TAMPA, Fla. — The Penguins lost a playoff game and a valuable defenseman Friday night and left Amalie Arena with a potential dreaded goaltender controversy. Other than that, they had a wonderful spring evening on the shore of Tampa Bay.
No one should have expected Game 4 of the Eastern Conference final to be easy. The Tampa Bay Lighting is too good of team to roll over and die. Maybe the Penguins were better in the third period of a Game 1 loss, won Game 2 in overtime and overwhelmed the Lightning in Game 3. The Tampa Bay club knows how to counterpunch. It made it to the Stanley Cup final last season. Enough said.
“We got embarrassed at home in Game 3,” Lightning coach Jon Cooper said. “Let’s make a stand.”
The Penguins expected it, but no one in their room could have guessed the night would be this bad. The Lightning built a 4-0 lead after two periods and hung on for a 4-3 win to turn the series into a best-of-three, beginning with Game 5 Sunday night at Consol Energy Center. Defenseman Trevor Daley left midway through the second period with what appeared to be a serious left leg injury after taking a clean check from the Lightning’s Ryan Callahan. He will be hard to replace because of the speed and poise he brings. Marc-Andre Fleury, who hadn’t played in 50 days, replaced Matt Murray in net at the start of third period and stopped all seven shots he faced.
So who starts Game 5?
This probably will come as a shock to you, but Penguins coach Mike Sullivan wasn’t saying.
Read More
“I haven’t even given it any thought at this point, really.”
I’m saying it should be Fleury.
If anything good came out of this rotten night for the Penguins, it’s that Fleury was able to get some playing time. He won’t be cold off the bench if Sullivan picks him for Game 5. That was my hesitation to go to Fleury earlier in these playoffs. Fleury hadn’t been in goal since March 31, since beating Nashville for his 35th win of the season and experiencing concussion symptoms the next day. It was his second concussion of the season.
Murray, who turns 22 Wednesday, took the job and was the surprise story of the Penguins’ series wins against the New York Rangers and the Washington Capitals. He went into Game 4 against the Lightning with a 9-3 record, a 2.13 goals-against average and .928 save percentage.
Sullivan came awfully close to replacing Murray with Fleury after the first period of Game 2 after Murray allowed a soft goal to Jonathan Drouin that tied the score, 2-2. Murray rewarded that faith by shutting out the Lightning the rest of that game and by winning Game 3, 4-2.
But Sullivan was right to turn to Fleury after a second period in which Murray allowed a power-play goal to Drouin and a chip-in goal by Tyler Johnson for the Lightning’s 4-0 lead. If nothing else, the Penguins needed to change the pace of the game. They needed a lift. They rallied around Fleury and got goals from Phil Kessel, Evgeni Malkin and Chris Kunitz on the power play to pull within 4-3 with 6:52 to play. Much to their regret, they couldn’t get the tying goal against Tampa’s 21-year-old goalie, Andrei Vasilevskiy.
“He’s a gamer, the kid,” Cooper said.
“It’s hard to chase a four-goal deficit,” Sullivan said. “We were not the more determined team for the first half of the game. We didn’t play the way we’ve been playing. We responded in the third period, but there just wasn’t enough time.”
With much of the action in the Tampa Bay end, Fleury wasn’t tested much. He did make good saves on Vladislav Namestnikov and Nikita Kucherov.
“The more it went on, the better I felt,” Fleury said. “It was good to get used to the traffic and the speed of the game again. I knew it was going to quicker and more intense than practice. I felt better at the end of the period than I did at the beginning.”
Murray, for his part, also sounded confident after the game. He was fairly spectacular in the first two periods and, almost single-handedly, kept the Lightning from ringing up a touchdown or more. The Lightning scored a fortunate goal on a Callahan deflection just 27 seconds in and never looked back. Its second goal by Andrej Sustr came after a defense breakdown when Daley and Ben Lovejoy got caught on the other side of the ice. They fired 18 shots at Murray in the first period after getting fewer than 10 in seven of the first nine periods of the series.
“I thought I played well,” Murray said. “It was just a weird game, from getting banged behind my net by own D-man [Brian Dumoulin] to goals going off their shin pads. Their last two goals were off brutal bounces. I don’t know that I could have done much with those. I thought I was in control most of the game.”
Neither Fleury nor Murray would speculate about the Game 5 starter. No one in the Penguins’ room did.
“We’re more than confident that either one will do the job for us,” Sidney Crosby said. “Absolutely. 100 percent.”
I’ll say it again.
It’s time for Fleury.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.