves to lead the Penguins to a 3-1 win. He made 31 saves in Game 4 in a 5-0 shutout. He has kept on winning, going 14-5 with a 2.09 goals-against average and .925 save percentage. If he gets that one more win against the Sharks, he will tie the NHL record for most postseason wins by a rookie.

Murray was at his best in Game 3 against Washington when he made 47 saves in a 3-2 win. He became the top Smythe candidate for me with his terrific 23-save performance in the 3-1 win Monday night in Game 4 against the Sharks. That came after he was beaten for a bad goal by San Jose’s Joel Ward in a 3-2 overtime loss in Game 3. It continued Murray’s streak of bouncing back after a bad goal or a shaky game. He is 6-0 in games after losses. He did his best work after being benched for Fleury for the third period of Game 4 and all Game 5 against Tampa Bay in the Eastern Conference final. He stepped back in to win Games 6 and 7.

You don’t think they’re changing the name of Murray Avenue in Squirrel Hill Thursday to Matt Murray Avenue for no reason, do you?

Advertise with us

“From day one, I’ve just been trying to have fun through this,” Murray said. “It’s been an absolute blast so far.”

Bonino says the same thing. He has done everything for the Penguins.

Driving the “HBK” line, which includes Carl Hagelin and Kessel, the three producing 19 goals and 53 points in these playoffs. Blocking shots, 18 in the first four games against the Sharks. Winning faceoffs, the three late in Game 7 against Tampa Bay stand out. Killing penalties.

“We think he’s a terrific hockey player,” coach Mike Sullivan said.

One or two people have said that about Crosby, as well. He was the best player in the Rangers’ series, scoring perhaps the biggest goal when he deflected in a Kessel pass in Game 3 to wipe out a 1-0 Rangers lead. He had three winning goals in the Tampa Bay series, including in overtime in Game 2 after the Lightning had won Game 1. He was absolutely brilliant in the first two games against the Sharks.

Advertise with us

“Inspiring,” Sullivan said.

Kessel has been the Penguins’ most consistent player, scoring three goals and six points against the Rangers, two goals and six points against the Capitals, four goals and six points against the Lightning and one goal and two assists against the Sharks. You had to like him in the clinching Game 6 against Washington when he scored the first two goals and assisted on Bonino’s overtime winner. You had to really like him in Game 4 against the Sharks when he assisted on goals by Ian Cole and Evgeni Malkin.

“I love Phil’s overall game,” Sullivan said. “He’s such a scoring threat offensively that I think sometimes his passing ability flies under the radar. He passes the puck as well as he can score. But what his teammates admire and respect and what his coaching staff certainly does is his commitment away from the puck and his play at both ends of the rink. He’s a complete player right now.”

The indefatigable Letang has played more minutes than any of the Penguins, at least 27 minutes in 15 of his past 16 games. “Monster minutes,” Sullivan called them. Letang has no choice with Trevor Daley out since his left ankle was broken in Game 4 against Tampa Bay. Letang and the other defensemen have done a remarkable job to help hold the Sharks to a total of seven goals. That’s an average of 1.75 per game for a team that came into the final averaging 3.5 goals.

To recap, I’ve got Murray, Crosby and Kessel as my top Smythe choices, in that order. Any of the three could win it with a star performance in the clinching game against the Sharks, be it Thursday night or in Game 6 Sunday night or even in Game 7 next Wednesday night.

Advertise with us

Of course, the Penguins have to get that fourth win.

“I trust our leadership,” Sullivan said. “I think our guys are very grounded. We have to try to do our best to ignore some of the noise surrounding the group. We still have a lot of work ahead of us.”

In other words, it’s OK for us to predict a Smythe winner as long as the players aren’t looking that far ahead.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the ”Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.